• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss how ‘A Woman’s Question’ by Adelaide Anne Procter and ‘Valentine’ by Carol Anne Duffy explore how women of different periods view their relationships

Extracts from this document...


GCSE Coursework Essay-Poetry Discuss how 'A Woman's Question' by Adelaide Anne Procter and 'Valentine' by Carol Anne Duffy explore how women of different periods view their relationships 'A Woman's Question' was written in the 19th Century and 'Valentine' is a modern poem which was written in the 1990s. This fact is fairly obvious from not only the content of the poems, but the style in which they are written, too. It also affects how the women generally view their relationships. Both show evidence of how society viewed women, and despite the different times in which they lived, they both rebel against traditional ideas of the time in certain ways. Procter and Duffy view their respective relationships very differently. Procter seems to be quite insecure about her partner, and wants to know whether he is going to leave her, and also talks about how she wants him to be completely honest with her. Duffy on the other hand, is very realistic about her relationship and not over-romantic. This does not mean that she does not think love is important; she just does not depend on her partner and does not talk about love using elaborate, romantic phrases. ...read more.


This could also mean she is showing that she is challenging expectations of the then current time (19th Century) with her poem and her beliefs, and showing this through the stanzaic form. Another way in which Procter challenges expectations is in her use of imperatives. The style of writing in this poem is quite gentle, but there a few commanding phrases, like "Speak now", which do not fit with the rest of the poem. This effect may surprise the reader, who may have initially thought it was a poem written in a fairly gentle style, e.g. romantic and old-fashioned wording is used. In 'Valentine', Duffy does not follow a specific form, and this is referred to as free verse, nor does she use much rhyming language, which means the poem is not very rhythmic. This style could show that it is a more modern poem-less passionate and exaggerated. This could mean that Duffy, too, is challenging expectations, only she does it in a more obvious way. Her view of love is not at all what someone might expect a woman's to be. She uses a lot of short statements, and imperatives, such as "Take it". ...read more.


I think that 'A Woman's Question' is basically Procter questioning whether her partner is as ready to commit to her 'Fate' as she is to his. I do not get the impression that she believes in fate, and everything happening for a reason, which is why she does not want him, if he deserts her, to blame it on 'fate'. I think she believes in making the future happen for herself, partly because she is making this huge decision for herself, and not leaving it up to him or fate. It may even be an 'illicit' or 'forbidden' affair, which maybe why she is so worried. Valentine, I think, is more about the different layers of love, and the complexities. Duffy is also questioning whether he's ready to commit to her, but instead of fixating on this one question, like Procter in 'A Woman's Question', she proceeds to tell him about the bad and good points of love. The end of the poem is not particularly final (it ends with 'cling to your knife'), as it is in 'A Woman's Question', but instead almost leaves more time for him to make up his mind, almost like she has not finished talking to him. She ends with a statement, but it is not one commanding for him to make his mind up about whether he wants to commit to her. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Carol Ann Duffy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Carol Ann Duffy essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How has Duffy used classical myths in order to comment on the nature of ...

    5 star(s)

    contrasts with the 'golden twig' and 'pear', in the hand of her husband. The fact that the simile 'like a light bulb' runs to the end of the line, and allows the one worded sentence 'On' to be in place also gives further emphasis and importance to it.

  2. By close study of "Valentine" and "I Wouldn't Thank You for a Valentine" shows ...

    particular does this by using her own conceit and in doing so describes a wedding ring as "platinum" because it would be worth more than gold or silver, although not traditional. Many of the things that men may do to try and woo a woman are included, but in the negative.

  1. Carol Ann Duffy explores different types of relationships in 'Valentine' and 'Before you were ...

    'The decade ahead of my loud possessive yell was the best one, eh?' She uses a rhetorical question. She doesn't really want her mum to confirm that statement. In her imagination she sees her mother clattering in high-heeled shoes 'I remember my hand in those high heeled red shoes relics

  2. Compare and Contrast Havisham and Anne Hathaway by Carol Ann Duffy

    The fact that Duffy has used an oxymoron so early in the poem suggests that she is trying to put a huge amount of emphasis on the conflicting emotions. The speaker uses both hateful and loving words which suggest that she has been hurt by love.

  1. Compare 3 poems by Carol Ann Duffy in which she shows us that things ...

    These shoes are 'relics' of that exciting time in the memory of Carol Ann Duffy. She must have thought of them as religious, saintly objects because 'relic' actually means: "a part of a deceased holy person's body or belongings kept as an object of reverence" (The Concise Oxford Dictionary), proving that she loved her mother very much.

  2. "My Grandmother" by Elizabeth Jennings and "In Mrs Tilcher's Class" by Carol Anne Duffy

    Like "My Grandmother" Duffy describes clearly and well in metaphors so you get the idea of exactly it was like within Mrs Tilchers class. Both poems are very similar feel by both ends of the poems a dull, dark and weary mood yet active with both poets expressing their feelings clearly.

  1. Discuss the ways in which Carol Ann Duffy explores the theme of alienation in ...

    The word "kill," is also repeated a lot, the speaker feels under appreciated because of the treatment he is receiving from others. He does not want to be isolated anymore and therefore feels he needs to 'play the role of god' to achieve some sort of status so that he is recognised.

  2. Duffy sometimes creates a character for the speaker of her poem - What methods ...

    It seems to the reader as if this point has been reached, and the receiver of the onion seems hesitant and reluctant to accept it. She says the onion and therefore the relationship "shrink to a wedding ring" and then she goes onto say, "if you like" implying that she

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work