• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does Miller succeed in making Eddie someone with whom the audience can sympathise?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

4. How does Miller succeed in making Eddie someone with whom the audience can sympathise? Arthur Miller wrote 'A View from the Bridge' as a modern version of a Greek tragedy, therefore, Eddie's death at the end of Act Two should be tragic. The audience have to feel pity, or pathos, towards Eddie when he dies to make the play a successful tragedy. According to 1.Aristotle's definition of a tragic hero, the hero should be noble and of high status; he should have a flaw, or hamartia, which should lead to his tragic ending; his punishment should seem to be harsher than his crime; and he should realise that his flaw has led to his tragedy. By making his play a modern version of a Greek tragedy, Miller uses the character of Alfieri, his description of Eddie as a likeable and respected man and an extreme and violent death in the arms of his wife to make the audience sympathise with him and to make him a tragic hero. Throughout the play, Miller gives his audience many reasons to respect and admire Eddie. Although there is "too much love" (p. 48) for his niece, it is also obvious that he is very protective over Catherine and genuinely cares about her. ...read more.

Middle

We're only thought of in connexion with disasters, and they'd rather not get too close." (p. 11). Later on in the play, when Catherine fell in love with Eddie, Eddie gets even more envious and angry. In his conversation with Catherine, he says "He [Rodolpho] marries you he's go the right to be an American citizen...The guy is lookin' for his break, that's all he's lookin' for." (p. 41). This shows how angry Eddie is at the fact that Catherine likes Rodolpho, and not him. Miller helps the audience sympathise with Eddie in this scene by making Catherine trust Rodolpho instead of Eddie. To a modern audience, there may be some features in Eddie that are hard not to dislike. His flaw involves love for a girl he has raised as if she was his own daughter, a terrible taboo. Also, Eddie is a parental figure who seems to expect women to do domestic work for him. Tragic heroes usually recognise their own mistakes. In Greek tragedies, this is the moment in a play when the tragic hero appreciates their own weakness and their own responsibility. However, throughout the play, Eddie does not admit to himself the truth about loving Catherine. Although Beatrice tries to make him face this truth by saying "You want somethin' else, Eddie and you can never have her" (p. ...read more.

Conclusion

Right from the beginning, Miller makes it obvious that Eddie would die in the end. Alfieri keeps giving clues to the audience about Eddie being destined to die, saying he felt "powerless... and watched it run its bloody course." (p. 12) Another quote from Alfieri is, "I knew where he [Eddie] was heading for, I knew where he was going to end." (p. 50) These quotes make us feel more pity for Eddie because, even when he seems happy and loving, we still know he is heading towards a "bloody" (p. 12) end. Miller successfully makes Eddie a sympathetic character by making him fit the tragic hero he is supposed to be. The audience goes from admiring Eddie to getting to know his terrible guilty secret. Through the whole play we get the unescapable feeling that he is heading towards his "bloody" end and that it is his 'guilty secret' that will cause it. Although for some modern theatre audiences, Eddie may seem to be an old-fashioned man and although he never really admits his own faults, Miller uses Alfieri's character to make sure we can still feel the intended pity. I think this is Miller's greatest achievement in this play, reminding us that we are all human, guilty in some ways, and that we should feel sorry for ourselves and Eddie for that. Word Count: 1,000 Resources used: 1. http://vccslitonline.cc.va.us/tragedy/aristotle.htm ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

5 star(s)

Response to the question

Response to Question
In this question, it is very important candidates read the question carefully, and focus on the ways in which Miller makes Eddie a sympathetic character, and not if this is the case or not. This candidate succeeds ...

Read full review

Response to the question

Response to Question
In this question, it is very important candidates read the question carefully, and focus on the ways in which Miller makes Eddie a sympathetic character, and not if this is the case or not. This candidate succeeds in this, examining the techniques used by Miller to characterise Eddie in a very extensive and developed way. The inclusion of Aristotle's definition of tragedy also shows depth and further research, signalling to examiners that this is a very strong candidate.

Level of analysis

Level of Analysis
The candidate's analysis of the text is excellent. The candidate uses a lot of quotations to support their arguments with between 2-6 quotes per paragraph, showing a solid knowledge of the text. The use of the Point, Evidence, Analysis formula also demonstrates a higher level candidate, and an example of the analytical part of the PEA formula is "This quote shows the audience that Eddie disapproves of this..." In this, the candidate is explaining the effect that the line has on the audience, marking them out as an A or A* student.

Quality of writing

Quality of Writing
The candidate's essay is of a high standard, with excellent quality of written communication. Quotations are integrated into sentences well, making for a much better flowing essay, for example "Beatrice tries to make him face this truth by saying “You want somethin’ else..."". However, providing page references is not necessary, as examiners are unlikely to check the quotations used (but do not use this as an excuse to misquote!) and depending on the edition of the text, the page numbers for the quotes used may be different. The referencing of Aristotle's definition of tragedy is a good technique, showing a strong candidate and learning to reference properly will stand students in good stead for further and higher education.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by ecaudate 03/04/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Can 'Death of a Salesman' be Described as a Tragedy?

    4 star(s)

    for the play being a tragedy can be flipped to argue against that too. Willy being a 'hero of his household' may not be accepted by some as a valid argument. Instead, they would say that since Willy does not live up to the high standards of all other heroes

  2. A View From the Bridge - The whole of this play involves symbolism, on ...

    This gives the play more energy.code der sededew orde dek inde fode de. Dramatic momentscoba bar sebabaw orba bak inba foba ba; Note how the conversations are broken up by scenes of dramatic action: e.g. Heidegger theorised parita20's rationalisation .

  1. Proctor, hero or Villain?

    he appears confrontational and defensive when questioned. He does well until he comes to the last few Proctor: Thou shall not make unto thee any graven image Hale: You have said that twice, sir Proctor: Aye All the evidence suggests that john proctor does not show signs of a hero but of a villain.

  2. None of the characters in Arthur Millers 'The Crucible' are wholly blameless for the ...

    Despite his attempt at niceties the cold and suspicious tone of his wife as they converse. Although this is deserved it causes a sense of pity for Proctor, as the audience is aware that he has told the truth and is questing for forgiveness from his unrelenting wife 'I think you're sad again.

  1. Does Arthur Miller Succeed In Making The Audience Sympathise With Eddie Carbone In 'A ...

    I'm responsible for you.' As the play progresses more and more incident which make you feel negatively towards him unfold. The major incident was when he came in drunk and kissed her and Rodolfo. 'He reaches out suddenly, draws her to him and as she strives to free herself he kisses her on the mouth.'

  2. Arthur Miller's Tragic Heroes

    living, is because she could not could with the idea of her son being dead. This is not so, it is in fact, that her sons death would be a punishment for Joes crime, which would be intolerable for her, so she continues to support Joe's deceit.

  1. To what extent can we sympathise with Eddie and to what extent do we ...

    Catherine loves this part of him and it is this, which makes her attracted to him. Eddie is again looking on the bad side of Rodolfo and decides that he only wants to marry her to gain American citizenship. Catherine has chosen Rodolfo and has decided to move away with

  2. To what extent can 'The Crucible' be viewed as a Classical Tragedy?

    I think not.' John resents her suspicions and believes that Elizabeth has no right to judge him more, 'still an everlasting funeral marches around your heart. I cannot speak but I am doubted, every moment judged for lies'. John believes he can do naught to please her and this quote shows that he believes her love from him has died.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work