• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss Nelly Dean's account of Heathcliff's Arrival in terms of what it reveals about the contrasts Between Hindley and Catherine and what it Reveals about Heathcliff's character As a boy.

Extracts from this document...


Gregory Andrews 12S Discuss Nelly Dean's account of Heathcliff's Arrival in terms of what it reveals about the contrasts Between Hindley and Catherine and what it Reveals about Heathcliff's character As a boy. In Chapter four, Nelly Dean begins her narration of the novel. Lockwood, who is still confined to his bed at the time, begins a conversation with Nelly that leads to her detailing the events of Catherine and Heathcliff's childhood, including Heathcliff's initial appearance at Wuthering Heights and the subsequent events leading to his inclusion into the family. Mr Earnshaw left on a business trip to Liverpool, promising to bring his children gifts on his return. When he does return he brings with him an orphan boy, Heathcliff. The children's hopes are dashed, as the presents that were promised to them have been broken or forgotten to accommodate Heathcliff. From early in the chapter we can tell that there is a definite dislike for Heathcliff on the part of Nelly, who has no real reason to dislike him except for a lack of tolerance and possible increase in workload. This comes across quite plainly in Nelly's narrative. Hindley and initially Cathy share this dislike for him, as he is leeching their father's attention from them. Heathcliff's initial description does not paint a positive image of him. ...read more.


This change is probably brought about by him having to adapt to a new environment, which is encouraged by him owning Earnshaw's favour over Hindley, which allows him to command some power. We learn that Earnshaw once had a son called Heathcliff who died at a young age, so when he chooses to call Heathcliff the same name, we get the distinct impression that Earnshaw's compassion for the child is not completely selfless. Heathcliff is essentially being used as a replacement, giving Earnshaw another chance to be a father to the son he lost. "...They had christened him 'Heathcliff'; it was the name of a son who died in childhood..." This means that he seems to greatly favour Heathcliff, as he doesn't want to see any flaw in Heathcliff, as in his eyes it reflects the same things on the son he lost, which he cannot cope with doing. "He took to Heathcliff strangely, believing all he said..." Heathcliff is not at all welcome in the eyes of Hindley who calls him a 'beggarly interloper', as if he is trying to usurp Hindley's position as Earnshaw's son, trying to steal his affections, to almost replace Hindley. As Earnshaw chooses not to fault Heathcliff, his aggression is in turn directed at Hindley, which leads to him harbouring a lot of resentment for both of them. ...read more.


Even at this young age he has much adoration for Cathy, priding her above others and not seeking to hurt her. He comes from a very empty background, both financially and emotionally, which would explain how his unique way of forming relationships with people in later life, especially with Cathy as he is able to focus all this pent up emotion on her, and he doesn't fully understand how to. His unfeeling behaviour to begin with is very uncharacteristic of any youth, especially Heathcliff, suggesting that his past life was hard, and it for a time, continued to be at Wuthering Heights. Once given the chance flourish he has the opportunity to vent this malice in the only way he knows how, like in later life. The contrast between Hindley and Cathy only begins to present itself when they accept that Heathcliff is going to be a staying with them. At this point they branch off in completely opposite directions. Cathy takes Heathcliff off on a much more positive route, becoming his friend and willing to accept him into the family. Hindley has a flatly negative response to him, and when he realises that he's going to be alone in his negative feelings, and often get punished for him, it instils bitterness in him. There is a deep felt hatred between the two of them, whereas there is a strong bond of friendship between him and Cathy, showing how different their personalities are, even though they are siblings. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Emily Bronte section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Emily Bronte essays

  1. 'Wuthering heights is a novel of great contrasts'.

    It is only when Catherine is taken into Thrushcross grange that she becomes more cultured ('they dried and combed her beautiful hair, and gave her a pair of enormous slippers.')

  2. In chapter 15 Nelly says "Far better that she should be dead than lingering ...

    However her actions towards Heathcliff show that she also hates him. She ignores him when he becomes a stable boy, leaving him with no one. She may also hate him because he is a threat to her e.g. if she falls in love with Heathcliff she will lose her security.

  1. Is Heathcliff someone you admire or detest? Discuss.

    speech about loosing Catherine to the Linton's, he remarks that "painting the house-front with Hindley's blood" would be one of his most satisfying pleasures. This is an incredibly violent thought for such a young person, and gives the reader an insight into his subconscious.

  2. "Nelly's personality and situation make her an ideal narrator," discuss

    I empathize with her humanity to admit her mistakes and wrong doings. This humanity makes her an ideal narrator, as she is not ashamed to change her opinion about certain characters because later she defends Heathcliff when Isabella complains that he is a monster: "Hush, Hush!

  1. Discuss the character of Catherine Earnshaw and your reaction to her and her importance ...

    Catherine and Heathcliff have an unusual type of love for one another; their love is more spiritual than physical. They talk about dying together rather than living together. They make love not by giving each other pleasure but by inflicting pain.

  2. How does Heathcliff's character develop

    After Cathy gets married to Edgar and after her death, Heathcliff becomes a vicious, lonely master. Words such as 'revenge', 'slaps', 'brutality', 'slitting up the flesh' and 'pain' show that Heathcliff has become vicious. Diction such as 'take any form', 'love' and 'broken...heart' show that Heathcliff becomes lonely.

  1. Comment on the roles of Major Petkoff and Catherine in 'Arms and the Man'.

    Moreover, Catherine is a character that does not only believe in heroic acts and romantic ideas, but is incredibly unaware that her husband is in the army due to his economic position and not to his admirable skills in the "art of war".

  2. 'The real tragedy of Catherine and Heathcliff is that their separation is brought about ...

    through such ways as personal relationships, appearance of characters, and even the setting. The division of classes is based on cultural, economic, and social differences, and it greatly affects the general behavior and actions of each character. The separation of Catherine and Heathcliff could be brought about by family because

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work