• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How just is the outcome of the trial scene for Shylock in the Merchant of Venice?

Extracts from this document...


Sanjoy Roy 11 Latymer How just is the outcome of the trial scene for Shylock in the Merchant of Venice? The trial scene of Act 4 Scene 1 is central to the whole theme of the Merchant of Venice, presenting Shylock's case for justice. It is a transforming scene hence making the events that occur important on the impact of the whole play. Justice is the key to the whole scene so when we say just, we mean a fair and moral judgement in relation to the law. In Shylock's viewpoint, what would be just for him is to have what he wants in the bond- a pound of flesh. Another central theme to the scene is mercy and the need for it alongside justice. The importance of mercy is referred to in this scene by the Duke and Portia in disguise. Portia describes it as 'the gentle rain from heaven' (line 181) as justice alone cannot bring fairness without mercy since 'mercy seasons justice' (line 193). So when Portia says 'then must the Jew be merciful' (line 178) she doesn't mean that Shylock must show mercy by law, but by being compassionate to Antonio and to forget what he has failed to do is the only moral course of action to achieving true justice and fairness. Nevertheless, as we see in the scene, the fixity of Shylock keeps him by the letter of the law so that he can gain revenge on behalf of himself who has suffered dearly. The whole aspect of the trial scene is to show the situation of mercy versus justice and the law. Portia, the figure representing mercy, wants to achieve both fairness and forgiveness on behalf of Antonio and Shylock yet Shylock wants the judgement based on the letter of the law because of his hatred and suffering at the hands of the Christians of Venice. ...read more.


It is not surprising that when Portia intervenes in the trial and asks Shylock, 'then must a Jew be merciful,' his response is 'on what compulsion must I?' Shylock is strictly sticking to the letter of the law so it is unlikely that Portia's presence would change his decision. Nevertheless, Portia's speech in lines 180 to 201 was a powerful display for the quality and reason for mercy. She describes it as the 'mightiest in the mightiest' (line 184) and that it is 'enthroned in the heart of kings' (line 190), yet Shylock's obsession with justice means that the speech makes little impression on him. This is strange, even for Shylock because justice is what he demands in the trial, yet Portia shows that justice will not restore things the way they are unless we also have mercy, hence the statement 'mercy seasons justice' is true. This should encourage Shylock to be merciful to Antonio, but since he refuses to do so and wants to give judgement against the Merchant of Venice, this proves how his code of justice lacks humanity and mercy in the deed. The result to this trial scene is the twist that occurs, where rather than Shylock gaining his justice triumph and sweet revenge from the death of his enemy, Antonio gains justice and wins from the downfall of his murderer. According to Venetian law, Shylock must give half of his wealth to Antonio, the other half to the state and his life at the Duke's mercy. This development is not only ironic but also comical and adds to the comedy theme of the play because Shylock had so much to gain from the trial, yet he loses all he has to his victim that he came to close to killing. Shylock had suffered dearly as a result to what had happened in the trial scene. Given the extreme penalties the court could exact on Shylock, we could say that he was a victim of his own code of justice. ...read more.


The comical convention does make it difficult to get this important message to the audience, even though Shylock's defeat was essential to bring the play fully into that genre. The ending also affects how vindicated the outcome is, since Shylock is not mentioned at all in the final act of the play, therefore giving the impression that the characters are unaware of the threats that took place earlier. This brings into the ambiguous question on whether Shakespeare was anti-Semitic in the play. He does bring across the message of Shylock's suffering in his speech in Act 3 Scene 1, making him seem powerfully human, yet he receives the same treatment as a villain in the trial. The way that the humans respond rather happily in the end does bring the sense of unfairness into the way he was treated finally in the trial and the fact that Antonio says 'I dare be bound again, my soul upon the forfeit' in Act 5 Scene 1 (lines 251-2) does show that the trial experience has not taught Antonio nothing and he is still willing to swear oath on Bassanio's behalf. So although the ending does seem rather comical to the audience, its deeper meaning is quite serious and important in relation to the happenings of the play. In conclusion to the answer of the title question, I think that the outcome is just for Shylock in the trial scene, yet it is deeply unfair since Shylock was unwilling to show mercy and his request for the letter of the law meant that he was a victim of his own code of justice. Shylock received justice but much more than he wanted, as Portia said in line 312. His unwillingness to show love and forgiveness which was offered to him many times by the Duke and Portia meant that he gained unfair justice as a result of what he really desired, which was revenge and his bond. 1 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Merchant of Venice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Merchant of Venice essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    To what extent do you think Shylock deserves the treatment given to him in ...

    3 star(s)

    completely innocent, although again the only evidence I have for this is that Shylock says "you spat on me, called me dog". But it also seems Antonio has done something more than that too. Moreover, Shylock is constantly insulted for his religion; whether it be Gratiano calling him a "currish

  2. Merchant of Venice - Comparing and Contrasting Antonio and Shylock

    has left him for Bassanio who is one of Antonio's closest friends and of whom he hates the most. However, in the next line he shows the audience that when he is upset he displays it with anger. "For I dream of money bags tonight."

  1. Shylock is a tragic figure, trapped by prejudice and driven to revenge by the ...

    This suggests to the audience that Antonio does not care about Shylock's feelings and that indeed Shylock has been the subject of constant abuse from Antonio this constant abuse may have caused Shylock to become detached and segregated from the Venetian society around him.

  2. The play "The Merchant of Venice" is described as Romantic Comedy. One aspect of ...

    The second theme in the play is Money/Wealth. Money is the theme of the love plot as well as the hate plot of the Merchant of Venice. Bassanio's need for money to win a rich heiress Portia as a bride, " a lady richly left" is what puts Antonio in the power of Shylock.

  1. Does Shylock deserve the treatment he receives at the end of The Merchant of ...

    (Act 4, Scene 1, Lines 85-87) This gives us the idea that Shylock is seeking revenge for the bad treatment he has received from Antonio and also the other Christians. This is backed up by what he later says: "So I can give no reason, nor will I not, More than a lodged hate and a

  2. "Is 'The Merchant of Venice 'a tragedy for Shylock and a comedy for all ...

    They could not buy land so it was very hard for them to even own property. Some Christians would be jealous of them, so they would do anything to make sure that they would not be prosperous. Although it seems as if they did not like him because he was a Jew, I do not think this is true.

  1. How does Shakespeare reveal Shylock to us in Act III Scene 1, what impressions ...

    are not punished themselves for their behaviour also as I believe they should have, after all Antonio did assault Shylock earlier and Portia was instrumental in Shylocks decision, although these people are not killers and don't show intent upon the death of Shylock.

  2. To what extent does Shakespeare intend the audience to sympathize with Shylock in the ...

    Here lies a similarity between her and Shylock's plots, both themed on revenge. The contemporary audience may sympathize with Antonio. Shylock first appears to be cautious, then as one who takes, and gives offence, and finally appears consumed with revenge.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work