• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How do the poets in Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neils Song use their poems as a form of protest

Extracts from this document...


How do the poets in Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neil's Song use their poems as a form of protest? In this essay I aim to illustrate how the poems Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neil's Song are used as a form of protest. Nothing's Changed is an autobiographical poem written by Tatamkhula Afrika. He was born in Cape Town and was banned from writing and public speaking for five years in 1987 by the South African government. Charlotte O'Neil's Song was written by Fiona Farrell. She picked the name 'Charlotte O'Neil' from genuine ships' records. Both of these poems protest about past ways of life. In Nothing's Changed the speaker is a previous resident of a place called District Six, in Cape Town. The poem is about how he feels when he returns to his old home. He conveys his opinion about the way nothing has changed since he was last here - apartheid is still in South Africa. ...read more.


Nothing's Changed shocks the reader with the realisation that apartheid hasn't ended. Significant cultural differences are shown in stanzas five and six, between the white suburban living-style restaurant and the working man's caf� down the road which sells bunny chows. The restaurant flaunts its crisp white linen and roses whilst people eating at the caf� spit on the floor after sitting at plastic tables. This caf� is an appropriate illustration of District Six in the present, but it is also relevant to the past and how District Six was then. Any ordinary working-class person would have eaten at the caf�, and this stanza conveys to us a very accurate image of what it was like to live in District Six. In the poem, everything has changed physically but there is still no social change and the barrier between black and white people still remains, due to white people being wealthier than black people. Charlotte O'Neil's Song contains various themes which are; freedom, servitude, change, protest, escape, the past and the future. ...read more.


In Nothing's Changed, there has been no change in District Six from the poet's point of view and the tone is angry. However, in Charlotte O'Neil's Song, the poet is looking forward to change and the tone is much jauntier. Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neil's Song are fundamentally the same - they are set in different places but the servitude is the same. The huge contrast between the two poems is the irony in Nothing's Changed that despite the fact apartheid has ended, segregation still exists due to money; meanwhile Charlotte is capable of changing her life for the better by taking control. In conclusion, the cultures in the poems are different but they share some key elements. Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neil's Song are poems which have been written to act as a form of cultural protest, using different techniques and styles of language. In my opinion both poets portray their views on freedom successfully and the element of protest in each of the poems is communicated to the reader effectively. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Tatamkhulu Afrika: Nothings Changed section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Tatamkhulu Afrika: Nothings Changed essays

  1. Nothing's Change

    With sarcasm there is also the idea maybe if given the chance, they are just as sophisticated and classy as white people. In the final stanza the poet moves back from the window and feels the same hatred that he in his childhood at the time of the apartheid government.

  2. Analysis of Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neils song

    He also shows how angry he is by, 'and the hot, white, inwards turning anger of my eyes.' This builds up tension and makes you want to read on through the poem because you do not know what he is angry about.

  1. Compare the ways in which the poets present people in two of these poems

    The person in 'Nothing's Changed' is the poet himself. When he returns to 'District Six' he says 'and my hands, /and the skin about my bones, /and the soft.../and the...' which conveys that he is angry and frustrated. The structure also helps to add to the developing anger that he is feeling.

  2. "Charlotte O'Neil's Song" and "Nothings Changed".

    "I polished your parquet floor". This alliteration suggests her angry tone of voice. "I scraped your grate", This also suggests the roughness of her work as the scr and gr sounds are hard. The rhythm of the poem is also quite jaunty.

  1. Comparing Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neil's Song

    Then later the things that is on offer at the restaurant the black people go to: "wipe your fingers on your jeans, spit a little on the floor" he then goes on to say "it's in the bone" meaning that it is how black people have been treated for so long .

  2. I have been asked to compare two poems. I will be writing about

    hatred they had instilled over the years in the white people towards the black people was still there. They still believed apartheid was right and no government judgement was going to tell them that everything they were bought up to believe was a lie.

  1. How do the poets convey anger

    The 'and' leads up to a dramatic part of the poem. 'and my hands, and the skin about my bones, and the soft labouring of my lungs and the hot, white, inwards turning anger of my eyes.' Repetition is indicated in red. The words after the repetition grow increasingly intense.

  2. How do Seitlhamo Motsapi and Tatamkhula Afrika portray apartheid in their poems 'Andif' and ...

    image of big holes in the earth full of dead people, mass graves it shows how many people were massacred and they put them in mass graves. The theme of killing in 'Andif' is linked to death, 'genocidal frenzies', 'coffins' and 'murdered' it is telling us all the suffering and pain they had in the time of the 'apartheid'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work