• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does the play highlight the contrasts between the different philosophies of Arthur Birling and Inspector Goole?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How does the play highlight the contrasts between the different philosophies of Arthur Birling and Inspector Goole? Set in 1912, and first performed in 1945 An inspector calls by J.B. Priestley shows the impact the Birling family have on vulnerable Eva Smith. After being thrown out of one job by Arthur, Sheila's petty jealousy turning her out of another, Gerald's affair, Eric's drunken mistake, and Sybil's cold heatedness, Eva feels she can't go on any longer and takes her life. This play demonstrates the selfishness of capitalists, and using all the things that happened between 1912 and 1945, and the warning of "fire and blood and anguish", Priestley puts across the message that if things don't change, we shall all pay the price for our actions. The opening stage directions give an insight into Birling's character. "Birling is a heavy looking rather portentous man in his middle fifties with fairly easy manners but rather provincial in his speech." In the opening scene Priestley wants to make it obvious that Birling is new money "They worked us hard in those days and kept us short of cash" This shows how Birling had to work his way up the class system. This would make you think that he would have some sympathy for the working class, but he doesn't: "lower costs and higher prices" this show his hypocrisy which is reflected through the rest of family (some more than others) at the start of the play. The stage directions also describe him as a portentous man, meaning that he is solemn and impressive but also implying the foreshadowing of an unhappy end. ...read more.

Middle

Priestley used this to heighten the audiences dislike for Birling even more, especially when Eric comes out with some very good points, contradicting Birling's clouded view of the world: "what about war?" At the start of the play, the inspector values Eric's opinion more than Mr Birling does. "It isn't if you can't go and work somewhere else"..."quite so"... "(to Eric) Look you stay out of this" This, not only shows the contrasts between the Inspector and Birling, but also between Eric and Birling. Whilst the Inspector interrogates Eric he doesn't treat him very harshly because he can see that he is already feeling very guilty: "You know, don't you?" Eric already knows that the Inspector is asking about things that they should feel guilty about because he was there when the Inspector was interrogating Mr Birling. When the inspector said Eric may have to get back up again if he went to bed Eric must have known his actions would come up. Another reason the inspector must have known Eric was already feeling guilty was that Eric was obviously more willing to tell him what he had done than the others, particularly Mrs Birling who stands firmly by her beliefs, that she had done absolutely nothing wrong, all the way through. Eric represents someone with more of a conscience than Birling. Eric can see what he has done to Eva Smith is wrong. However he is also weak as he does not see these feelings through by helping Eva. Mr Birling treats Sheila more like a child, who is too na�ve to hear about these things, than a grown woman in her early twenties: "Well go to bed then." ...read more.

Conclusion

You could think of him just as a normal man, who, having heard of the Birling family's selfish acts, wishes to help them change for the better. Or he could be a conscience to make them feel guilty about what they've done, and stop distancing themselves from the working class. He could also be the ghost of Eva Smith in another form to make them pay for what they've done. His surname also indicates this as it is a homonym of ghoul, another word for ghost. I conclude that Birling represents the views of capitalists and the inspector represents the views of socialists. Priestley makes Birling a weak, unintelligent, ignorant and Selfish character who rambles on a bit and desperate to fit in with the higher class that he follows his wife's lead. Sybil seems to guide her husband, Telling him what he should or shouldn't say, this is made evident when she disapproves with him saying: "Good dinner too - Sybil tell cook for me." Mrs Birling would disapprove because saying what good food it was, wasn't considered a polite thing because it is like fishing for compliments from Gerald. She doesn't like him saying tell cook for me because it implies they talk to their servants, which wouldn't have been done in those days. Birling also copies Gerald's father's (his social superior) choice of wine, to make Gerald think that he is marrying into a family with as much money as his. In contrast, Priestley makes the inspector appear as a person who speaks carefully, is intelligent, knows what is going on in the world, is very strong and comes across as a kinder, selfless person; Priestley uses this to make the audience think that a socialist society will provide a fairer, more just solution to the world's problems. By Anna Mckean ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE J.B. Priestley section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE J.B. Priestley essays

  1. Who is inspector Goole and what is his function in the play? How may ...

    who believed in "lower costs and higher prices". When the Inspector gives his final speech about social responsibility " we are all members of one body; we are responsible for each other. And I tell you that the time will soon come when, if men will not learn that lesson, they will be taught in fire, blood and anguish.

  2. An Inspector calls Compare and contrast the way in which Arthur and Sheila Birling ...

    Sheila Birling learns a lot during the play and undergoes a change that usually only happens over a longer period of time. This sudden change is caused by what she has to go through during the play. First, she finds out that she contributed towards Eva's suicide.

  1. Examine How Priestley Uses a Variety of Dramatic Devices To Highlight the Theme of ...

    When they find out that there hasn't they know that the inspector is a hoax. There is then a call from a police officer saying that a girl has committed suicide after swallowing disinfectant. I believe that the Priestley did this for a reason.

  2. "An Inspector Calls" - issues raised in the play concerning the social structure ...

    The audience will probably pick up on this and it creates a sense of tension, this is obviously a subject which Gerald and Sheila feel badly about and the audience becomes interested in what it means, it stands out as the happy situation of the engagement party has been tarnished slightly.

  1. Closely examine the character of Mr Arthur Birling and his daughter Sheila Birling showing ...

    to the time when the Crofts and Birlings are no longer competing but are working together." Mr Birling does not treat the working class people as normal people who deserve wages and due respect; he just exploits them and pays them with great reluctance.

  2. Write About The Ways In Which Birling, Eric and Gerald Treat Women

    This passage also shows the Mr Birling is both arrogant and ignorant. Mr Birling is also very wealthy but not through inheritance but hard work, whilst his wife Sybil on the other hand is an aristocrat she therefore was born into money.

  1. Analyse the character of Inspector Goole. Compare and contrast him with Arthur Birling. What ...

    In fact, the inspector manages to have the characters admit to the truth and does not have to force them into confession at all. He works very systematically; he likes to deal with one person at a time. As Sheila puts it, "He's giving us the rope - so that we'll hang ourselves."

  2. Discuss the Importance of the Inspector 'Goole' in this play:

    don't understand why you should come here, Inspector" the word come here indicates that their sort (rich and popular) should not be questioned because of their high popularity in the village, and saying that his sort in society should be excluded from all acts of crime and investigations made.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work