• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine the supernatural and rational interpretations that seem to explain events in 'The Signalman' and 'The Red Room'.

Extracts from this document...


Examine the supernatural and rational interpretations that seem to explain events in 'The Signalman' and 'The Red Room'. How far have Charles Dickens and H. G. Wells achieved a balance between these different outlooks through the characters and narrative development in their stories, and particularly in their endings? The stories 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens and 'The Red Room' by H G Wells are similar in the balance between the supernatural and rational. In 'The Signalman' there is a ghost or vision that gives warnings to an impending accident on the train line. After various warnings the signalman, who sees the visions is killed by a train. The story leads us down a path, which never reveals which explanation the writer wanted the story to be based around. This is similar to 'The Red Room'. It also has a story that mixes the rational and supernatural, without telling the reader which one to believe. The story is of a man, who is trying to prove that a room in a mansion is not actually haunted, by staying in the room over night. During the night various things happens, leading to the man being injured and knocked out. In both stories the mix of rational and supernatural are combined so you are never sure which one to believe. In 'The Signalman' you are told of two visions witnessed by the signalman. ...read more.


The ghost was not just blowing the candles out but it was 'as if the wicks had been suddenly nipped between a finger and thumb', which suggest that it was not a draught, as it left 'the wick neither glowing nor smoking'. As the candles go out, there were more shadows in the room, causing more fear in the man. As the 'shadows seemed to take another step towards (him)', he begins to become more agitated. This adds to the supernatural feeling of the story. To balance out the supernatural in both stories there are many rational excuses for the happenings in both stories. In 'The Signalman' most of the happenings are explained with a rational excuse, usually by the narrator. After the signalman explained the first story of the vision followed by the accident the narrator dismisses the incident as a 'remarkable coincidence'. The signalman continues to the second story of the death of the woman, preceded by a vision. However, after listening to both stories, the narrator now has 'nothing to say' and cannot dismiss them both as a coincidence. The narrator also tries to tell himself that the signalman may actually just be mentally disturbed and the visions were 'infection in his mind'. He is trying to dismiss them as not actually true. He also tries another excuse. He believes that the visions may be a 'deception of his sense of sight' and based on shadows and light causing strange shapes. ...read more.


He does call them 'curious circumstances' yet also claims that it was 'coincidence' that he said those words. By leaving the narrator in mixed minds about the true reasons for the visions or deaths, the writer also leaves the reader in two minds about what happened. In 'The Red Room' the narrator tries to reject the idea of a supernatural presence in the room. When he is asked if it is a ghost that is present in the room, he replies that 'there is no ghost there at all'. But after he says this he feels the bandages the housekeepers put over his wounds. This leads the reader to think that there was a presence in the room in order to give the man wounds. The narrator tries to dismiss the idea of a ghost as actually just 'Fear' that is only in the minds of the people who enter the room. Was it 'fear' of there actually being a ghost that caused the man to make himself go delirious and blow the candles out himself with the breeze he produced? The narrator himself is believes that it was the fear in his head that caused him to be scared and knock himself out. However, the writer again leaves it up to you to decide which interpretation to believe, as in 'The Signalman'. Both stories leave you a balanced interpretation of what happened and it is up to the reader to decide what one they wish to believe in. Howard Roof 10T English ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Signalman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Signalman essays

  1. Analysis of The Red Room and The Signalman

    Wells also uses personification by, 'shadows cower and quiver.' This personifies the shadows and the statues. Cower and quiver suggests that the statues, shadows show the same fear as the narrator is feeling. In The Signalman Charles Dickens builds up tension by using; the plot, the setting, the characters, the atmosphere and the signalman's story.

  2. Which is the more effective of the supernatural stories of "The Signalman" and "The ...

    The young man remembers the legends and stories regarding the room. The room is a large, shadowy room with a lot of hidden areas H.G wells uses hiding areas because the reader doesn't know what is going to come out from the hidden area.

  1. "The Signalman", "The Red Room" and "The Man with the Twisted Lip"

    He feels that the signalman is very lonely and that he is afraid. The narrator feels sorry for the signalman. It seems to me that he is a person who does not know what he is dealing with or what is happening to him.

  2. Explain what makes a good mystery story, based on your understanding of 'The Red ...

    the end of the room; it also creates a sense of unwelcoming. After midnight he said that 'the candle in the alcove suddenly went out'. The fact that it was midnight could have contributed to this, because lots of scary things occur at midnight, so he could have been thinking

  1. The Monkey's Paw" by W. W. Jacobs, "The Clubfooted Grocer" by Sir Arthur Canon ...

    The ending of the story is very effective because we don't know what the last two wishes are and we don't know who was at the door. There are many questions which are left unanswered and this allows the readers to make their own conclusions about the ending of the story.

  2. Compare The Red Room, The Signalman and The Ostler.

    intention to practice, and by 1848 he had turned to writing, a number of short works appearing in Charles Dickens' periodicals, Household Words and later, All the Year Round. His first novel Iolina involving sorcery and sacrifice was rejected by publishers it was written as early as 1844 but was

  1. 'The Red Room' - review

    'The old woman sat staring into the fire, Her pale eyes wide open, She swayed her head from side to side and muttered: A many thing to see and sorrow for.' The old woman's actions are peculiar and she leaves the audience wondering what exactly is there to see and sorrow for, perhaps she is revealing something from her past.

  2. Make an analysis of the two stories and compare and contrast how the supernatural ...

    However brave he says he is, he carries a gun with him, this shows that he is prepared for a possible emergency and it reinforces that he doesn't believe in ghosts. By the end of the story the man has much changed and the confident boastful man that we knew

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work