• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss Miller(TM)s portrayal of John Procter(TM)s relationship with Abigail and Elizabeth with particular reference to acts one and two of The Crucible.(TM)

Extracts from this document...


Discuss Miller's portrayal of John Procter's relationship with Abigail and Elizabeth with particular reference to acts one and two of 'The Crucible.' 'The Crucible,' was set in 1692 in a Puritan society and religion was vital to every day to day life in Salem. John Proctor has two very different relationships, one with his wife, Elizabeth Proctor, and one with a young seventeen year old girl, Abigail. As committing adultery is one of the Ten Commandments, John and Abigail committed a serious crime in the eyes of that society. Their relationship is a very passionate one in contrast to Proctor's and Elizabeth's relationship which is very forced in this act. One of the ways that Miller portrays the different relationships is through the language between John and Abigail shows anger, heat and passion, for example when Abigail mentions the fact that he was, 'sweating like a stallion,' whenever she was near him. This shows us that even though there is anger in the relationship, the passion is still there and there definitely was a connection between them even if there is not one now. ...read more.


As well as there being no warmth in the relationship, there is no forgiveness and the phrase that John says illustrates this. Another way in which Miller portrays the different relationships is through the stage directions. In act one with John and Elizabeth their actions symbolise, again, heat and passion, 'feverishly looking into his eyes.' Abigail shows most of the passion in the relationship and provokes him when she talks, 'tauntingly.' But John moves her, 'firmly,' out of the way. He knows that there is still a connection and there is a lot of contact between them both. Abigail is, 'grasping his hand,' because she does not want him to go, she demonstrates more contact. It is a meaningful conversation complete with meaningful actions, unlike with John and Elizabeth. Here in act one, Abigail, 'clutches him desperately,' and gets, 'anger,' in her voice a lot. This shows us that they are both not afraid to shows their emotions in front of one another and that they have an extremely interesting relationship. Stage directions between John and Elizabeth are much more reserved and secretive. ...read more.


The house is described as, 'low, dark,' and the living room is, 'empty.' This represents the fact there is no effort being put into the relationship, especially by Elizabeth, as John has been away for, 'eight days,' he comes back to a cold empty house that Elizabeth has kept. In the 1600's it was the woman's role to look after the house and keep it welcoming. On the whole the relationships that John Procter has with the two women are shown in very different ways in acts one and two. Act one between John and Abigail, there is a lot of heat and passion shown through their language and actions. But in act two, between John and Elizabeth, the atmosphere between them is demonstrated as cold and plenty of tension is shown. Their actions shows that there is no, or very little connection, like when John goes to kiss her she does not return it and there is a small amount of contact. The scenes are placed close to each other so that the differences are clear and that there is a clear contrast in the scenes and relationships. At this point in, 'The crucible,' we are convinced that John and Abigail's relationship would be the best one, even though the social rules are against them. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The Crucible - How does Arthur Miller use dramatic devices in Act 1 to ...

    3 star(s)

    Arthur Miller chose Tituba's speech so that it is apparent that she is trying to fit in with the community. This is shown by confessing and trying to be part of the community by mimicking other characters ways and words she escapes her death.

  2. How does Miller present the relationship between Proctor and Elizabeth in Acts 2 and ...

    Proctor wants more flavour in his food, which suggests he also needs more flavour and excitement in his life; whereas Elizabeth has a plainer taste, and this therefore shows how her life is lacking flavour and quite bland. The extremities of their personalities seem to be separating Proctor and Elizabeth further and further apart.

  1. The role of the Inspector in 'An Inspector Calls.'

    I think the mystery surrounding the Inspector makes a big difference to the story because it gives it a distinguishing feature that would have been missing if this twist was not included. The play is written in a style whereby there are twists and revelations whenever the story gets comfortable

  2. The Crubcible - John Proctor Essay

    Ultimately, this fails when Mary Warren turns on him and he is forced to admit his adultery, putting aside his dignity in order to rescue his wife. 'I have known her [Abigail], sir'. This shows a heroic quality in Proctor as he is putting the well-being of others before himself.

  1. How may I live without my name? I have given you my soul, leave ...

    Proctor then has to go and clear his lumber and as he leaves he says that he's heard of Hale's reputation as a very sensible man and asks if he would leave some of it in Salem. Speaking of reputation when Hale greets Rebecca Nurse he commends her of her

  2. Diverse Influences (The Chrysalids John Wyndham)

    I'm telling you that nobody - nobody really knows what the true image is" (64). Using his wisdom, Uncle Axel is able to provide David with an ethical approach to their existence, rather than his father's corrupt and stereotypical beliefs.

  1. one girl one dream

    a sash saying 'MAYOR' addressed the men by saying "you aren't doing this fast enough! Any day now the builders will be here with the housing bricks, I want my mansion build quickly." The shortest man then said "but what about the animals, isn't this a big enough area for your house?"

  2. the crucible in earley 1950

    I believe that this is a significant choice miller has made. The small room suggests that the accusations take place with more force as if they are bouncing and echoing of the walls of the small room. "I saw Goody Booth with the Devil!", this adds to the power of the final accusation.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work