• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Harmonium and Praise Song for my Mother Comparison English Literature GCSE

Extracts from this document...


Harmonium and Praise Song for my Mother Comparison AQA English Lit Poetry Moon on the Tides Relationships GCSE In ?Harmonium?, Armitage presents an awkward relationship between a weak, aging gfather and his embarrassed son, who finds it difficult to express his feelings. Whereas, in ?Praise Son?, Nichols portrays the love an appreciation a daughter feels for her inspirational mother, suggesting that despite physical separation, they are still as close as the you before. Armitage presents the importance of the speaker?s father and the harmonium is to him-how closely they belong to his heart. ?But its hummed harmonics still struck a chord.? ?Struck a chord? is usually a saying which usually describes an experience that has had an impact on someone and stayed in their memory for a long time. This suggests that the harmonium has had an impact for a long time, which is suggested by the ?still?. ?Still? also shows that the speaker still values it for memories he was provided with when he was younger. ...read more.


?You were? implies that her mother is dead.. ?The crab?s leg/fried plantain smell? is another Caribbean- a Caribbean speciality. Nichols shows that her mother was like the ?fried plantain smell? to her. Food is also important to sustain life. Nichols simply shows how important the mother was the speaker. In Harmonium, Armitage describes the shock he feels when his father jokes about his own death; ?And I, being me, then mouth in reply some shallow or sorry phrase or word too starved of breath to make itself heard.? It is quite a long sentence without a pause, which means that when read out loud the reader quickly becomes ?starved of breath? too, which emphasises the speaker?s feelings. Literally, it could be because the harmonium is too heavy, or it could be the shock at the thought of losing his father. Armitage presents a father who is very blunt, and makes it obvious that the son does not have his father?s humour, because it?s ?he, being him? and I. ...read more.


?futures? is plural and could either mean that she could do anything she wants and make a future, or that she will have a future as a parent, as a wife, and as someone succeeding in their career at the same time. I think that both poems display a kind of shock or realisation at the loss of a parent. In Harmonium, Armitage presents the shock of a son at the realisation that one day his father will die. In Praise Song, Nichols? character realises she must come to terms with her mother?s death and move on. I think that Nichols is much more open about the love of the narrator for her mother, simply stating the importance, presenting a stereotypical mother and daughter relationship which is open and honest. Whereas, Armitage shows a son who finds it harder to describe his feelings for his father, and shows it by using an extended metaphor of a harmonium, in order to show the reader all the memories he has had because of his father, and how he loves him. The way his father jokes about his own death is an example of the stereotypical father and son relationship; not as open about feelings. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparisons section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparisons essays

  1. morning song and catrin comparison essay

    Before the actual birth, Clarke looks out of the window at 'The people and cars' doing what they do on a normal day where as she is about to experience one of the most significant events of her life. I think she mentions traffic lights because it kind of defines giving birth.

  2. Consider how relationships are presented in Harmonium by Simon Armitage and Praise Song for ...

    In "Praise Song for My Mother", Nichols uses "You", a second person pronoun, which introduces a sense of intimacy and makes the poem very personal. This is followed by "were", a past tense verb, which indicates the poem is addressed to someone who cannot hear her or maybe is no longer alive.

  1. Post-1914 Poetry Comparison How do Plath in Morning Song and Clarke in Catrin suggest ...

    This implies to us that she feels trapped as a mother, as she doesn't know what to do. By following this with 'trailing love and conflict', it suggests to us that she feels challenged, as she know there will be arguments if she denies her daughter what she wants.

  2. Belonging "Love Song of J.Alfred Prufrock" "As You Like It"

    altering Orlando's self perception allowing him to display "Kindness nobler even then revenge, and nature stronger than his just occasion, made him give battle to the lioness" re-establishing his family ties with Oliver.

  1. Compare the way the writers of In Paris with you and Praise song for ...

    This is the reality, and the speaker doesn't appear to be bothered by it as he closes the stanza once again with the line "And I'm in Paris with you." Additionally, the sixth and final stanza opens with a repeat of the first line of the fifth stanza, "Don't talk to me of love.

  2. Love song of J. Alfred Prufrock and Portrait of a Lady comparitive piece

    The lines, "Admire the monuments, Discuss the late events, Correct our watches by the public clock's", are images of conformity and reflect the persona's and the woman's need to be accepted in society. The line also reveals the lack of depth in their relationship and the facade they create for themselves.

  1. Comparing Nettles and Praise song for my mother

    openminded and the use of enjambment at the end implies the infinite possibilities ahead of her. It is also suggesting the continuing influence she has on her daughter and that the relationship endures in spite of death or separation. The repetition of the adjective ?replenishing? encourages reflection on how the mother still provides spiritual sustenance.

  2. Comparison between 'The Hero' and 'The Soldier' (Poems) - English Lit.

    This is used by the writer to emphasise on the point and make the reader reflect further on it. Returning back to the poem, ?The Hero?, the writer has in many occasions written about the soldiers? families and their reaction to the absence of their siblings.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work