• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Effective Do You Find "Speckled Band" and "Lamb To The Slaughter" as Murder Mysteries?

Extracts from this document...


How Effective Do You Find "Speckled Band" and "Lamb To The Slaughter" as Murder Mysteries? Before we read any murder mystery there are certain criteria and rules that we expect to find in the story and usually the way we judge a murder mystery is by how well the story fits our prior expectations. In typical murder mysteries we usually expect to have a psychopathic but usually intelligent murderer and a weak helpless victim, we expect a big mansion as the setting and a highly intelligent and quirky detective solving the case. The setting of a murder story is a very important feature and much emphasis is usually put on the setting, as this is where much of the story takes place. My expectation for the setting in a murder mystery is an eerie old place like an old mansion, which is found in many murder mysteries. In Lamb to the Slaughter, at the scene of the crime there is a very calm and relaxed atmosphere "The room was warm and clean, the curtains drawn, the two table lamps alight - hers and the one by the empty chair opposite." It seems like an idyllic family house and the married pair seems very content, there is no initial feeling of hostility. ...read more.


'It is not cold which makes me shiver... It is terror'. As for money, it is revealed that Helen Stoner is about to come into a fairly large amount. She says that an agreement was made whereby all her mother's fortune was to go to Dr Roylott, 'with a provision that a certain annual sum should be allowed to each of us in the event of our marriage'. Later in the plot, Holmes uncovers the will of Helen Stoner's mother, and finds out 'each daughter can claim an income of �250, in case of marriage.' So, from all these quotes, we can determine that after Helen Stoner's wedding, Dr Roylott would have had to given her �250 per year- an amount which could have ruined him, as at the time the story was set, �250 had much more value than it does now. The Speckled Band does a very good job of presenting a victim to whom we can relate as she is the sort of person we expected to find before reading any of the story. In Lamb to the Slaughter, looking at the description of Mary Maloney at the beginning of the story, she seems to be the perfect choice for the victim of this story yet Dahl keeps using unconventional methods and she is not. ...read more.


Neither of the endings fitted my expectations very well and were different in almost every way, they were both very original but in my opinion did not make either story very effective as murder mysteries. Comparing the two stories for effectiveness is not very easy as neither story is perfect, I found The Speckled Band to be a better murder mystery mainly because in Lamb to the Slaughter there was no mystery about it, it was just a story about a woman killing her husband which left it a bit unfulfilling. The Speckled Band stuck to many of the rules that I outlined as expectations of a murder mystery and so overall was quite effective and throughout was conventional in almost every aspect. Lamb to the Slaughter however bent many of the rules of a typical murder mystery and was original in contrast to The Speckled Band's conventionality. The main ingredient of a detective story is that the villain is caught and justice is achieved. This happens in The Speckled Band, with the poetic justice of Dr Roylott's death, but in Lamb to the Slaughter it doesn't, and the villain gets completely over-looked. Even if they had found her out, they wouldn't have any evidence. Many ingredients are missing in Lamb to the Slaughter, so for this reason I find The Speckled Band to be more effective as a murder mystery. 1 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Roald Dahl section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Roald Dahl essays

  1. Both Lamb to the slaughter and the Speckled Band share some characteristics of murder ...

    'Knelt down beside him and began to weep her heart out' - here she is overcome by emotion and remorse despite having killed her husband herself. Also, 'her first instinct was to reject it all'. 'She might find none of it had ever happened'.

  2. Compare 'Lamb to the Slaughter' with 'The Speckled Band', assessing their effectiveness as examples ...

    Holmes takes his work seriously. He chooses to take on cases and so he sees it as his personal goal to solve them. "I can only say, madam, that I shall be happy to devote the same care to your case" Holmes is very polite, and again I think this

  1. Comparing Rhoda Brook-"The Withered Arm" and Mary Maloney-"Lamb to the slaughter".

    She was happy to find that they had checked the greengrocer out and even happier when the detective came back and she realised that they did not suspect her. The position of the woman in this story was that she sat at home waiting for him to come home every

  2. Compare "Lamb to the Slaughter" and "The Speckled Band" commenting on any differences I ...

    "......bewildered eyes......" "......a kind of dazed horror......" On the contrary, Helen Stoner is tense and scared. She goes to Holmes for help but fears at what her step dad would do if he found out about her business. "It is fear, Mr Holmes.

  1. Compare and Contrast two Murder Mysteries

    Julia's room, as the door was locked from the inside, and the only window in the room was boarded up and had grills on the outside.

  2. Compare the Two Short Stories, 'The Speckled Band' And 'Lamb To The Slaughter'.

    This is usually done by the detective. It reveals the true events to the reader so at the end of the story nothing is left to be questioned and the case is truly closed. 'The Speckled Band' is typical reflection of this basic structure but 'Lamb To The Slaughter' is not.

  1. Comparison between Murder Mystery stories - " Lamb to the slaughter" and "Speckled Band".

    this atmosphere does not change but I do feel that the room gets much more tense as he almost brings a dull feeling to the house. I think this is because he is very unpleasant and says very little to Mary, which we have already learnt, would do almost anything for him.

  2. Explore How The Women Are Portrayed In The Texts The Withered Arm and Lamb ...

    She is a stereotypical middle-class housewife of the mid 20th Century. She exudes respectability. At the start of the story Roald Dahl shows her to the reader as a very 'tranquil' woman 'without anxiety' and with 'a slow smiling air'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work