• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do you have any sympathy at all for Hibbert? Give evidence for your opinion

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Journey's End igcse English Do you have any sympathy at all for Hibbert? Give evidence for your opinion It could be argued that the realistic way the horrors of life in a First World War trench are depicted in "Journey's End" leads us to feel sympathy for all the soldiers, including Hibbert, an officer in the company led by Stanhope. We see how soldiers had to deal with physical hardships like rationed food, rats, extreme discomfort and the emotional traumas of terror and almost inevitable death. The conditions they come to accept as ?normal? would strike anyone not accustomed to them as intolerable and Hibbert?s response, based on his instinct for self-preservation, may be seen as rational and in many ways understandable. However, his stance goes against the crucial military requirements of camaraderie and unity against the enemy and thus he loses the sympathy of the audience, even though he has, in all probability, been forced to go to war through conscription. I shall examine in this essay why it is possible to feel sympathy for Hibbert at the beginning of the play, but how this diminishes as more of his character is revealed. We first meet Hibbert towards the end of Act One. ...read more.

Middle

In Act Two, there is a crucial scene when Hibbert, faced with the prospect of the forthcoming battle breaks down emotionally and says he ?cannot stick it any longer?. I continued to feel sympathy because of his predicament: he has no control over his destiny. Stanhope has already had a word with the doctor to prevent him from sending Hibbert for treatment and the only escape appears to be death, but when Stanhope threatens to shoot him, Hibbert urges him to do so, "Go on, then, shoot! ... I'll never go into those trenches again. Shoot!" In Hibbert, R C Sherriff portrays how unbearable the war was for some soldiers: so bad that some preferred to die than live and fight there. Stanhope changes tactics and instead of threats, manipulates Hibbert into staying. ?Think of all the chaps who?ve gone already,? he says and ?It?s the only decent thing a man can do. Stanhope is a good psychologist. When Hibbert ?breaks down and cries? Stanhope ?turns away? because he understands Hibbert?s fear and what is likely to happen to them when the German attack begins. You?re never usually asked to empathise with cowards, but Sherriff makes it hard to ignore the genuine distress driving Hibbert?s behaviour. ...read more.

Conclusion

He is clearly drunk and when Trotter says that he has never seen Hibbert ?so cheerful out here? we understand that Hibbert?s form of escapism is to boast about female conquests and make himself appear more manly. It might be argued that Sherriff is revealing Hibbert?s true, unattractive character, but I interpret his boasts as being a way of covering his insecurity as a man and disguising his true fears; the bravado is his way of boosting his confidence, a misguided attempt to appear more heroic. It is a sign of his own insecurity too when he attempts to undermine Trotter?s praise of Raleigh?s ?pluck? after the raid with a ?Did you see him afterwards though...?? Hibbert is at his most unsympathetic towards the end of the play when he is stalling over leaving the dug-out to go and fight. Compared to the dignity and heroism shown by Raleigh and Osborne in particular he does appear feeble. ?There is no appalling hurry is there?? he asks after his colleagues have already left to do their duty.It is time to confront his demons and he intends to delay this for as long as possible. We do not admire him for it, but given what we have seen of the wasteful horror of war, it is easy to understand why he falters. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE RC Sheriff section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE RC Sheriff essays

  1. In what ways does R.C.Sherriff re-create for his audience the tremendous stress and fear ...

    Sherriff emphasises this when hardy mimics the noise that the rifle grenades and minnies make. "Swish-swish-swish-swish-BANG!" From Osborne's hurried response, "All right-all right-I know" we can presume that he doesn't want to be reminded about the terrors of war although his character can accept the harsh actuality of it.

  2. English 4UO Independent Study - Comparative Essay

    On his journey, Pi is immediately forced into a tragic, life altering situation but is able to develop his maturity through it all due to an innate connection with God and a unique relationship with a true friend. In The Alchemist, Santiago achieves both maturation and self-realization through the life

  1. Journey's end - Focusing on the exchange between Stanhope and Hibbert in act two, ...

    Stanhope again offers Hibbert support and a huge reassurance. Act three, page 98, Stanhope gives Hibbert a drink and some reassurance so that he can go out to fight. This Stanhope and Hibbert incident also sheds some light on the end of the play, where Raleigh is killed in battle.

  2. Journeys End Drama Studies

    In the context of the time, it was rare for, what we now call shell shock to be recognised as an actual problem and to be taken seriously. A man who was seen as incapable of going out was very likely to be seen as a coward and many men would have been shot.

  1. In what ways does R.C.Sherriff re-create for his audience the tremendous stress and fear ...

    We can gather that deaths would only dampen the morale of soldiers so meaningless pieces of information are elaborated on. "Do much damage?" "A dug-out got blown up and came down in the men's tea" The main comparison between Hardy and Osborne is their attitude to their lifestyle within the bleak, somber and deprived dug-out.

  2. Explain the ways in which R C Sherriff conveys a sense

    If the characters had the choice they would not talk about death and squalor, however it is the stuff of their daily lives. They get around talking about the subject but using light hearted banter. This way they can talk to each other without losing personal control or upsetting each other.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work