• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does Willy Russell present differences between Mr Briggs and Mrs Kay

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How does Willy Russell present differences between Mr Briggs and Mrs Kay in "Our day Out"? Willy Russell contrasts two teachers in the play "Our Day Out" in order to present different teaching attitudes. The play is set in 1970's Liverpool, which was poverty-stricken and had high levels of unemployment. By having this setting Russell gives the teachers difficult children to teach and the play seems to test who will deal with the children best. Russell doesn't make either of the teachers perfect but exposes their true feelings to show what attributes a good teacher should have. Mr Briggs is strict but willing to teach whereas Mrs Kay is fun and sympathetic but has lost hope in teaching the students. In my opinion Russell seems more approving of Mr Briggs, especially by the end of the play. Mrs Kay and Mr Briggs have very different relationships and attitudes to the children in the Progress Class. The differences are between the teachers are revealed through the handling of and treatment of the children. They have different characteristics but neither of them can be said to be entirely positive or negative in the eyes of the audience and also the children. Mrs Kay is relaxed and gentle with children whereas Mr Briggs is far stricter and more demanding of the Progress Class. This is apparent as soon as the play starts so the audience admire Mrs Kay over Mr Briggs at the beginning. ...read more.

Middle

He says that Mrs Kay's "philosophy is all over the place" and that he views her as being the "champion of non-academics". By saying this Mr. Briggs implies that he feels that she is not fit to be a teacher. When Mr Briggs is complaining about Mrs Kay's organisational skills, she suddenly changes plans from going to Conway Castle to going to the zoo first. It is very ironical that Mr Briggs finds this out just as he is complaining about her. The teaching methods of Mr. Briggs and Mrs Kay shows that both the teachers are at extremes and at opposite ends. It is good to be patient and generous but Mrs Kay is too generous and laid back. It is also necessary to be firm and be responsible but Mr Briggs is far too strict. He needs to be slightly more sympathetic to the children while Mrs Kay needs to be firm and take responsibility. Using songs in the play is a technique used by Russell to give important ideas. Many of the songs are sung by the children; these songs tell us something about the children. For example in the first song, "We're Goin' Out", the line, "Goin' off somewhere far away", hints to the audience that the children are not very bright as they are not aware of where they are going or if its the right direction to go in. The reason for this may be as it is the first time they are travelling out of Liverpool. "Me mam says I can go ... ...read more.

Conclusion

At first the pupils try to touch Mr Briggs but he does not like it: "Girl1 and Girl 2 go to link arms with Briggs. He shrugs them off" this shows that he does not wish to associate with the children but after his character change on the cliff scene, " He stands with his arms wrapped around [Carol]." The audience also learn something about the teachers from the children themselves. Despite the Progress Class seeing Mr Briggs as a strict and constantly moaning teacher, many times in the play is it implied that the children want to learn something from the teacher. The Castle Song, Song 12, shows this: "Tell us, Sir go on, we want to learn from you sir" and "We'd be really brainy, Sir, if all the teachers were like you". This shows that Mr Briggs is the only one of the teachers that will teach and has any hope for them. This shows Mr Briggs in a positive light and Mrs Kay in a negative light as the Progress Class do not seem to believe that they can learn from Mrs Kay. Willy Russell seems to criticising teachers of the time because of their negative attitudes towards poor students and the lack of hope teachers have for these students. Russell compares the two different teachers at two extremes to show what a good teacher should be like. In conclusion it seems that Mr Briggs has a better attitude towards the teaching profession because he is responsible and always has hope for his students, although some of Mrs Kay's attributes, such as her kindness and generosity, should be taken into account. Grade - B/A ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Our Day Out section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Our Day Out essays

  1. Compare the characters of Mrs Kay and Mr Briggs from Willy Russells our day ...

    He thinks that the trip should just be learning no fun and nothing else but when Mrs Kay decides to take the class for a quick visit to the Zoo Mr Briggs is not at all happy "but I thought this trip was organised so that the kids could see Conwy castle?"

  2. Our Day Out - How and why Mr Briggs changes

    way she treats them, they care for her as she does for them. Along with being a motherly figure Mrs Kay is also a good friend to the progress class, she is understanding and always on their side - never any one else's.

  1. Our Day Out - character study of Mr Briggs

    "You two .... off! Go on move." Carol and Adrews go but Mrs kay is angry too. "I was taking to those children!" Mrs ka and briggs argue about the trip. "...they are left to race abd chase abd play havoc" "You're on their side arent you?"

  2. Our Day Out by Willy Russel - Scene 31 Conway Castle Analysis

    Then Mr Briggs gets anxious, in a way be-friends her, smiling, showing warmth, and a fatherly image. If it means keeping his job he would rather smile for a few seconds than let his job go because of a small girl who was not going to change his life.

  1. Our day out by Willy Russell - review

    "Look...Carol" He starts to speak to her personally and calls her by her first name. Here Russell wants the audience to start to take a liking to Briggs. The start of a personal relationship with the students is conveyed. Briggs is idealistic and says to Carol "What's to stop you

  2. Compare the characters of Mrs Kay and Mr Briggs from Willy Russell's "Our day ...

    "Speak quietly to the person next to you", "look nicely at the scenery outside" and many more. This also shows how the two teachers believe the progress class should behave, it is difficult to decide which is more effective but they are completely different styles of teaching.

  1. Our Day Out - Analyse the cliff scene in detail showing how Russell uses ...

    'Briggs with Andrews asleep next to him sees the familiar surroundings and the kids hanging about the streets. He sits up puts his tie back to normal goes to straighten his hair and feels the cowboy hat'. Its home to Mr Briggs when the coach arrives into Liverpool and makes him realise the responsibility and concern of his reputation.

  2. Look at the Way Tension is Built up in Scene 35. Examine the Characters ...

    Where it's nice." Mr. Briggs replies with the original line "Stay here? How could you stay here? What would you do? Where would you live?" Carol then adds more tension by telling Mr. Briggs that he doesn't care, which of course is true in one aspect but in another aspect he does.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work