• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How successful as an adaptation of the novel is the cartoon version of 'Animal Farm'.

Extracts from this document...


How successful as an adaptation of the novel is the cartoon version of 'Animal Farm' "A film for all the family. It educates and entertains with a story that is forever timeless." This was how the animated version of 'Animal Farm' was described. The eighty-seven page novel written by George Orwell aimed at teenagers and adults has recently been converted into an hour and ten minute long film which is suitable and supposedly appealing to young children. This meant having to cut down and altar some of the storylines and characters within the novel to suit this age range but at the same time, trying not to lose the basic structure of the novel and the messages given out by George Orwell throughout the book. After viewing the film, we all have our individual opinions on whether this has been done effectively and whether the purpose of the novel was fulfilled. I felt that on a whole, the cartoon version of 'Animal Farm' did not live up to the standards of the novel, however, you find that this is the case with most films that have been converted from books. Although the basic storyline of the novel was suitable for children, the meaning behind the novel was beyond the understanding of this age range. ...read more.


An example of this is right at the beginning of the cartoon version of 'Animal Farm' during Old Major's speech. The film did not show all the animals learning 'Beasts of England' however; all the animals somehow seemed to know it. This wouldn't have mattered to children, however teenagers and adults would have most probably noticed this. Throughout the whole book, a lot of the events were in the wrong order, which didn't really make much difference if you had not previously read the book, however it made me slightly confused. Also, a lot of the events that were changed from how they were written in the book because of the audience that was trying to be attracted. They changed the storyline from how it was written in the book to make it much more understandable by children, and on occasions, such as the one right at the end, they created a totally new event so that it would be more appealing to children and not frighten them. One of the major events that they changed in the film, was that of the windmill being knocked down for the first time in a storm. All that was showed in the film was it being knocked down for the second time in 'The Battle of the Windmill'. ...read more.


My personal opinion is that this change did not help the film in any way. In fact, I actually feel that it degraded the film a little as Benjamin's character covered up a lot of Boxer's effort and bravery. I agree with the fact that the producers decided to keep in all the small parts because there was no real reason to leave them out, however I think that they could have defined between Snowball and Napolean more as they came across to me as too blended. With Mr Jones, you could easily tell that he was a 'baddy' just by the way the artist had drawn him, however there was no real noticeable difference between Snowball and Napolean apart from the way they looked. I would have thought that the film would have emphasized the characters that the audience could get hooked into, such as Mollie. However, this didn't seem to be the case and I do not feel that they successfully altered the characters so that they suit a film for all ages. On the whole, I do not feel that the cartoon version of 'Animal Farm' was very successful. I think that they chose a very hard task and they did not carry it out effectively as it certainly did not entertain and educate my classmates and myself. Clare Weaver 9S 16.11.01 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Animal Farm section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Animal Farm essays

  1. Summarization of animal farm chapters 1-10

    CHAPTER 7 This chapter begins in the bitter winter with the animals trying their best to rebuild the windmill, but the cold and their hunger dampen their spirits. It is only Boxer's never-failing cry of "I will work harder" that inspires them to continue.

  2. The main elements of Napoleon's character.

    The group of neighbouring farmers are no better. They pretend to sympathise with Jones while secretly contemplating how they can turn Jones's misfortune to their own advantage. They see the events at Manor Farm (which they refuse to call Animal Farm) as a threat to their own farms and try to sabotage the rebellion by spreading false tales and malicious lies.

  1. The Ethics and Morals behind Xenotransplants

    Pigs raised for their organs may be protected from flu viruses, but that won't protect humans. All pig cells carry a known retrovirus known as Porcine Endogenous Retrovirus, or PERV. It is harmless to them, but no one knows what it might do to humans (although it has been shown that it can infect human cells).

  2. Animal Farm.

    The animals call one another "Comrade" and take their quandaries to the pigs, who answer their questions about the impending Rebellion. At first, many of the animals find the principles of Animalism difficult to understand; they have grown up believing that Mr.

  1. Animal Farm Book Report

    forced explanations out of the animals because he thought they were conspiring against him and working with Snowball. He ordered his dogs to kill a lot of the animals this made them very scared and timid and they never questioned Napoleons doings.

  2. "Propaganda and it's role in the novel, Animal Farm."

    He tries to make the animals believe that "Napoleon was very cunning . He seemed to oppose the windmill , simply as a manoeuvre to get rid of Snowball , who was dangerous and a bad influence". He calls that tactics but the animals can't understand it but by the

  1. 1984, and Animal Farm.

    Trotsky was found with a pickaxe in his head at his villa in Mexico. ("Animal Farm" 3) Napoleon steals 9 puppies from their mothers and raises them himself, molding them in his image, mimicking the KGB. After they are abducted they disappear from the scene, only to reappear when Napoleon needs them most.

  2. Explore the ways that the writers use contrast within a character or between characters ...

    Napoleons increasing preoccupation with his position and status demonstrates that he uses the revolution for his own gain. The seven commandments throughout the book are rewritten to suit Napoleons aims. He announces his intentions to the animals. Who are terrified into silent agreement, when it is clear that his plans have already been made.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work