Explore the ways in which James Joyce illustrates the character and behaviour or Mr Duffy, in his story, ‘A Painful Case’.

Authors Avatar

Paul Talbot

Explore the ways in which James Joyce illustrates the character and behaviour or Mr Duffy, in his story, ‘A Painful Case’.

‘A Painful Case’ by James Joyce is a story about a man, Mr James Duffy, who lives on his own, and has very little contact with anybody.  He is very lonely and isolated from the outside world, until one day he forges an unlikely friendship with a married woman, Mrs Emily Sinico.  Their relationship becomes very close, and eventually Mrs Sinico attempts to develop it to a more intimate level – the prospect of which frightens Mr Duffy, who is then forced, by his own fear and pride, to end the relationship.  The story then moves on several years, and Mr Duffy returns to his solitary and somewhat distant lifestyle.  He reads of the death, and suspected suicide, of Mrs Sinico, and begins to reflect on his isolated and desolate past, and regret his actions towards his relationship with Mrs Sinico.  The story ends with: “He thought he was alone”.

Joyce uses a lot of imagery in illustrating the character and behaviour of Mr Duffy.  The characteristics of his rented room represent much of his character, and indeed, some of the main themes of the story: these being desired elitism and consequent loneliness.  His “uncarpeted room” has “lofty walls”.  This would give the impression of a grand, wide open space, which, being uncarpeted, may possibly be prone to echoing, emphasising the idea of emptiness.  The fact that the room is “free from pictures”, again, illustrates an empty and lonely atmosphere.  Mr Duffy has “four cane chairs”, only one of which is regularly, (if ever) used.  These extra, unoccupied spaces are, again, representations of emptiness and loneliness.  

Join now!

Mr Duffy sleeps on a “black iron bedstead”.  This is hard and uncomfortable, where beds are supposed to be places of comfort, on which to relax.  Joyce has used this to show how Mr Duffy is generally used to discomforts, and that his life is in fact barren of such comforts and luxuries, both physically and emotionally.

The shape and colour of the furniture in his room have deeper layers of meaning still.  His “square table” is the most simple of shapes, and shows how Mr Duffy’s life has no extravagant shape, and is somewhat rather plain and ...

This is a preview of the whole essay