‘Hester and Katherine exploit each other, but for different reasons’. Discuss
Hester Harper is a lonely, single lady in The Well. It was her loneliness, lack of love and need for companionship that made her bring Katherine home. She did not have a life of her own. Katherine was an unloved child, who had already been rejected by people in her country until she luckily met with Hester. Katherine formed a close relationship with Hester, and soon realised that Hester was quite fond of her. Katherine fulfilled all her requirements, and Hester believed that it is the beginning of a secure and loving relationship. Hester spoiled Katherine and made her life incredibly comfortable; she did not want to ever let go of her.
Katherine was incredibly good at manipulating Hester. She displayed her care and friendliness on the first day that she was brought home, “Oh Miss Harper I will. Thank you…she hugged and kissed her.” She was all open and honest to Hester, it seemed strange that a normal person would show affection to a stranger, without even forming a close relationship. Katherine from the first day, had a concealed motive by knowing that Miss Harper was a well respected and rich lady and for this reason was already trying to take advantage of her, trying to win her love so she could be the replacement daughter and inherit Hester’s assets. There is also the time when Katherine convinced Hester to invite Joanna to come stay for a week. The suspicion gets even stronger when we learn about “Katherine’s ability and willingness in the household” and that “there was nothing Katherine could not copy or learn.” She seemed to have all the makings of an efficient criminal. It is very unusual for a young girl to be willing to stay at home and doing house chores unless they are endeavouring to achieve something. Katherine was also always trying to spoil Hester, “…I thought you’d like the sherry trifle...” There is so little mention of Katherine’s past and the orphanage except for Katherine complaints. You are also reminded, that Katherine’s past and true identity are still not revealed. Katherine influenced Hester enormously in many ways, and always had complete control of every situation.
