• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far is it possible to feel sympathy for Laura and not Hedda?

Extracts from this document...


Jasmine Seippel, IB06, English A1 Standard world literature essay How far is it possible to feel sympathy for Laura and not Hedda? Throughout both plays of "Hedda Gabler" and "The Father" one may feel that Laura and Hedda are both evil, manipulative characters, however in certain ways one may also sense that one character is seen to be more sinful than the other character. "The Father" is a play about relationships, between a married couple, between men and women and between father and daughter. The play is about a man who is manipulated by his own wife into convincing himself that he is mad and ends up being driven out of his own home by the suspicion that his daughter is not his own. "Hedda Gabler" is also a story about the relationship between married couples and lovers. Hedda is a bright and ambitious middle-aged woman. Hedda opts for a conventional marriage without any love involved. She marries with the idea that she will find complete fulfilment in her husband's career and finds out too late that this is unlikely to happen. "The Father" is regarded by some as a naturalistic play as it shows the audience how life truly is at some stages of life. ...read more.


Jasmine Seippel, IB06, English A1 Standard world literature essay In many ways, one may feel less sympathy for Laura than is expected as while reading the play you feel a great deal of anger at her because she is such an evil character in the way that she treats her fellow characters in the play. She does this by misleading them; she misleads the doctor and convinces him that the captain is completely insane. The doctor feels more reason to believe Laura as at the end of act two she provokes the captain to become so furious as to throw a lamp at her. This is extremely shocking coming from the captain however; it is seen as an act of a mad man. It is extremely cruel how she uses this act against the captain as his actions where due to her comment on how he will be under restraint the following morning and Laura will then have complete control of the house. The act of her convincing the doctor that the captain is mad is an extremely cruel plot, which she succeeds in. By seeing Laura treat her husband in this way, someone she loved in the past shows us that should not have that much sympathy for her. ...read more.


Jasmine Seippel, IB06, English A1 Standard world literature essay Both of these characters are very similar in certain ways, which allows us to react to them equally. Laura shows us how she drives the captain insane but possibly realises he needs to be sent to an institution anyway. The way Laura reacts to his scientific brain is extreme and offensive to him. When looking at how Laura, being a wife, reacts to the captain I feel as though she has reasons to react this way but there better ways to do it, and not by making him believe he is not the father of his daughter. I feel very sorry for the captain to have to put up with her. With Hedda on the other hand, I feel as though she deserves more sympathy as, to me it seems as though her reactions to everyone are due to her confusion and jealousy. However, Hedda has no real excuse to react the way she does and deserves very little sympathy in this respect but still some. It is not very easy to feel sympathy for either of the two characters in the plays as they have different reasons to react the way they do, still they do not respect the surrounding characters as much as they should. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Glass Menagerie section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Glass Menagerie essays

  1. Important Symbols and Themes of The Glass Menagerie

    Overall, it is a symbol of the passage from freedom to being trapped in a life of desperation. The fire escape allows Tom the opportunity to get out of the apartment and away from his nagging mother. Amanda sees the fire escape as an opportunity for gentleman callers to enter their lives.

  2. High Fidelity - Critical Essay.

    A-K' rack out into the street, go off to work in a Virgin Megastore and never come back." Although he wishes he could, Rob makes no attempt to escape from his job, one which is hard and pays badly but involves the main passion of his life: music.

  1. How do the methods used by Lysistrata to accomplish her plight differ from those ...

    This apparent detachment seems to make the Commissioner and the delegates give her more respect as she has broken away from the stereotype, this in turn makes her appear above the other women. This is both similar and completely different to Laura's method.

  2. In Rossetti's 'Goblin Market' the forces of life and love are threatened by death ...

    As Laura first encounters the goblins, once being groped by them, they begin to advertise their goods to her saying "Plums on their twigs; Pluck them and suck them". How this cannot be scene as an innuendo, is beyond me.

  1. 'Amanda is selfish and heartless' How far do you agree with this statement in ...

    Amanda's continuous repetitive story of 'one Sunday afternoon in Blue Mountain I received seventeen gentleman callers.' This obvious exaggeration or total figment of Amanda's imagination will only make Laura feel that she can never be what her mother wants her to be, and that she will never receive a gentleman caller.

  2. Student Task 1 - Reading and the Study of Texts - The Getting of ...

    clothes with a certain elegance that 'made up for their shortcomings' (pg 25). They would stand amazed at her cleverness and charisma, and she would form a kind of eternal friendship with one of her admirers that would be 'the wonder of all who saw it' (pg 25).

  1. The Day My Life Stopped

    "No it's great, and I really appreciate it, and I'm really grateful, thanks it's a really nice thought! And by the way don't worry about the thing with you and Nat, I mean you did what you thought was right, and it wasn't fair of me to make you feel held back from that.

  2. How does Tennessee Williams create sympathy for Tom, both as an individual, and as ...

    Tom as the narrator also describes Jim as a hero. The audience can see this when he says, "In high school Jim was a hero." Tom says Jim was like Chinaware. He says, "He had the tremendous Irish good nature and vitality with the scrubbed and polished look of white chinaware."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work