Evaluate who or what, in your opinion is most responsible for the Fates of the young lovers.

Authors Avatar

                Evaluate who or what, in your opinion is most responsible for the

                                         Fates of the young lovers.

I believe that fate is a key responsibility for the young lovers fates and eventual deaths of Romeo and Juliet, we must first answer the question: what is fate? According to the Oxford English Dictionary, fate is the ‘inevitable destiny or necessity destined term of life; doom.’ Thus to put it simply, fate can be described as a pre planned sequence of events influencing one’s life, therefore it is unstoppable and uncontrollable, it has to happen, it was meant to be. In Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, is it true to say that Fate was the sole contributor to the deaths of the young couple, or was their demise brought about by the mistakes of others that Juliet and Romeo had to pay for.

In this day and age most people however do not seem to see fate is what killed the young lovers for they themselves choose to believe that they have a sense of meaning and responsibility and can control their own lives. Therefore supposing that their problems are caused by the actions of themselves or those influencing them or those that make mistakes affecting them. This is the other view point, being that it is therefore true and justified to say that the deaths of Romeo and Juliet were caused by the mistakes made by themselves and others: therefore the fate factor is nonexistent. If anyone, four characters in the play intensely influence and manipulate the tragic path of the young couple these being Mercutio, Tybalt, the Friar and the Nurse. I will evaluate each one in turn and try to conclude how responsible each one is for the star-crossed lovers fates are.

We begin with Mercutio, the mercurial, active, sprightly and changeable character who seems to be Romeo’s best friend and a supporter of the Montague household, he dramatically changed the course of events by originally encouraging Romeo to go the Capulet’s masquerade by his influential wit and bawdy innuendos such as “if love be rough with you be rough with love.” If Mercutio had not encouraged the disheartened Romeo “is love a tender thing? it is too rough” to go to the Capulet’s dance, the couple would never have met and if Mercutio had not cheered Romeo up before he may not have seen Juliet in the same way he did and their deaths would have been prevented, but instead he is mesmerised and shows his overwhelming feelings for her with rich metaphors and beautiful similes “As a rich jewel in an Ethiop’s ear”. But the fate question is was Romeo destined to meet Juliet, regardless of the actions of others? Mercutio also dramatically changed events of the book by volunteering himself to duel with the “king of cats” Tybalt in town, if the high-spirited, witty Mercutio using his puns to try and insult and frustrate Tybalt “consort? What, dost thou make us minstrels” and had he not continually taunted “by my heel I care not” the short tempered violence hungry Tybalt “thou art a villain” whilst out with Romeo and Benvolio whose ironic prose seemed to sense danger was imminent, “lets retire: the day is hot, the Capels are abroad,” Romeo would never have got into his fight with Tybalt in vengeance for Mercutio’s death and therefore would not have been banished. However, the question rises again perhaps the fight commenced by Mercutio that misfortunate day was inevitable: could it be that Romeo was somehow destined to be exiled?

Join now!

Tybalt the fiery cousin of Juliet and the impulsive, impatient hotheaded enemy of the Montague household who loves a fight “have at thee, coward!” remarkably changed the course of events by originally trying to fight Romeo in town “thou art a villain.” If Tybalt had not been so enraged and violence hungry he and Mercutio would not have got into there duel and therefore the “brave” Mercutio would not have died. However Tybalt’s vengeful and proud character would not let Romeo get away with the embarrassment he had caused Tybalt to receive in an argument with Capulet in Scene 1 Act ...

This is a preview of the whole essay