• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine the ways in which tragedy is presented in Shakespeare’s Antony and Cleopatra.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Examine the ways in which tragedy is presented in Shakespeare's Antony and Cleopatra. Shakespeare's presentation of tragedy in this play is very clear, in that he adheres to the accepted formula of what tragedy entails. However, to analyse thoroughly the means by which Shakespeare evokes the tragic elements of the plot, we must first understand what makes a tragedy. Aristotle's Poetics presents a precise definition of what tragedy is. Tragedy involves a person having a negative change of fortune, often leading to their demise. However, this change does not occur because of some moral defect or depravity, rather due to an internal error within the person, which is also intrinsic to their personality. Antony's weakness seems to be his love for Cleopatra and his inability to decide whether he should pursue duty or personal pleasures, a fault made visible by Shakespeare's presentation of Rome and Egypt, and the rapid alternation of scenes between the two. Rome is quickly established as a metaphor for Antony's responsibilities, and of Egypt, represented by Cleopatra, we are told that the "beds ... are soft". The differences between Rome and Egypt are made so apparent not only by the constant shift in scenery between the two, but also by the characters chosen by Shakespeare to represent the two places. ...read more.

Middle

He is repeatedly called, by several characters, a "triple pillar of the world", not just in reference to his political position as a triumvar, but also his importance to Rome. His value to Rome and it's armies is presented through an impressive array of narrative techniques. The most predominant is the use of size related imagery to describe literally his apparently immense character. His legs were said to have "bestrid the ocean", and "His reared arm crested the world". In relation to this is the oft-used God-like imagery used only in conversations concerning Antony, which is also important. Antony the "Herculean" is said to continue a "Jove" even after all of his mistakes during the wars between his armies and Caesar's, suggesting that his previous eminence must have been tremendous in comparison to his latter days. Throughout the play, Enobarbus is portrayed and perceived as the epitome of truth and cynicism, and is used by Shakespeare not only to add humour to the performance, but also as a dramatic device to increase the magnitude, and therefore tragedy of the piece. Enobarbus's pragmatic views eventually lead to his emergence as a moral indicator for the audience, and therefore his death is seen as a tragedy in itself, as noted by Antony, "my fortunes have corrupted honest men". ...read more.

Conclusion

Therefore, the last act is strategically placed to combat the sour taste of Antony's fall, and to represent the more dominant views of his character, revealing that his downfall is in fact merely a result of his fame. His mistakes during battle, when his "fleet...yielded to the foe" are evidence of the human properties of love and companionship he felt for Cleopatra, and work in counteraction to the descriptions of him as a god. His inability to decide seems to be his fatal flaw - he is a man caught between conflicting aims, an idea made literal by the personifications of his choices, Cleopatra and Caesar, during their sea battle. Tragedy is portrayed so well in this play partly because of Shakespeare's adherence to Aristotle's guidelines, but also because of his use of narrative techniques to expand and develop Antony's personality, making him seem human, whilst preserving the God-like qualities mentioned in reference to him throughout the play. This enables an audience to feel empathy with him, and therefore with his problems. It is this empathy that ultimately leads to Shakespeare's triumph. The ability of an audience to be able to take events from the play and apply them to their own lives is key. Aristotle calls this universality, and says of it that if a play is truly tragic, it can be 'stripped' of all specifics and applied to any other situation. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Antony & Cleopatra section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Antony & Cleopatra essays

  1. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of EITHER Cleopatra OR Antony in Act three Scene thirteen. How ...

    If Shakespeare did have another prominent female character in the play, I do not think it would convey the same meaning because having one strong female character highlights the femininity well enough. This line (1.3.2) also implies that Shakespeare was trying to show that women (in particular Cleopatra)

  2. Explore the love between antony and cleopatra throughout shakespeares play

    Cleopatra is then seen as beside herself with grief, believing that Antony has turned against her and bids her servant to inform Antony, 'go tell him I have slain myself; say that the last word I spoke was Antony.' Cleopatra is trying to provoke a response out of Antony; she

  1. Evaluate his taints and honours, thus enabling us to draw our own conclusions about ...

    In Macbeth, the resolution of the conflict and the re-establishment of social and moral order are the important elements, along with the hero's inner awareness of his tragic conflict. Arnold Stein writes, "Antony is no explorer of consciousness. He has very little Hamlet or Macbeth in him".

  2. Discuss the 'variety' of Cleopatra, and how successfully Shakespeare presents the contribution, which this ...

    There are times in the play when Cleopatra can be stubborn and illogical. An example of this is seen in Act three scene seven, when she does not accept Enobarbus' argument that her presence at the battle of Actium "needs must puzzle Antony/Take from his heart, take from his brain, from's time/What should not then be spar'd".

  1. How, in your opinion, does Shakespeare use language throughout the play to present Cleopatra's

    first line is "I will be even with thee, doubt it not". Telling Enobarbus to "doubt it not" implies an annoyance with him for attempting to control her. It also has a finality in its tone which shows that she is not willing to change her mind and is confident of her own opinion.

  2. "Rare Egyptian" or "Foul Egyptian"? Discuss how Cleopatra is presented to us. What is ...

    He being one of these, he cannot criticise this. Pompey is untrue. This leaves just Julius Caesar, and this was a successful relationship about which Antony has no right to judge Cleopatra. This, again, is a typical Roman insult, used constantly by those who reject Cleopatra as a ruler.

  1. An exploration of the way in which Shakespeare presents the character of Enobarbus and ...

    and 'Affection' (sexual desire) to 'nick' his reason and military judgement. Cleopatra's reaction to Enobarbus' truths is far different to her hyperbolic reactions of earlier scenes. Enobarbus' words do not provoke a reaction such as the messengers in Act 2 scene 5, because she understands that Enobarbus' comments are not out of spite but out of a true realisation.

  2. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of EITHER Cleopatra OR Antony in Act three Scene thirteen. How ...

    He also obviously presents the contrasting side between Antony and Cleopatra's personalities and ambitions. As well as this, Shakespeare has presented these characters so that the audience can identify with them much easier, by giving them their flaws and imperfections so they that they do not seem like perfect, unrealistic

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work