• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do you agree with critics who argue that Hamlet's death and the appointment of Fortinbras as king are deeply unsatisfactory and bring no real restoration of order to the play?

Extracts from this document...


Do you agree with critics who argue that Hamlet's death and the appointment of Fortinbras as king are deeply unsatisfactory and bring no real restoration of order to the play? At the end of Act Five, Shakespeare has re-established Hamlet as a traditional Elizabethan revenge tragedy through the bloody catharsis at the end of the play, the purpose of this being to cleanse Denmark of the corrupt and to restore order, although it is doubtful whether Hamlet's revenge achieves this aim. It is during Act Five that Hamlet regains his heroic status: "it is I, Hamlet the Dane" and his supposed madness diminishes. Hamlet once again embraces his Christian faith, realising that "there's a divinity that shapes our ends, rough hew them how we will", this theme would reflect the orthodox Christian beliefs of the audience. Hamlet now believes that God is in control, and that he can only slightly alter his destiny; perhaps Hamlet realises that it is destiny that Fortinbras should take the throne, although there is little else he could do to stop this. All Hamlet can do is give Fortinbras his "dying voice", which will perhaps stop civil war within Denmark. ...read more.


Issues such as suicide would interest the less blood-fixated members of the playhouse crowd, giving them something to debate about. When Hamlet does revenge, it results in a bloody massacre. Many critics feel that this is unnecessary, and argue that many of the characters should not have died. It can be argued that the bloody catharsis is necessary in ridding vice and restoring order in Denmark. It is certainly necessary to fulfil the audience's lust for the conventional tragedy of blood. It can be argued that Hamlet is not required to restore order, as the ghost asks him to "revenge this foul and most unnatural murder" and while he is doing this "taint not thy mind, nor let thy soul contrive against thy mother aught. Leave her to heaven". However, in saying this, the ghost implicates the removal of the traitors from the throne and from the royal bed. Although he does argue with his mother, her death is not a direct result of him. The poisoned chalice that was meant for Hamlet was instead taken by Gertrude. Using Hamlets philosophy we could say that this is divine retribution, and therefore she has been left to heaven. ...read more.


Claudius is a man of words, like Hamlet and although he avoids a war with Norway, this is only for a short time, as at the end his words have been in vain as Fortinbras takes the throne. A patriotic audience would realise the implications of an invading power taking over, and would realise why Hamlet gave Fortinbras his "dying voice". In the Branagh version of Hamlet, Fortinbras has all the symbols of the previous regime destroyed, including a statue of king Hamlet, perhaps an ironic gesture showing the ultimate failure of Hamlet in carrying out his father's wishes. Shakespeare's conclusion to Hamlet is entirely satisfactory in restoring order to Denmark. Fortinbras seems to be a good leader of people, much like old Hamlet who was dearly loved by the Danish people. Hamlet's blessing on Fortinbras, "he has my dying voice", whether reluctant or not, will ease the way for Fortinbras' take over. It is likely that Fortinbras will encounter resistance, as he is a foreigner imposing power, an idea shown in the Branagh version of Hamlet. Denmark, previously described by Hamlet as "an unweeded garden that grows to seed things rank and gross in nature" has been cleansed by the destruction of those corrupt persons in the bloodshed of Act Five. It can therefore be said that Hamlet has been successful in restoring social and moral order to Denmark and to the universe. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Hamlet essays

  1. 'Hamlet is primarily a personal rather than a political tragedy' - To what extent ...

    how tempting suicide is to him, to try and escape his wretched condition and the burden of responsibility placed upon him by his father's ghost. So far in the play, Hamlet has spent the majority of his time reflecting on what the ghost has told him and how he is

  2. How successful is Hamlet as a play about revenge? Consider both the modern and ...

    Unlike Claudius, Hamlet cannot carry out his actions simply. He spends a great deal of time philosophising over his revenge, rather than carrying it out. After hearing the Ghost, Hamlet promises, "I with wings as swift/ As meditation or the thoughts of love/ may sweep to my revenge." He does not actually fulfil what he says here, but spends

  1. An exploration of how Shakespeare presents Hamlet's fear of death.

    hell; they have to pay off their debt by waiting in this place in order to get into heaven. The fact that it is also only mentioned in passing, can be construed as a glancing around the subject of death, as the ghost says he is "confin'd to fast in

  2. How does Shakespeare display Hamlets limitations as a conventional revenger? How do you as ...

    Even before the ghost appeared to Hamlet, he was distant, as we saw him sullen and inattentive in the court, still preoccupied with his father's death and mother's remarriage. Claudius: But now, my cousin Hamlet, and my son - Hamlet: [Aside] A little more than kin and less than kind

  1. Hamlet & Madness

    life, as well as with the proposition that his uncle killed his father, he did not lose Williams 5 control of his conscious mind, but instead, knew exactly how to resolve his pending maladies. There is no question that his apparent madness was his own concoction devised to aid in

  2. Comparing Hamlet with Fortinbras

    for all we know may have little or no female influence, just does things without thinking about them, and also behaves quite violently - both stereotypical male traits. You get the sense that Gertrude and Hamlet were much closer before King Hamlet died, because after the death the swift marriage

  1. According to Aristotelian philosophy a tragedy is a compressed development of a single plot.

    This brings about the cause for Laertes revenge. Hamlet sends two of his friends to their deathbed. The whole thing was a ploy to get closer to Claudius. Hamlet started a battle of wits between him and Claudius by acting mad. He wanted to act mad as to isolate him from the rest of the court.

  2. Hamlet Coursework: Is Hamlet alone responsible for Ophelias death? - WJEC English Lit. ...

    In response to Polonious, Ophelia is more polite to begin with. We see this when she says 'so please you', this yet again adds to the feeling of her lower status within the court compared to her father. Another interpretation of this formal language is that Ophelia does not know

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work