• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Great Expectations is sometimes said to incorporate a powerful nostalgia for the social and moral certainties of Joe Gargery's forge' (David Trotter). To what extent do you regard Dickens's novel as nostalgic?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Great Expectations is sometimes said to incorporate a powerful nostalgia for the social and moral certainties of Joe Gargery's forge' (David Trotter). To what extent do you regard Dickens's novel as nostalgic? During his childhood Pip never seemed happy; not even with himself; his sister constantly reminded him of how lucky he was to be alive and, people like Pumblechook, rumpled his hair and were forever reminding him that he was "brought up by hand". His surroundings were as miserable as they could be, with cold, wet marshes, and the hulks out to sea full of men like the one he met in the graveyard, whose memory forever haunts him. Pip's life ends up revolving around something he knows he cannot change; the fact that "he is a common labouring-boy!" (60). However; suddenly things change and, as his expectations take shape, he heads off to London and begins the life of a gentleman which he has been striving to live for so long. This new opportunity seems to bring new happiness, until he is told the truth of who his benefactor really is; and it seems to change Pip, and the course of the novel; he begins to realise who he really is, and the guilt at leaving the forge builds. However, does Pip really show any nostalgia for the forge and its moral certainties or is it the just that he realises he knows nowhere else and so is forced to return? ...read more.

Middle

The forge is not really his home, and it is certainly not where he would have chosen to grow up. Jerome Bump suggests that his family actually drove him away because "as "compensation" for his shame he soon identified himself with Estella's extraordinarily dysfunctional "family" and adopted her view of Joe and a stance of "vicious reticence" or lying" (Bump). When Joe comes up to London and visits him, Pip is appalled by the idea because he is ashamed to be associated with him. Pip says that his feelings about Joe's visit were of "considerable disturbance, some mortification, and a keen sense of incongruity." (218). Awkwardness has built up between the two friends; Pip has literally stepped up a few classes from a blacksmith to a gentleman, and neither of them know how to act towards the other. This awkwardness works in two ways for Pip, firstly he is ashamed for Joe to see his recently decorated flat and his servant; he is aware of Joe's simple ways and is ashamed to show off his riches in front of a blacksmith. Secondly, and I think more importantly, he is ashamed to show Joe, and therefore his background, to any of his new acquaintances. As Joe is leaving, he tells Pip that he accepts the class division between them and that from then on he will only be met by Pip at the forge. Pip is so overcome by this that he goes after Joe but finds he is too late to catch up with him. ...read more.

Conclusion

divest myself of a misgiving that something might happen to London in the meanwhile, and that, when I got there it would be...clean gone." 146). This longing far over shadows the nostalgia for Joe Gargery's forge, Pip does miss Joe but I would not say he missed the life that went with him. There are times at which he regrets ever leaving the simple way of life that went with Joe and his forge but I do not agree with the fact that there is a "powerful" sense of nostalgia "for the social and moral certainties of Joe Gargery's forge". I think any nostalgia felt was sprung out of guilt for denying his past in the hope of becoming a gentleman: "For Pip, his bed just has become "uneasy," and that uneasiness also comes from himself, as his own conscience bears down upon him for leaving Joe and Biddy to become a gentleman, and rejecting that sphere of life Joe and Biddy represent. Thus, in Pip's case, anxiety comes from giving into his desires instead of following down the most logical path for his training and status." (Lee). However, the most logical path is not always the preferred path: when Pip returns to the forge at the end of the book he finds it "offers nothing less than the reconstitution of the family as the medium of social and moral understanding." (Dickens, xvii). Before he left, however, this "understanding" was never there and so Pip would be hard pushed to miss it. Word Count: 1,907. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Great Expectations section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Great Expectations essays

  1. Great expectations

    The tone Estella uses to speak to Pip is very rude: " 'Ah!' said the girl, ' but you see, she don't.' " This shows the readers that Estella feels superior to Mr. Pumblechook. Furthermore, it has connotations that state Estella is not afraid to speak to her elders, she thinks she knows what Miss.

  2. Discuss the role of Joe Gargery in Great Expectations.

    Dickens portrays Joe as described above during the early parts of the novel. It is possible that the only reason he got married to Mrs Joe was to bring up Pip. When Pip is being attacked by his sister Joe regularly comes to his aid: ' Mrs Joe has been out a dozen times, looking for you, Pip.

  1. An exploration of the ways in which issues of class and status are presented ...

    Joe seems to see any aspiration to a higher class or way of life, as lending to his own insecurity and weakness. Joe is contented and happy with his class and hard work with it, and is even proud of it as Biddy tells a surprised Pip.

  2. Examine how Dickens deals with the issue of social class in Great Expectations.

    Magwitch recounts the trial in court, "My lord and gentleman, here you has afore you, side by side, two persons as your eyes can separate wide; one, the younger, well brought up, who will be spoke to as such; one, the elder, ill brought up, who will be spoke to

  1. Great Expectations

    in the fulfillment of great expectations, and that hose obstacles must sometimes be overcome violently. Mrs. Joe was, in her refusal to see anything at all in Pip, an obstacle to great expectations. She had to go. And yet Pip, who childishly believes that achievement and status will be conferred

  2. Great Expectations

    Who brought you up by hand? And why I did it, I should like to know...I'd never do it again! I know that". Mrs Joe believes that Pip should be grateful to her for what she has done for him. She is also quick to say that she is ashamed of her situation.

  1. What does Dickens reveal about social class in 'Great Expectations'?

    Pip is shocked and horrified to find that a convict and not Miss Havisham is his benefactor. Magwitch tells Pip that Estella is his daughter by Molly, who is now employed by Jaggers. Magwitch is in grave danger because if he is caught he will be hanged.

  2. Examine How Charles Dickens Portrays the Differences in Social Class of Mrs. Joe Gargery ...

    Throughout the meal, it is clear that Mrs. Gargery thinks very little of Joe and Pip, and tries to act in a higher social class, talking down to them both. Even though Mrs. Gargery treats Joe in a degrading and humiliating way, she still expects him to stick up for, and stand by her.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work