• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"How far do you think that the play is about the struggle for power between men and women? In forming your response, evaluate the different critical standpoints & consider the importance of historical context."

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"How far do you think that the play is about the struggle for power between men and women? In forming your response, evaluate the different critical standpoints & consider the importance of historical context." "The Winter's Tale" explores a wide variety of themes such as art and nature, disguise and reality, justice and injustice, but the most prominent theme is definitely the struggle for power between men and women, especially when considering the historical context of the play. Since The Winter's Tale's creation it has been performed to many different audiences. Each particular audience will interpret the play differently due to the context of beliefs and attitudes that exist at that time. Many factors determine the context, and therefore determine how 'The Winter's Tale' is construed. A Jacobean audience will have accessed ideas that are pertinent to Jacobean times, whereas a modern audience will consider meanings that are relevant to a modern context. 'The Winter's Tale' is therefore ambiguous, as a number of different interpretations can be formed. The role of women is a conceptual context that is inherent within many of Shakespeare's plays, such as "The Winter's Tale', 'King Lear' and 'Macbeth'. The persistence of the theme therefore creates a context itself, through which an interpretation of the text may be reached. ...read more.

Middle

Looking at the play from a Feminist viewpoint Leontes' behaviour and language are reflective of the repressive structure of society, where sexual degradation is a tool for women's repression. Shakespeare uses this language to portray Leontes publicly degrading Hermione, however her reciprocation is done honourably: "Should a villain say so. The most replenished villain in the world, He were as much more villain. You, my Lord, Do but mistake" She insists that he must have made a 'mistake' as only 'the most replenished villain' would say such things. The use of the noun "villain" distances her attack from being personal. Hermione also uses the subjective 'if', showing how she skilfully manipulates her subject. She behaves in a way, which is paradoxical to Leontes' suspicions. Shakespeare does this to intensify Leontes' paranoia and Hermione's sense of justice. Shakespeare uses this contrast as a device to ensure that we can see the different powers that Leontes and Hermione posses. Leontes is superficial and brash whereas Hermione is confident and thoughtful. Shakespeare is showing us that Hermione knows how to use her power in an ethical way, in comparison to Leontes who uses-his rashly with selfish intentions. She is representative of the eloquent stoicism we associate with heroines of Greek tragedy. ...read more.

Conclusion

Throughout The Winter's Tale' the female characters demonstrate an ability to subtly demonstrate authority over the male characters, thus avoiding any misunderstandings and allowing the men to maintain their dignity. Shakespeare uses these subtleties to portray the dangers of absolute power. Despite the overwhelming power of the kings, the only two to triumph in the conflict are Hermione and Perdita. They both show themselves to be above the corrupt actions of the kings whilst maintaining the highest level's of dignity throughout. While the struggle for power consumes Leontes and Polixenes, it is the struggle for equality and the right to speak that the women pursue. At the end of the play, despite the hardship suffered by all characters it appears that this struggle for equality is not over. Paulina is speaking and Leontes interrupts: "0 peace, Paulina" This suggests that despite all his protestations of reform he has still not grasped the concept of equality and freedom of speech, emphasizing the ongoing "....struggle for power between men and women?" Daniel Maddock 2000 Words Approx. Reference Material. William Shakespeare's "The Winter's Tale" J.H.Pafford's Introduction to The Winter's Tale Penguin Critical studies - Shakespeare's sources for The Winter's Tale Secondary sources - "The Winter's Tale" The Early Reviews. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Winters Tale section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Winters Tale essays

  1. In Death and The Maiden, Paulina's struggle is symbolic of the struggle of oppressed ...

    Roberto, and she speaks about how she can not ever listen to Schubert again because of the memories and pain it brings back. Also the fact that she talks about being 'vulnerable again', and Gerardo having to 'take care of me all over again'(Act I, Scene I, pg5), shows that

  2. How does Shakespeare present relationships between men and women in The Winter's Tale, ...

    Staging can answer these questions: Hermione's degree of enthusiasm illustrates her degree of love for Leontes.

  1. How are women represented in "The Winter's Tale"? How might a modern audience react ...

    jeopardised the future of the throne by not having a son for a long period of time. It is perhaps implied that, by the end of the play, Leontes's life has been controlled by women. Leontes's oppression of Hermione and his attempted oppression of Paulina at the beginning are ironic

  2. It has been said that in "The Winter's Tale" Shakespeare dramatises the contemporary struggle ...

    an adultress he is reduced to insulting Paulina calling her "Dame Partlet", "Callat", Lozel" and "hag." This would have brought a different reaction to a modern audience, from the Jacobean one, who would have considered it an outrage that a woman would have questioned a man, let alone a king, who had been 'chosen by God'.

  1. Explore the role of women in 'The Winters Tale'

    She says she has lost Leontes love, "the crown and comfort" of her life, she is "barred" from Mamilius like one "infectious" and she has lost her newborn baby. The focus of the play transfers to the oracle and it's contents.

  2. How does Shakespeare present relationships between men and women in The Winter's Tale and ...

    In the character of Paulina, Shakespeare creates a female antagonist who is able to challenge the traditional roles of wife, widow and of women in general. Paulina speaks in an aggressive and challenging tone to Leontes despite his authority, likewise with Antigonus she speaks in a tone, which would not have been considered feminine in Shakespeare's time.

  1. Consider how play writes make characters speak in play's you have studied and say ...

    if truth really is helpful or not, as it could be a tool for vengeance and division. It also forces readers to analyse the issue on if the truth is in reality helpful or not for Paulina or/and Gerardo. Along both plays, there are many interruptions being made.

  2. Discuss The Presentation Of Women In The Winter’s Tale.

    this when she retorts to Leontes, "it is the heretic who makes the fire, not she who burns in't." In Shakespeare's time, women could be sentenced to death for retorting to a man, and in this respect I believe that Shakespeare is trying to make the audience believe that women can be valued as much as men.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work