• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explain how and why Gregory from "The half brothers" and Sylvia Lister form "One Wednesday Afternoon" were so badly treated by their families.

Extracts from this document...


Wider Reading Essay Explain how and why Gregory from "The half brothers" and Sylvia Lister form "One Wednesday Afternoon" were so badly treated by their families. Describe the ways in which they were persecuted and explain their persecutors responses to the tragedies which overcame them. The story "The Half Brothers" is written by Elizabeth Gaskell. It is set in the 1850's, in Cumberland, which is a farming area. The language used it typical of the area in Victorian times, and we also know where it is set as it tells us so in the story "he rented a small farm up in Cumberland". The story "One Wednesday Afternoon" was written around the 1950's by Stan Barstow. This story is set in an imaginary industrial town called Cressley in the midlands. We can tell this from some of the typical midlands language which is used. "An accident y'say?" In the story "The Half Brothers", a woman called Helen is going through a bad time. She has lost her husband and daughter, and is left on her own with her son, Gregory. As Helen is finding it difficult to cope on her own with a small child, her sister, Fanny comes to live with her. The family is very poor as Helen is unable to work due to her eyesight failing. ...read more.


In "the half brothers" the story is set in Cumberland, so therefore is going to be associated with countryside and farm work. William owns a farm, and Gregory helps out the old Shepherd on the farm. In "one Wednesday afternoon" , the working places are very different. The Listers live in an industrial town, and both work in factories. The stories differ on the places of work, but the causes of the main incident or death are both related to the work area. Gregory in "The Half Brothers" dies whilst out in the countryside looking for his brother, and Sylvia gets her scalp ripped off when her hair gets caught in a machine at the factory. In the two stories there are many different family relationships. Both of the stories contain jealousy. In "The Half Brothers", William is hugely jealous of Gregory as his mother has so much love for him. William sees Gregory as being Helens connection to her previous marriage. Also as Helen has so much love for Gregory, she has little or no love for William. In "The Half Brothers" Fanny is also jealous that Helen gets married to William and not her "Aunt Fanny was a good deal shocked at this". The relationship between Gregory and his brother isn't a very good one. ...read more.


We also can guess that he doesn't have a very good education from when he visits his wife in hospital. He seams to be embarrassed around the young, smart doctor who he speaks to " Are you her husband? The man nodded dumbly". Jack appears to be so intimidated by the young doctor, that he can barely even look him in the eye "The man brought his eyes up from the floor". Sylvia must have some kind of education to have got a job, but her job is still only in a factory, so it cant have been that good of an education. The language used in each story is very typical of the period in which it was written, and the setting in which it was written. In "The Half Brothers", there are many Victorian style words and sayings "Died of consumption", "Came to bear her company"," I don't think I ever scouted him". Because of the Victorian influence of the story, the language is all very formal and proper, which sometimes makes the story harder to read and understand. In "One Wednesday Afternoon" the language is very different. Words which are used such as "Bairn" and " Donnin' up" tell us that the story is set in north England. There are lots of slang words used n this story, which makes the language very informal. The length of the sentences and paragraphs in the story vary a lot, and the use of vocabulary is very easy to understand. Laura Miller 7165 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sylvia Plath section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sylvia Plath essays

  1. What happens in the story? Superman and Paula Brown's New Snowsuit is a short ...

    Nowadays young children may well see violent or disturbing scenes in films and on TV programmes, but this would not have been so in the USA in the 1940s.) At the end of the story, the fantasy is destroyed forever - the blue capes dissolve and vanish "like the crude drawings of a child."

  2. A Trapped Life: The Autobiographical Elements of Sylvia Plath's The Bell Jar.

    She could write the novel because she was writing about what she knew, which is an imperative necessity to a great novelist. "On the other hand if madness is a form of insight and itself a comment on its causes, then effective expression of it may Trolenberg 5 achieve success in art, if not in life" (Wagner "Critical Essays" 38).

  1. How is Sylvia Plath's life reflected in the poems

    "Daddy" is Plath's most controversial and renowned poem. The images of Otto Plath and Ted Hughes appear randomly throughout the poem. The first half of "Daddy" chiefly talks about Otto Plath, Sylvia's father; she writes, "Daddy, I have had to kill you./You died before I had time-/Marble-heavy, a bag full

  2. "Growing Up" the main character experiences something that changes his view of things. Compare ...

    to help her, this also makes her begin to doubt herself "I was not sure. I wasn't sure at all." she becomes insecure. "squares of light in the windows that were home." This is a description of her home and Plath uses light as metaphor for heaven to show how

  1. The three poems I have chosen to compare are 'A Parental Ode To My ...

    A line, which truly shows how much respect and pride a father would have for his child can be found in the poem, which says 'Thy father's pride and hope'. This line is showing how much of a perfect creature his son is, epitomising the fathers dream of his sons future.

  2. How does the author's treatment of relationships effect the characterisation of the heroines in

    genuine affection, but are brimming with selfish motives and a desire to make an impact on others. Both novels are full of deception, for example Esther lies to herself and others about her happiness and mental health in order to maintain an acceptable social image.

  1. Moments of change in the modern short story and how they are expressed.

    The simile about the crude drawings being wiped away is especially effective because it corresponds together with her situation. She also uses words such as 'dissolved' and 'vanished' in relation to describe her sense of loss. The very last line, ' That was the year the war began and the

  2. I will be discussing five of them all written post 1900. These poems are ...

    The bridge becomes an awareness that danger is everywhere and so, it is the safe route. Childhood innocence is lost through experience. The title embodies this in as much that he realizes rats are everywhere or symbolically, danger is ubiquitous.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work