• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does John Proctor change throughout the play? Does Act Four show him as a tragic hero or a desperate failure?

Extracts from this document...


How does John Proctor change throughout the play? Does Act Four show him as a tragic hero or a desperate failure? In 1952, Arthur Miller wrote a play called The Crucible. Written in a period of heightened tension in America due to the persecution of communists, Miller uses the play as a device to make a statement about that time. The play surrounds the events of the Salem witch trials of 1692, which Miller uses as an allegory for the McCarthyite persecution and the Red Scare of the time of the play's publication, which was subsequently banned. Miller remains to this day a world renowned playwright with his plays performed globally on a regular basis to this day because of the enduring messages his plays convey. John Proctor is an extremely complex character, who we as the audience come to love over the course of the play. Proctor is predominantly a typical "good man" who has a good wife, they are not criminals, and Miller's motivation is that this very fairytale image should build dramatic tension ready for something bad to happen; we expect the worse. ...read more.


This is especially true at the point when Elizabeth subtly confronts his adultery, exposing all of Proctor's weaknesses and failures. We cannot help but think that Proctor has sunk as low as he possibly can if he cannot even be happy in his home. Out of the blue, events take a shocking change of course as we see that he does care for his wife after all; he defends Elizabeth fervently when she is accused of witchcraft. At this point of high dramatic tension, we see his love for her come through as though he is a changed person displaying a vast contrast to previous events. This is particularly evident when Proctor loses his temper with a character called Cheever and proclaims "out with you" at Cheever's presentation of a warrant. The pace of the conversation at this point in the play is extremely fast and we can see that Proctor is greatly outnumbered and so is forced to snap back at any remark made, possibly without thinking as much as he should have. This sort of tribalistic fighting; against those that support the new movement of persecution and Proctor who does not, elevates him to the status of a tragic hero. ...read more.


immense sympathy for Proctor to the point where we feel we can do no more, and it is as if his fate is in God's hands. He is like any civil rights movement figure head, dieing as a true hero, hoping that the world will see its wrong, however tragically he winds up doing so. The language used at this point in the play enables us to almost hear the emotion and trouble in his voice; it enables Proctor to flip the tables and almost become the figure of authority for this brief moment, stealing it away from the Judges. In conclusion, John Proctor's character goes on a plight of status change throughout the play, seemingly able to go from being the lowest of the low to the man that everyone has respect for, visibly or not. In some respects Act Four shows that he has failed to get what he wanted, and instead ended up losing his own life, but at the same time it also shows that his intentions changed, and he finally did not care about just himself, instead leaving an impact as a martyr; a tragic hero. [WC - 1,496] ?? ?? ?? ?? Matthew Simpson 10RH ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. 'Is John Proctor A Tragic Hero?'

    The audience are more likely to empathise with Proctor for this reason. These small details that Miller gives us, are very useful to help us understand Proctor all the more clearly. (His proud nature and straight speaking ways are reasons why he eventually rips up the confession he has previously signed.)

  2. Examine miller's presentation of the marriage of John and Elizabeth proctor in the crucible. ...

    Parris reminds him that Rebecca Nurse is no immoral woman such as the others executed and there will thus be less satisfaction, and claims that he worries for his safety, having found a dagger outside his doorway. Still, Danforth refuses to postpone any of the executions.

  1. To what extent can John Proctor be described as a tragic hero in Arthur ...

    illustrates the fact that he will stand by his morals even if that means opposing those with the power to have him executed. There is no doubt that Proctor is introduced as a heroic, steadfast figure. This then leads to the audience giving John their respect.

  2. Examine how modern protagonists are caught in a classical, tragic tale of revenge and ...

    It is more laid back. Alfieri spoke in formal language, but Eddies' speech is entirely relaxed. 'Well, I'll see ya, fellas.' He appears to be a stereotypical male. Soon Catherine is added to the conversation. We are not immediately told what her role is in this play. Who is she?

  1. Do you consider John Proctor to be a modern tragic hero?

    right and courage to act, despite the risks on his own reputation. In his actions toward Elizabeth, we see he is loyal and caring. Even though he strayed from his vows, he seeks forgiveness more than anything else and puts off Abigail's advances, "I will cut off my hand before I reach for you again."

  2. John Proctor, the Tragic Hero

    The strain in the relationship is shown at the beginning of Act two when Miller uses short sentences which Elizabeth and John use to try to return to normalcy. It is also clearly shown here that they are not in love, but their feeling for each other change as John realizes his faults and his fate.

  1. Analyse and discuss the way in which Arthur Miller presents the relationship between John ...

    done the bad deed in the first place so it should be him dealing with such a situation. When the play itself was written it would have been the men in charge of the women, who were the once who saw to there every need and done everything for them.

  2. John Proctor is the tragic hero of "The Crucible". Discuss

    Towards the end of the witch trials, he publicly confessed his adulterated past about Abigail. Everything he told the court was of true nature and he did not intend to hide anything more. He signed his own written confession, denunciating the end of the witch trials.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work