How Far Do You Agree With Malcolms Assessment of Macbeth as a Butcher and of Lady Macbeth as a Fiend-like Queen?

Authors Avatar

How Far Do You Agree With Malcolm’s Assessment of Macbeth as a ‘Butcher’ and of Lady Macbeth as a ‘Fiend-like Queen’?

At the end of William Shakespeare’s play ‘Macbeth’, Malcolm the newly crowned king of Scotland states that Macbeth the ‘butcher’ and the ‘fiend-like queen’, Lady Macbeth, are dead, their tyranny gone with them. In the course of the play Macbeth progresses from a nobleman of Scotland to a tyrannical leader. While Lady Macbeth progresses from a ‘fiend-like queen’ to a woman who is reconciling yet deranged and suicidal.

Macbeth is depicted as a butcher, but he was not always so. Infact at the beginning of the play he was a Scottish nobleman who fought for his king and country. A wounded captain on the battlefield, Act 1 Scene 2 line 16, told of Macbeth                                                                                “For brave Macbeth-well he deserves that name….like valour’s minion he carved out his passage.”

But once he         stumbled across the witches he changed. He begins to fathom the possibility that he may be king. He demands more from the three witches.

 “Stay you imperfect speakers. Tell me more.”

 His wife reads the letter that she has been sent from Macbeth and persuades him to kill Duncan.

Act 1 Scene 7, Macbeth decides to kill Duncan and this is where Macbeth begins his descent into evil, thinking only about his success.

I have no spur to prick the sides of my intent, but only vaulting ambition.”

Macbeth fights against his ill will and refuses to kill Duncan after a time of thinking to himself. He says to his wife.

We will go no further in this business.”

 But after persuasion by his wife, he finally commits himself to perform the murder. Lady Macbeth begins to plot the murder.

Join now!

However this section of the play shows that Macbeth found it hard to believe that killing his own cousin was the right thing to do. When going to kill Duncan he sees a hallucination.

Is this a dagger I see before me?... Come let me clutch thee

As he moves to kill Duncan, his thoughts are all of evil. Once the bell rings he begins his first act that condemns him. The language between the two here is quick paced and in short sentences, to show that they are nervous and want to keep quiet what they have done.

...

This is a preview of the whole essay