• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Hardy and Hill both present the reader with female characters who are isolated and ostracized by society. Compare and contrast the ways in which both writers deal with these themes.

Extracts from this document...


Jennifer Hardie. 11H. Hardy and Hill both present the reader with female characters who are isolated and ostracized by society. Compare and contrast the ways in which both writers deal with these themes. Susan Hill and Thomas Hardy are clearly both interested in the role of women and their position in society. The female protagonists, in `I'm the King of the Castle and `The Withered Arm', are insecure as they lack a man to provide them with social status and respect. As a consequence of their troubled pasts, they are rejected from society, and are both left vulnerable and desperate. Helena Kingshaw represents a certain class of women in post-war England, the setting for Susan Hill's novel, who found themselves lacking the emotional and financial support of a man. The superstition in those days left these genteel, unskilled women in a shameful position. Society rejected those spurned by men and many became objects of gossip of a malicious nature. Similar nonsensical teachings in Victorian times, the setting for `The Withered Arm', also left abandoned women, such as Rhoda Brook, viewed as social outcasts. Thomas Hardy is clearly sympathetic to such women, especially those reaching the stages of their lives where he suggests, through a careful adjective selection "worn", they may be becoming desperate for a husband. He seems to consider them as isolated victims of the stereotypical image of women as a possession, classed by looks and fortune, and his novel exposes the hypocrisy in society. ...read more.


In `I'm the King of the Castle' it is frowned upon for a woman, with the status of housekeeper, to wear make-up and dress up. As in `The Withered Arm' this is because a woman's dress sense reflected their position in society. We see how the Farmer Lodge's pretty wife's wealth gives her the right to wear, "a silver coloured gown". On the other hand, the affect a woman's appearance on the male protagonists of each novel is different in that Hooper's opinion of her looks seems relatively insignificant to how he had been "impressed by the graceful letters of Mrs. Helena Kingshaw." Whereas, Gertrude was worried about her disfigurement because in `The Withered Arm', "men think so much of personal appearance." Both writers also convey to the reader how lack of status generates a fear within the women to change from their set principles. We notice this in Kingshaw's displays of stereotypical motherly affection and more subtly in Brook, through her indignancy when her son suggests she goes to see her successor; "I, go to see her!" The two women are forced into these ways of dealing with their isolation by their shared insecurity. Their two different ways of coping both have their drawbacks: Kingshaw is so busy trying a good impression and secure her future with Kingshaw that she cannot form a proper relationship with her son. ...read more.


On the other hand, 'The Withered Arm' is set over a much longer period of time and informs the reader of ill-feeling towards Rhoda from outside the immediate circle of protagonists. Through these very different structures, Hardy and Hill both create an increasing sense of doom for the two female protagonists. The absence of love in both characters' lives undermines their confidence and relationships, resulting in isolation. Warings reinforces the theme of isolation as it is completely set apart from events in the normal world and, as in `The Withered Arm', the accumulation of hostile imagery of the surrounding countryside further emphasises their loneliness and vulnerability. In both novels the main requirement of women was dynasties, so those rejected by men were despised and ostracized from society. This put both Brook and Kingshaw lacking status and in a very pitiable position. Nevertheless, due to the way the two writers deal with the themes of isolation and ostracization of the female protagonists, as a reader I never felt for Kingshaw quite the sympathy I did for Brook. As Hill presents Helena Kingshaw as so shallow a character, we feel so much anger at her dismissive attitude to her son that it is almost as though she deserves anything. By contrast, Hardy deliberately presents Rhoda Brook, "her red eyes weeping", as a more pitiful character who seems much more the victim of her bad luck. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Susan Hill section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Susan Hill essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How does Susan Hill use Gothic techniques to create tension and horror in the ...

    5 star(s)

    The novel is in his opinion, which makes it easier for the reader to relate to the character, as well as provoking a feeling of empathy. As events are told from the present, looking back to the past, the narrator knows how the story will end, yet the reader obviously does not.

  2. Consider the theme of loneliness in the novel "I am the king of the ...

    demonsatrating his selfishness. He is very closed and "would not give anything of himself away". As well as creating a beast in Hooper, Susan Hill also shows us Hooper's other side. The side of loneliness and sensitivity. An example of this is when he thinks "now I see why it is better to have a house like The Warnings".

  1. Explain the importance of Warings in the novel?

    He had felt "himself more than ever removed from them" and "saw that they did not really know him, not any of them". At that point, even Mrs Kingshaw chose to believe Edmund's false allegation that Charles bullied him in the woods, which made him feel that "there couldn't be any kind of truce between them".

  2. Looking in detail at ‘The Woman in Black’explore how Susan Hill builds and sustains ...

    When he is outside he feels relaxed and calm. "Sometimes I glanced up into the great bowl of the night sky and at the constellations scattered there and the sight was comforting and calming to me." Also this makes him think about the women in black with the wasted face and the sound that he had heard.

  1. I'm The King Of The Castle, by Susan Hill - Who Is Responsible For ...

    Kingshaw thinks to himself ' Fielding is my friend, mine.' He has managed to make a new friend and is proud of this accomplishment, but could also be a source of power over Hooper. He is afraid of Hooper controlling and taking over his life forever, so he seeks advice from Fielding.

  2. Chips with Everything - Corporal Hill

    Deformities and Misfits Pip and Smiler both have a 'deformity' that makes them stand out from the other conscripts. Pip stands out because of his upper class accent and superior attitude. However, he uses this to his advantage by capturing the conscripts' attentions with stories about his father and the upper classes to become their leader.

  1. Compare and contrast the portrayal of parent / child relationshipsin the two novels

    She strongly contradicts herself by asking Kingshaw if he has any problems and that she if always here for him. When he does finally decide to express his feelings, she immediately tells him that he is wrong. This, again, is a strong contrast to the relationship between Silas and Eppie in Silas Marner.

  2. Explore The Ways In Which The Monster In Shelly's Frankenstein And Kingshaw In I'm ...

    The note is showing the early relationship between both of them. 'I don't want you to come here' Susan Hill is demonstrating the relationship amongst them that will develop through the story. It is as though Hooper is marking his territory and Kingshaw is a threat.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work