• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the view that when Miller wrote the 'A View from the Bridge', he created a tragic play which suggests that true justice does not exist and the law is often inadequate.

Extracts from this document...


A View from the Bridge - Arthur Miller Michael Cawdry Discuss the view that when Miller wrote the 'A View from the Bridge', he created a tragic play which suggests that true justice does not exist and the law is often inadequate. Arthur Miller wrote 'A View from the Bridge' in 1955 as a one-act play, it was later made into a two-act play in 1956. This play was written under the influence of Miller's experiences and stories told to him. This play is based on 1940's Brooklyn, when Miller was particularly interested in the lives and work of longshoremen and dockworkers. Miller described it as a 'dangerous and mysterious world at the water's edge that drama and literature had never touched' He then describes it as 'a desert beyond the law'. Poorly paid workers who in many cases were illegal immigrants populated the docks. These people had, along with Miller's parents, come to America in the hope of work, wealth and security, which their home country couldn't guarantee. Arthur Miller wrote the play shortly after the end of the McCarthy era, a period when most of American society was worried that communist sympathisers had held government positions, and Joe McCarthy took advantage of these fears, accusing prominent Americans of harbouring or being sympathisers. Miller knew of Americans with Communist ideas, and refused to name them before the Un-American Activities Council (UAAC) ...read more.


Lawyers are seen as rational, a man of justice, honesty and a judge of character. In my opinion Alfieri is similar to the Friar in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, a fatherly figure at times. Alfieri 'knows' Eddie slightly "I represented his father in an accident case some years before and I was acquainted with the family in a casual way." Because of this, Alfieri secretly treats Eddie as a relative of his own always warning him and advising him. But Alfieri is not always independent on his own thoughts "I even went to a certain wise old woman and I told her, and she only nodded and said 'pray for him' and so I waited here. But as Eddie contemplates the betrayal, Alfieri reads Eddie's mind and can see what fate Eddie has got so warns him of the consequences if he tells Immigration. Both Catherine and Beatrice are likeable characters, but, Beatrice is much more stable in herself. Whereas the young Catherine is uncertain about things, Beatrice is much more mature and has a clear view of matters, including law and justice. She only shows her fear for the law when the Immigration Officers arrive. She holds her head in her hands and reflects on the fact that she, to a certain extent, put Marco and Rodolpho in this situation and the fate they await. ...read more.


Eddie needed his respect back. He is also, once stabbed, seen as a 'fool' by the others (neighbours) and Marco, for thinking he can get back his name and reputation. But Beatrice and Catherine's immediate reaction is to hold and comfort him, as though he was a shrine. Marco's attitude to the law is that he did not think of the law as THE LAW, more as vague rules that aren't enforced, guidelines more than anything 'Where is the law? Is it in a book, is it written down?' He becomes disillusioned with the law as soon as the Immigration officers take him in. He finally realises that the law is completely against him and that he will have to leave America again, and the money from his job in the dockyard will cease when Alfieri explains his situation directly to him. Marco then makes his decision to confront Eddie. Ironically, when Marco stabbed Eddie it was technically self-defence, putting him on the correct side of the law. Rodolpho is in love with America from the minute he steps off the boat, even commenting of Eddie's house 'And they said they were poor!' The law does not play a role in his life until the Immigration officers arrive. By this time he has a promise of marriage from Catherine, so therefore the law does not necessarily apply to him. He simply carries on as normal. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. A View from the Bridge: Eddie and Catherine's Relationship

    He only cares for himself, because he loves her so much he does not want to let her go, and so is hurting her. This shows how he believes that his actions to keep hold of Catherine are for her good but really he is selfishly attempting to imprison her in his life for his own good.

  2. Explore the role of Alfieri in Miller's 'A View from the Bridge.'

    When "Alfieri rises with new anxiety" with "a tougher tone...calling desperately" it implies that no matter what he does or say, he is still helpless in stopping the outcome of Eddie's hamartia even if he does lower his tone to drop vocal hints.

  1. How does Arthur Miller use the character of Alfieri in A View from the ...

    Alfieri is again seen to be the pacifist after Eddie has reported Marco and Rodolfo. Marco says 'In my country he would be dead now.' This implies that the Italians would have taken the law into their own hands and killed him for betraying his family.

  2. Explore the way in which Arthur Miller presents justice in 'A View From The ...

    At first all the characters are horrified at the story of Vinny. He had caused great injustice to his family for snitching on his uncle. He portrayed betrayal to all his family especially his uncle. Miller prepares the audience mentally about the ending of the play by mentioning the irony of Eddie's horror at Vinny's betrayal.

  1. 'A View from the Bridge' is often described as a "Modern Greek Tragedy." Discuss ...

    He tells them a true story about Vinnie B, how he betrayed his family by snitching to the authorities about the illegal immigrants his family was hiding. As a result Vinnie gets treated like a foreigner in his own family, and gets thrown down the stairs and has to leave the house despite being the youngest.

  2. 'A View from the Bridge' - review

    Girls don't have to wear black dresses to be strict. Know what I mean?" Although Eddie did not absolutely loose his temper he has forewarned Rodolfo very frankly in front of the whole of household that he should keep his distance from Catherine.

  1. A View From the Bridge - The whole of this play involves symbolism, on ...

    he is in he is drunk it excuses him, but being drunk he relieves his thoughts and kisses Catherine on the mouth, leaving her in shock and in tears. But as Rudolph attacks Eddie he too kisses him, proving to Catherine what Rudolpho's sexuality is.

  2. "A View From the Bridge". The main themes in this play are justice and ...

    There is a feeling that if people always abide by the law then they will have to "settle for half". Alfieri seems to be saying that the law is often incapable of satisfying everybody. Eddie tries to force Alfieri to give him his kind of justice.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work