• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

I will be comparing the poems Lochinvar written by Walter Scott in 1808 and Le Belle Dame Sans Merci written on 1820 by John Keats.

Extracts from this document...


Comparison of Poems I will be comparing the poems Lochinvar written by Walter Scott in 1808 and Le Belle Dame Sans Merci written on 1820 by John Keats. Lochinvar and Le Belle Dame Sans Merci are two Romantic poems that claimed popularity in the movement of Romanticism simply because they were short in length, they both tell a story and contain a plot, they were fashionable for the Romantic movement also they were easy to remember and recite. The main and most obvious similarity between the two poems is that they are Romantic. The Romantic period began about 1798 and ended approximately around 1832. Romantic poetry concentrated on nature, feelings and emotions. Furthermore the subject matters of the supernatural and medieval were used. It was a break with the old tradition, that was until the Victorian movement moved in and people, actions, outward morality and reason were more important. Poems such as 'Porphyria's Lover' were written during the Victorian movement. One of the main differences between the two poems would be that Le Belle Dame Sans Merci is a ballad whereas Lochinvar uses rhyming couplets and archaic language. In addition Le Belle Dame Sans Merci could be described as being tragic and heart-rending where Lochinvar is the perfect fairytale with the idyllic ending. ...read more.


Their families attempt to follow them. The main characters in Lochinvar would be Ellen and Lochinvar. Lochinvar is a Scottish Lord and Knight. He is very brave and bold. We know this because, 'He rode all unarmed and, he rode all alone,' also 'He stopped not for break, and he stopped not for stone,' and 'He swan the Esk River where ford there was none.' There is some speculation that he could be dangerous. We know that Ellen's family is quite well off, the live at Netherby Hall. And Ellen's parents do not approve of Lochinvar. It could be possible that Ellen's marriage could be arranged. Lochinvar and Ellen have been in love for some time so maybe Ellen's parents arranged this marriage to try and exclude Lochinvar from Ellen's life. The story of Le Belle Dame Sans Merci is that of a tragic one, ending in possible death and mystery. The narrator in the poem meets a knight who looks extremely unwell. The narrator asks the knight what is wrong. He continues to tell the narrator that he met a fairy in the field. He made her some jewellery consisting of flowers, then the fairy tells him that she loves him. ...read more.


Both Lochinvar and Le Belle Dame Sans Merci concentrate on nature, feelings, emotions and both contain some aspect of supernatural or medieval subject matter. In Lochinvar the feelings and emotions of the two main characters are concentrated on, they are in love but there are some difficulties. Lochinvar himself is the medieval subject matter because he is a knight. In Le Belle Dame Sans Merci the main emotion showed is the heartbreak of the knight. He has fell in love with the fairy but she has left him and now he may face death. The fairy is the supernatural subject matter here. There is a fair bit of natural imagery used in Le Belle Dame Sans Merci, one example being, 'I see a lily on thy brow.' The tone and mood of both poems is different. Lochinvar is quite a dramatic poem. It has a very eventful plot with a heroic love story and a happy ending. This pleases the reader but at some points in the poem may keep them in suspense. The medieval subject matter enhances this. Whereas Le Belle Dame Sans Merci is very dreamlike, within the plot of the poem there is nothing too stimulating. However the poem does not come across boring because the plot itself is quite complex. The element of supernaturalism adds to the poems dreamlike effect. English Literature Kieran Walsh 10E ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Keats section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Keats essays

  1. Compare how nature is presented in two Romantic Poems

    Both poets use the structure of their poems very cleverly to get the whole idea of the poem across to the reader. The tempo also is very different in both. 'To a Skylark', is much faster, as it moves from notion to notion and this gives you the image of how lively the skylark is.

  2. How is Keats' Romanticism Revealed in the Poems 'To Autumn' and 'La Belle Dame ...

    This poem showed his fascination and recognition of beauty within nature. He is trying to prove that although summer has finished, not everything is preparing for the harshness of winter. He is expressing that we are still reaping the benefits of summer such as 'the fruit with ripeness to the core', and the 'swelling gourd'.

  1. The Women in 'My Last Duchess' and 'La Belle Dame Sans Merci' Represent Two ...

    They are both young and beautiful from what we can tell, and are aware that they appeal to men. They are both flirtatious though it seems the Duchess is far too shy and unaware to realise this. They both, also, appreciate the power and simplicity of nature and not for wealth and status which rules the Dukes thoughts.

  2. Write an appreciation of "The Eve of St Agnes" as a narrative Romantic poem.

    The element of magic and enchantment is still continued. "Hark! 'tis and elfin-storm form fairy land." This shows although there is no real meaning for the rest of the poem Keats still keeps up the themes that have been shown throughout the poem.

  1. I have decided to use the following poems in my essay - The Poison ...

    Love can come in many forms, but this love is a sadistic form of the emotion, where he gets pleasure from the other person's pain. Infatuation plays a big role in The Poison Tree, as the speaker is seemingly obsessed with growing and nurturing his anger like a plant, his

  2. Compare 'La Belle Dame Sans Merci' and 'To Autumn' by John Keats. Write about ...

    Autumn is coming to an end and bareness, "stubbing plains." The birds are starting to migrate: "Gathering swallows twitter in the skies" The poem has three stanzas and ten lines per stanza except for the last stanza that has eleven lines.

  1. In this study I will be comparing the 2 poems, To Autumn and Ozymandias. ...

    and the third is on hearing ("songs", "music", "sing"). He has included this, I think, to show us that we should use our senses, and not let them go to waste. Another point that I think agrees with my conclusion is that in the second stanza it talks of laziness

  2. La Belle Dame Sans Merci

    The structure of the sonnet is 14 lines altogether which comprises of an octet and sestet. The rhyming scheme is AB AB CD CD EF EF GG. The rhyming couplet at the end of the poem brings the poem to a close.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work