• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the ways in which Jonathon Swift and George Orwell create a sense of disgust in the reader in 'Gulliver's Travels', 'A Modest Proposal' and 'How The Poor Die'. Whose approach do you find more effective and why.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss the ways in which Jonathon Swift and George Orwell create a sense of disgust in the reader in 'Gulliver's Travels', 'A Modest Proposal' and 'How The Poor Die'. Whose approach do you find more effective and why. Firstly, when looking at these three pieces, the authors' reasons and objectives for disgusting the reader should be explored. Both Orwell and Swift were seeking social reform, but Swift chose a more extreme method of persuasion. In 'Gulliver's Travels' Swift uses the disgusting to make the reader look at how the supposedly civilised Gulliver is behaving, and question their own actions and society. In 'A Modest Proposal', Swift is writing in order to persuade the reader to consider a proper answer to the Irish question, disgusting the reader so they realise just how dire the situation actually is. However, in 'How The Poor Die', Orwell is writing initially to inform the reader of the situation in the Paris hospital, though indirectly influencing their thoughts. Orwell and Swift disgust the reader in different ways: Swift uses the scatological to repulse the reader whereas, Orwell uses less physical, more emotional ways to disgust his audience. Orwell tugs at the emotions of his readers by discussing how people were 'dying among strangers'. ...read more.

Middle

He even talks of their 'claws' and 'fore-feet'. 'How The Poor Die' and 'A Modest Proposal' both deal with socially taboo or unpleasant subjects that would repulse readers. In 'A Modest Proposal', Swift discusses everything from sex to domestic violence, abortion to miscarriages, none of which people were open about at his time of writing. He says that men wouldn't 'offer to beat or kick [their wives] during their time of pregnancy for fear of a miscarriage'. Orwell's writing is about death, a topic that would not usually have been discussed in the conversational manner he uses. The use of hyperbole in Swift's writing adds to the sense of repulsion felt by the reader. In 'A Modest Proposal', he doesn't simply state that we should eat babies, but goes on and on with more gruesome ideas. He suggests recipes and even recommends 'flaying the carcass' to make 'admirable gloves... and summer boots', all of which is simply revolting to the reader. In 'Gulliver's Travels' he goes into explicit detail about the most disgusting of bodily functions as in Lilliput where he cannot resist putting in that his faeces was 'carried off in wheelbarrows'. Orwell doesn't exaggerate in 'How The Poor Die' but simply emphasises and reiterates his point on the disgraceful lack of respect shown for the lives of the poor. ...read more.

Conclusion

Near the end of 'How The Poor Die', Orwell refers to the poor having 'their teeth extracted with no anaesthetic'. This would strike a chord with many readers as a huge number of people will have had a tooth extracted at some point in their lives and would be able to sympathise directly with the victims. In 'Gulliver's Travels' the revolting sections seem more light-hearted in a way, than the other two pieces. I find Gulliver earnestly describing unpleasant processes a little sickening, slightly funny, but not very disturbing. I think that the disgusting sections in 'Gulliver's Travels' are less important than those in 'A Modest Proposal' and 'How The Poor Die'. I find it difficult to choose whose approach is more effective as the two writers are quite different. They both had social consciences: Swift was a dean and Orwell an early socialist, however I get the impression that Swift is angrier about poverty and it shows in the unbelievable nature of his writing. Orwell doesn't seem as passionate as Swift, as he doesn't use such emotive language and writes in a blunt, flat way. In conclusion, I find Swift more effective. This is probably due to the outrageous, offensive nature of what he has written in 'A Modest Proposal'. I think that by writing in this entertaining way and amusing the reader he is more effective than Orwell. 1349 words Aime� Allam 11B.2 English Coursework page 3 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Jonathan Swift section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Jonathan Swift essays

  1. How effective is 'Modest Proposal' by Jonathon Swift

    Firstly he says in the 6th paragraph "of these I have calculated there may be about two hundred thousand couples whose wives are breeders". This is saying that swift has done a few estimates, and researched on what he has said.

  2. A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift How does Swift attempt to make his ...

    He then calculates the amount of breeders in Ireland and minuses the amount of miscarriages. It's good that he does use statistics because otherwise the reader will not be able to imagine how you can put this plan into action to solve the problem of too many poor Catholics in Ireland.

  1. Swifts 'A Modest Proposal' is considered to be one of the most effective pieces ...

    In my opinion, this in itself is proof enough that A Modest Proposal is the most effective piece of satirical writing ever published, as it managed to deceive people into believing an idea which seems totally preposterous in this day and age.

  2. Reading of 'A Modest Proposal' concentrating on how Swift criticised the society in which ...

    provide for their own children but it could also be translated that Protestants think so badly of Catholics that they do not care how their children are treated. In paragraph seven, there is a further criticism concerning Catholic children. He says that 'a boy or girls before twelve years old

  1. What are the Objects of Swift's Satire in 'Gulliver's Travels' in the 'Voyages to ...

    It is quite an amazing description as it compares the emperor to all 4 seasons, when normally people are only compared to one, for example, 'as lovely as a summer's day'. As you can see Swift obviously over-exaggerates this description to show his disgust for flattering and complimenting higher-ranked people than yourself purely for self gain.

  2. Compare the Way in which John Donne and Swift present the women in their ...

    flabby dugs and down they drop" He also uses the rhythm and the rhyme to covey the motion of her breasts as they move from a high position to a low, sagging one, the alliteration is also slightly comical. Swift is making the point about her false appearance because he

  1. Discuss the ways in which Swift criticises his society in 'A Modest Proposal'.

    In addition, this draws the reader into the article as he becomes interested in what the narrator is going to say next. Another example of this is when he says, "Sustenance for their helpless Infants, who as they grow up, either turn Thieves for want of work," This also gives

  2. How Gulliver's Travels Satirises the Politics of Swift's Time.

    Projects done by such people are summed up by "the Universal Artist," who directs his followers to turn useful things into the exact opposite, which results in useless achievements. Some of the experiments held were to create tangible air, wool-less sheep, and horses with stone hooves.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work