Examine The Setting Created By Conan Doyle For His Story "The Man With The Twisted Lip"

Authors Avatar

Charlie Dowden        02/01/10

Examine the setting which Conan Doyle created for his story, “The Man with the Twisted Lip”. Consider his reasons for choosing this setting, the effects he has created and how they contribute to the atmosphere.

        ‘The Man with the Twisted Lip’ is a short story by the Victorian writer Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, focusing on his most famous characters, the detective Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson. The story is another of Holmes’ cases, however this story opens with Watson. After a plea for help by Kate Whitney to find her husband, Watson goes to an opium den in the East End of London and retrieves her husband, Isa Whitney. However whilst in the opium den he stumbles across Holmes’, who is in disguise and in the middle of a case of his own. Watson joins Holmes on his case and the case is explained to him as they take a carriage to the house of Mrs St Clair. Her husband, Neville St Clair was believed to be dead after Mrs St Clair spotted him in the window of a building in the East End. A beggar named Hugh Boone had been arrested as the evidence all pointed to the fact that Neville St Clair had been thrown out of the window. However Sherlock Holmes revealed that Boone was in fact a disguise which Mr St Clair had assumed to earn money more money as a beggar. Yet again Holmes solved the mystery whereas the hapless police had blindly stumbled to the wrong conclusion.

        The setting Conan Doyle chose fits in well with the plot to make an altogether eerie and sinister story. The story is obviously Victorian; set between the years of 1837 and 1901 which were the Queen’s reign. These 64 years were a time of invention and progress and many aspects of life were different at the dawn of the 20th century compared to when Victoria came to the throne. The Man With The Twisted Lip, one of 54 short stories based on Sherlock Holmes, was written in 1891, the last decade of the great Victorian empire. Sherlock Holmes’ tales often display aspects of life during this time. Conan Doyle created his hero as an amateur detective, as he was aware of the public criticism of the police who were seen as incompetent. Strangely, the fictional Holmes first appeared in 1887 whilst the real life Jack the Ripper committed his gruesome and notorious murders the following year, in the autumn of 1888. The setting chosen by the writer wishes to hold the reader in suspense. The East End was a highly polluted area, full of smoke belching industrial factories around which the workers lived in slums. Disease was rife but medicine was primitive, with doctors prescribing opium based laudanum. As a result of this, although the opium den was an environment connected with crime and the underworld, it operated quite openly and legally. The selling of opium or other drugs was no crime in the London of 1891, and nobody considered it to be. In this time opium was a very topical and current issue as opium addiction was a common problem. Interestingly it was a problem only affecting the wealthy, as they were the ones who could afford it; in contrast those who inhibit the East End, the lower classes.

Join now!

        As Watson heads down Upper Swandam Lane to retrieve Isa Whitney from the opium den, many aspects of the East End of London are described. Upper Swandam lane is described as a “Vile alley lurking behind the wharves”. The vile alley conveys the dark and rough area. “Lurking”, gives a sense of crime and unsafety. The alley is a backstreet which suggests it may be off the beaten track. “Vile”, suggests the area is filthy, foul, nauseating and repulsive. To emphasize the lack of money in this repulsive area of London, it is mentioned that there are “a slop shop” ...

This is a preview of the whole essay