• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Hamlets dilemma - Why can't he act?

Extracts from this document...


HAMLETS DILEMMA: WHY CAN'T HE ACT? One of the focal aspects within the play is a dilemma he is forced to face. This dilemma is whether or not he should murder his uncle to revenge his father's death. In Act 1 Scene 5, Hamlet comes face to face with the ghost of his father, who is doomed to suffer eternal damnation unless his sins are purged; yet this can only occur through the revenge of his own death. Hamlet believes that despite doing his father the justice, he will go to hell, since according to the Christian religion; all life is sacred and should not be ended by anyone but God. Evidence of Hamlet's religious belief, in relation to afterlife, can be found in Act 1 scene 2 in which he expresses a desire to end his life: "...that the everlasting had not fixed his canon gainst' self-slaughter. How weary, stale and unprofitable seem to me all the uses in the world!" This is an explicit expression of Hamlet's melancholic state of mind. He has near lost the will to live, yet cannot commit suicide, as he holds a Christian belief that life is sacred; and so if he ends his own life, he will be sent to hell. Hamlet is not a man of action, barely possessing the will to go on with his life. Therefore it is a tragic turn of bad luck when his father asks Hamlet to revenge his death, because he is suffering from melancholia and consequently a lack of decisiveness and action; yet he has to face a dilemma concerning whether or not he should act on his father's will. ...read more.


However, we can connote a deeper feeling of chaos felt by Hamlet at the thought of his mother sleeping with another man. By society's standards of the time, it was considered scandalous for a woman to reveal herself capable of desire. Hamlet's Oedipus complex causes him to suffer intense sexual jealously at observing sexual desire in his mother, especially because that desire is not for Hamlet himself, but for another man. Among others, this is the sort of psychology that constitutes Hamlet's inner turmoil, which his initial prone to indecisiveness and inability to act is a symptom of. Hamlet's melancholia and inability to act is a crucial flaw in Hamlet's character and according to Aristotle; it is essential to the progression of the plot. According to Aristotle's theory, in revenge tragedy there is a tragic flaw in the hero (main protagonist), which to an extent undermines his/her purpose as the tragic hero of the play. As previously mentioned, Hamlet's purpose is to revenge his father's death. However, because he suffers from depression, he has not the personal conviction to commit to any form of action. Throughout the play he is contemplating whether or not he should murder his uncle to revenge his father's death, believing that if he does, he will surely go to hell. This creates an enormous dilemma: Hamlet either revenges his father's death, subsequently freeing his father from purgatory whilst Hamlet himself goes to hell; or he decides not to kill his uncle, saving his own soul whilst leaving his father to face eternal damnation. ...read more.


whilst praying/repenting, that person may not end up in purgatory- this uncertainty further adds to Hamlet's confusion over what action he should take, if any. My personal feeling is that Hamlet's religious fears and uncertainties intensify Hamlet's dilemma so strongly, that it is only natural that Hamlet is forced into action by a change in the plot or a moment in which Hamlet is pushed into a corner and has to act- I am referring to Act 5 Scene 2 in the play, in which the King and Laertes plot to kill Hamlet by putting poison on the tip of the sword, or alternatively, by handing him a drink of poison of the former plan fails. The scene takes a crucial turn when the Queen drinks from the cup, in respect to Hamlet's health. She dies, and then Laertes blames the King. It is only at this point that Hamlet is fuelled into a course of action that he would have otherwise felt too indecisive to take. Hamlet of course kills his father in revenge of his mother as well as his father. This scene is an essential device in providing a logical conclusion to the play. Without being fuelled into such a vengeful rage, it is likely that the time taken for Hamlet to commit any action could not be married with any suitable duration of time a play should last for! On this note, I conclude that Hamlet's dilemma, influenced by his fears; depression and indecisiveness could not be logically resolved on his own exclusive decision to act. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Hamlet essays

  1. How does Hamlet's character develop during the play?

    In Act 3, Scene 3, he says "Why, this is hire and salary, not revenge". In Act 2, Scene 3, he convinces himself that his plan to add sixteen lines to the play, The murder of Gonzago, and watch Claudius's reaction is the best plan of action.

  2. Exploring Hamlet's state of mind(Act 1, Scene 2 - Act 1, Scene 5)

    Again, the ghost, Hamlet's father, has explained to him that Claudius had killed him and his soul couldn't rest until revenge was brought onto his brother. The audience hears Hamlet's promise to make Claudius pay for his murderous ways. Already, the audience should be excited by hearing Hamlet's promise because it is giving them something to look forward to.

  1. How does Shakespeare portray changes in Hamlets character in soliloquy one and four

    This is where we are first introduced to Hamlet's emotions and feelings. This is where the downward spiral off Hamlet's life begins where we can see a mixture of emotions consisting mostly of anger, depression and self doubt, leading to suicidal and miserable thoughts.

  2. Hamlet Act 3 scene 4

    Claudius should also emphasise when he says, "Forgive me my foul murder!" as this shows that maybe he does truly repent and feel guilt. He could shout this line to the ceiling as if he were talking to god. When Claudius talks of the things he does not wish to give up, "My crown, mine own ambition, and my queen."

  1. Hamlet. Throughout the play we see Hamlets state of mind through the presentation ...

    These imply that he is very emotional and he is losing control. While to Hamlet Claudius is a villain, so too is he for not taking any action. He is a pitiful, weak, miserable fool who lacks the 'gall' to step up to his commitment.

  2. "How does Shakespeare represent the development of Hamlet's revenge during the first three acts ...

    To post with such dexterity to incestuous sheets. It is not, or it cannot come to good." It is obvious that many questions are plaguing Hamlet's mind: how much does Gertrude know and could she actually be involved in murder? At this stage in the play Hamlet has an instinct that his father's death was not an accident yet has no clear evidence supporting his feelings.

  1. How Does Shakespeare Convey a Sense of Anomie in Hamlet Act 1, and to ...

    Our last king, Whose image even but now appeared to us, Was, as you know, by Fortinbras of Norway, Thereto prick'd on by a most emulate pride, Dared to the combat; in which our valiant Hamlet--For so this side of our known world esteem'd him--Did slay this Fortinbras; who by

  2. Commentary on a poor example of an essay on Hamlet's madness.

    The tragedy in which the play ends can be perceived in many different ways. The perception of the author is that because of Hamlet?s madness he caused the downfall of Denmark. However, Hamlet was not capable of killing anyone due to his moral beliefs which the author previously stated.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work