• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss The Similarities And Differences Between 'Billy Cart Hill' And 'Remembering Aunt Marie', Focusing On Language, Narrative Structure And Content.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss The Similarities And Differences Between 'Billy Cart Hill' And 'Remembering Aunt Marie', Focusing On Language, Narrative Structure And Content. 'Unreliable Memoirs' (by Clive James) and 'Remembering Aunt Marie' (by Grace Nichols) are both popular autobiographies written by well-known authors. We were asked to compare two random autobiographical extracts from the books and discuss the language, narrative structure and content of each. Billy Cart Hill, from the book 'Unreliable Memoirs' is one of many of Clive James' memories of growing up in Australia and getting into trouble. Remembering Aunt Marie is more descriptive but is just as amusing. Remembering Aunt Marie is Grace Nichol's memory of how she almost got into trouble by stealing her Aunt Marie's rosary, but luckily escaped by playing on her Aunt's Catholic faithfulness. In Billy Cart Hill, there is a woman, Mrs Branthwaite, who has a perfect garden which James describes 'like the cover of a seed catalogue,' so when James makes a train of 'Billy Carts' and they destroy the poppies by crashing into them, Mrs Branthwaite has to be taken away, speechless, by two police officers and the children scatter in all directions. ...read more.


I think this is because James uses exciting words like 'disastrously' and 'skidded' unlike Nichols's description where she doesn't use any outstanding words. The language used in Billy Cart Hill is significantly more exciting than the plain descriptive language used in Remembering Aunt Marie. Clive James puts rhetorical questions and suspense to good use in his book, he uses them so well that they create an exciting sense of tension, - 'Why did I ever suggest the Irene Street turn?' and 'I should have left it at that but got ambitious.' I think these sentences make the reader wonder, what's going to happen next? Likewise Grace Nichols also takes time to build up suspense - but in a different manner, 'I got the chance one day...' Nichols uses a lot of description, which makes the reader ask, what is it building up to? Also she uses certain words like, 'impatiently' and 'rushed,' this creates tension as well. Another technique Clive James uses is personification. ...read more.


In conclusion, despite the fact that both extracts are popular and high quality, I prefer Billy Cart Hill (by Clive James) to Remembering Aunt Marie (by Grace Nichols.) I like Billy Cart Hill because I feel more drawn towards his style of writing; I think this is because he uses a larger range of language skills such as similes, metaphors and hyperboles, while Remembering Aunt Marie uses straightforward language skills which are still enjoyable but not as exciting. My preference is also due to the narrative structure and content of the two extracts, - Billy Cart Hill goes almost straight into the main story whereas Remembering Aunt Marie takes a long time to set the scene very descriptively. Also, I think James has chosen to talk about an exciting subject, which I would rather read about, because although I can relate easily to Remembering Aunt Marie, I do not think she has chosen a very interesting topic to talk about. However, Billy Cart Hill does have some flaws, one of them being, that because he describes the poppies so carefully from the first paragraph, you know what's going to happen - the poppies get destroyed! ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Grace Nichols: Hurricane Hits England section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Grace Nichols: Hurricane Hits England essays

  1. How Does Grace Nichols Create a sense of Cultural Identity through her poetry?

    This shows that Nichols is not welcome in Europe and continues by saying that she does not want a 'quiet jerk tear wiping'. These comments about a European funeral all present Britain as being lifeless and dull whereas the Caribbean funeral is presented as positive, it says how there is

  2. What does the language of Grace Nichols’ have to tell us about her culture?

    The use of sibilance in 'sulphur' and 'springs' creates the fearsome aura of the situation of terror and imminent destruction. Another reference to the slaves being a part of nature themselves is how Nichols' has perceived the slaves as being thought of as insects: '"And we the rage growing like

  1. How does the poet use language, imagery and form to make their person expressive ...

    This is as if, she learns that she is living in one place and that earth is circular. It never stops turning because it goes round and round and round. In the poem the poet creates a feeling of homesickness by using certain words like 'old tongues'.

  2. What Do You Find Interesting About The Work Of Grace Nichols?

    Titles of poems can sometimes say a lot about a poem. 'Beauty' is a short simple title. If the reader had only got as far as the title, it could be presumed that it would be similar in content to the stereotypical views of beauty or about the scenery.

  1. How has Grace Nichols created a sense of other cultures in her poems 'Fat ...

    When she is tormented by the 'salesgals' she curses them in Swahili. This is because people won't understand what she is saying but it will also make her feel closer to her roots and her identity. The conclusion that the fat black woman creates about London is 'nothing much beyond size 14'.

  2. Many of the poems in the Anthology are concerned with origins. The poets explore ...

    'Blessing' is a religious word: blessings come from gods. A congregation can just mean 'a crowd of people', but its main meaning is 'a crowd of worshippers'. Stanza 3 refers to men, women and children, but stanza 4 focuses on the children alone, as the water pours over their small bones.

  1. An Analysis of a favourite Grace Nichols Poem - Fear.

    To want to go back to the Caribbean so much they must feel that blacks are unwanted and are not treat as equals. The theme in 'fear' continues throughout the poem because we can see it in the last two lines as well as the first two, - 'I think

  2. Hurricane - Grace Nichols

    When, in the 18th and 19th centuries, the people of Africa were transported to the Caribbean to be sold as slaves, they carried their old religion with them. At first the gods were worshipped secretly, but in the 20th century they have emerged as symbols of the African side of Caribbean identity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work