• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

From your study of three Sherlock Holmes cases, what do you consider to be the key components of detective fiction and to what extent do the stories appeal to the modern reader?

Extracts from this document...


From your study of three Sherlock Holmes cases, what do you consider to be the key components of detective fiction and to what extent do the stories appeal to the modern reader? The three cases that I have studied are The Adventure of Silver Blaze, The Red-Headed League and The Adventure of The Speckled Band. Conan Doyle was a very early detective fiction writer, if not the earliest. He based his Sherlock Holmes stories on his professor at Edinburgh University, Joseph Bell. Doyle graduated as a doctor but apparently wasn't very successful and took to writing. The Victorians were very interested in the science of crimes; this is why Sherlock Holmes was so successful; Doyle wrote exactly what the public wanted. Doyle solved a real crime where George Adalgy was wrongly accused of mutilating horses; this could have been the inspiration for Silver Blaze. Holmes uses his experiences in life and incorporates them into his stories. One key factor of detective fiction is the setting; Doyle uses the settings in his stories to reflect the emotion of the crime. In The Adventure of Silver Blaze the setting is Dartmoor, Dartmoor is a "Sparsely inhabited" area of England, it is the perfect setting for crime and it says this in the text, "the moor is a complete wilderness, inhabited only by a few roaming gypsies". ...read more.


This clue led Sherlock Holmes to the result but may not have been as obvious to the reader. In the Speckled band there were many clues such as the "charred stump of a match" in Julia's right hand and a match-box in her left. This meant that Julia looked about when the alarm took place. Also the whistling at the dead of the night is a very unclear clue or a red herring; it could have led the reader to believe that the whistling was caused by the roaming gypsies. Conan Doyle uses clues to get the reader involved and feel part of the story, also the reader would feel satisfaction from solving a case, and feel as though he is like Holmes rather than Watson. The clues are not too obvious so that the reader feels like he/she is being challenged, if the crime is obvious then the reader won't feel as though he/she's achieved anything therefore won't have enjoyed the story. The same method is used in modern detective fictions and is one of the most important elements of a detective fiction. An additional key component of detective fiction is 'how the crime was done' not just who did it. ...read more.


Shortly after Watson introduces the story in Silver Blaze he says to Holmes "I should be most happy to go down with you if I should not be in the way". Watson appears inferior to Holmes from the start of the story and this makes the reader respect Holmes. One factor about Doyle's stories that would not work today is how women are seen to be inferior to men. If any women appear in the stories they are usually maids or clients in need of Holmes, for example Helen Stoner is in a "pitiable state of agitation". Looking through the text in The Red-Headed League it is very difficult to find a woman even mentioned. In modern day detective fiction women are always involved and seen equal to men (however I haven't seen one that has a women as a main character). All of the techniques that I have mentioned in Sherlock Holmes are needed in detective fiction. Aspects of the novels should be kept in all detective fictions as they are proven to be the most successful. The fact that The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes were set in the Victorian times does not change anything. Modern detective fiction still uses all of these components and Sherlock Holmes is the reason why they are successful. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Authors essays

  1. What is the importance of setting in 'Endgame?'

    And you could see down to the bottom. So white. So clean'. What she says is completely unrelated to the conversation, suggesting that Nell sees her memories as a world that she would rather live in. The other factors that help to build up the image of Nagg and Nell's inside and outside world are the stage directions and the setting that Beckett puts them in.

  2. Sherlock Holmes

    This is why it became known as Sherlock Holmes adventures. Sherlock Holmes adventures have a very unique structure. This is because it creates a story with in the story. It starts with the victim coming to Holmes about their problem(s).

  1. Wonderland Vs Neverland

    The only problem is that no matter how grown up Alice thinks she is, and can act, saying she knows just about everything, her meeting with the Duchess, who comments that Alice "[doesn't] know much, and that's a fact" causes her to realise she in fact knows nothing, and still

  2. Prose Study - How important is setting in Gulliver's Travels?

    The war started because the then Emperor of Lilliput passed a law saying that everyone had to break their eggs at the small end. People who broke this law were discriminated against, and books by them were destroyed and not published.

  1. Culture Clash in "Two Kinds" and "Dead Mans Path"

    The culture clash is emphasized when Amy refuses to rehearse properly for her performance and play's badly as a result her mum is deeply ashamed as she has in Chinese terms at least "shamed the family's name" her father shares a similar view He says: "That was something else" In

  2. Compare and contrast the two pairs of lovers in 'Much Ado about Nothing'. Consider ...

    rather than hold three words conference with this harpy". ( 11. i. 246-254) When he hears that Beatrice is in love with him he promises to love her better, however he hides his deeper emotions until the latter stages of the play when he falls victim to a deception.

  1. Prose Study (Oscar Wilde)

    When the Prince was alive he lived in the palace of San-Souci, here he wasn't allowed to see the outside world, that didn't bother the Prince because there he had everything he wanted and needed. He was very happy this led to people naming him the Happy Prince: "My courtiers

  2. "The darkness out there". Penelope Lively develops Mrs. Rutters character in many ways, with ...

    This shows she has no feeling of mutual human kindness and doesn?t feel obliged to help. Again, she is not bothered with the fact he is in his late teens. Mrs. Rutter is bitter and resentful because of the death of her husband.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work