• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does Peter Medak gain the viewers sympathy for Derek Bentley in the film, 'Let Him Have it'?

Extracts from this document...


How does Peter Medak gain the viewers sympathy for Derek Bentley in the film, 'Let Him Have it'? The film 'Let Him Have It', tells the real-life story of Derek Bentley. Derek is a nineteen year old epileptic who is caught breaking into a shed in his early youth. He is sent to approved school but is released early due to his epilepsy and his low IQ. It is later on discovered that Derek has the mental age of eleven, this plays a great part in the injustice later on. After his release he ends up being involved with a local youth, Christopher Craig, an American style gangster with a dangerous hobby. Derek follows Chris around, undertaking any activity which he does. One of these includes a midnight robbery of a warehouse. This, however, turns drastically wrong when Chris ends up shooting two officers, fatally wounding one whilst injuring another. Both boys are found guilty of murder and Chris is imprisoned, leaving Derek to face the death penalty. Despite obvious bias and protests, the sentence is carried out. The story is so controversial for many reasons. One was being Derek's mental age of eleven. Any eleven-year-old would not be allowed in court, let alone face the death penalty. There was also strong bias on behalf of the judge involved, pressuring the jury into their verdict. It was also an unfair charge as Derek did not actually commit the murder. In this essay, I will discuss how Medak uses lots of close-ups for emphasis on Derek's emotions; how he seems never to fit in and is alienated from his problems; different camera angles and lighting angles used to create emphasis; how Derek and Chris' lives are contrasting and are made to look obvious; how innocence is used as a tool to make us associate it with Derek; the clothing Derek wears and the connotations of those styles of dressing and the issues of the story (justice and bias) ...read more.


This means he does not fit in, in the two places he should (with his friends and with his family). This is another device Medak has used to create sympathy. There are some scenes in the film, in which Medak uses a mixture of devices to create sympathy. These scenes are particularly interesting as they give the viewer a chance to create a better impression of him. This in turn creates sympathy as the scenes are particularly traumatic, and we can empathise with Derek being involved in such situations, no eleven year old should be put through. One of these scenes is the trial scene. Derek is being charged with the murder of P.C. Miles. The scene opens with a view of Chris Craig who is sat, looking very different to Derek. He has a smug impression on his face, showing he has no respect for authority. It is obvious in the early scenes that Derek does and so we again feel the two should not have been involved together. After the injured police officer and Chris have been interviewed, it is Derek's turn in the dock. He is immediately seen as uncomfortable in the situation. He is stammering badly as he tries to answer. This relates to the way in which a young child would act in the situation - this behaviour is seen throughout the scene. They query Chris's gun collection, of which Derek is unaware. They accuse him of knowing he was in possession of a gun on the night of the murder, which Derek denies truthfully. However, the judge and the barrister continue to pressure him to say otherwise. Derek's head is bowed as he cannot seem to bear looking up and facing the problem in front of him. This conduct also resembles that of a youngster. As the barrister pummels Derek with questions, the camera flicks between the faces of the barrister, Derek and the judge. The effects of the intense camera shots mirror the intensity of Derek's emotions. ...read more.


This is a very poignant moment as it signifies the end of Derek's time on Earth. As you can see, Medak has used many devices to gain the viewer's sympathy for Derek. He has used clothing, the way it shows his innocence and how it mirrors his dad's style, therefore highlighting his juvenile mentality; how he has used close-ups and extreme close-ups to make it easier to realise what he is thinking and sympathise with that; how lighting is also used to symbolise his innocence, or the opposite (in this case, dark to show criminal activity); how he has shown Derek as not fitting in with anyone and being alienated from his situations and consequently feel sorry that he cannot fit in; how he blatantly compares Chris' and Derek's lives to make it obvious Derek should not have been involved with them in the first place as they are total opposites and so sympathy is felt when he gets into trouble, as he should not really have been involved with them. Also, how Medak mixes all the things mentioned above to generate scenes which combine to make scenes of great emotion which are easy to empathise with. The opinion of Medak is quite obvious to thinking Bentley was innocent, and the way he uses Derek's innocence versus the dark, gangster style of Chris makes this plain to see. The overall message of the film seems to be to prove Derek's innocence. The sympathy generated during the film makes this point clear, as in every scene there is an instance in which Derek is shown to be just a simple child who wants a nice life with his parents. He is very biased in his opinions, and shows this during the court scene where the Judge and jury are biased against Derek despite the obvious innocence. The devices he uses are very effective, as it is very easy to identify with Derek and his family, so you can sympathise with the situation he is in. The film overall, I feel puts this point across well. Media Coursework 'Let Him Have It' Louise Tarsky ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    An analysis of the ways in which two non-fiction texts present a biased account ...

    4 star(s)

    The article goes on to use key words and phrases such as; the London crime wave, battle of Sidney street, bandits, gangsters, Sten gun and gunmen. These words and phrases raise feeling of anger and fear in the reader towards the two young men who were involved in the armed robbery.

  2. A View From the Bridge

    praying in the church. You understand?" This means that Marco is asking God to pardon him for what he is about to do. Because of the tension, the audience can guess that Marco is on his way to kill Eddie.

  1. How is Genocide Presented in The Boys in Striped Pyjamas and Hitel Rwanda

    he was extremely proud of his father, never did he know again that his father made the fake film, and is actually keeping the Jews weak and close to death before killing them. This shows he strongly believes in what he is shown, the naivety of the young boy.

  2. how does the director paul greengrass create tension in the film united 93

    One passenger shout out "GO!", and then this is followed by shouts. The terrorist with the bomb is then lashing out with his knife wildly, but then gets kicked down by the passenger that shouted go. He then gets taken to the floor and gets beaten up by all the passengers.

  1. the midnight betrayal

    "It's time for prison industry, George. Stay close to me and we might be put in the same room," Fernando quickly said to George as the guard came into the room, and started shouting at the two and pointing at the door.

  2. comparing newspaper articles

    The article contains the opinion of more than one person but with the same opinion which makes them seem like there are more people on their side and more people agree with them, 'John Webster.......new evidence presented fast-growing strains of broiler chickens are prone to leg disorders.'

  1. Male and female gender roles in brick (film noir)

    I think that this adds to the whole weirdness. He is the Boss of all the things that are happening. He tries very hard to always appear really powerful and strong; but underneath the facade there all is not as it seems. In one of the scenes were he is trying to impress Brendan and takes him somewhere to

  2. How does Bronte create sympathy for Jane Eyre?

    Also, because Bronte has written the novel in the first person, we see everything for the point of view of Jane Eyre and therefore more sympathy is felt towards Jane as the reader can be more in touch with the way she is feeling and the way she is treated first hand.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work