• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

If you were directing this play, how would you ask the actor playing Shylock to portray his character: as a villain, or as a victim?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

If you were directing this play, how would you ask the actor playing Shylock to portray his character: as a villain, or as a victim? 10 November 03 A villain or a victim. This essay will be considering the evidence for and against the two dramatic interpretations of Shylock in 'The Merchant of Venice'. Could a villain become a victim? Is it possible for Shylock to be both a villain and a victim? Shylock is a very complex human being, who you can feel sympathy and hatred for during the play. One of the examples of this is when Jessica runs away from home into the arms of a Christian, knowing that Shylock, her father will be left on his own, with no one to trust nor care. I feel very sorry for this poor old Jew. On the other hand, running away is a very brave decision for Jessica to make. How has Shylock driven Jessica to these emotions and actions, to a situation that leads Jessica to think that leaving is the only method in order to have a better life? Jessica also has mixed emotions when she knows that she may not be able to see her father ever again. ...read more.

Middle

In Act 4 in the Duke's palace, the Duke shows sympathy towards Antonio, he says' I am sorry for thee', which suggests that the Duke is on the Christian's side, so how is this judgement fair? Secondly, when Portia releases Antonio from the bond, she is not satisfied, she wants revenge, she heaps financial penalties and humiliation on Shylock. Worst of all, they make Shylock agree to change to a Christian. Religion is spiritual. Nobody has the right to convert anyone's religion, as this is a part of our soul. On the other hand, Shylock is prejudiced when he says 'I hate him for he is a Christian'. He is just as insulting back, being prejudiced towards any Christian in sight. He wanted a pound of flesh as a payment from Antonio. In other words, Shylock wants to kill Antonio, and he wants to get rid of him. A pound of flesh is far too extreme as a payment. It is understandable if Shylock uses this chance for revenge, but there are many other ways. However, he chooses the cruellest way. Shylock calls it 'a merry bond', as if killing were just a game for him after all. ...read more.

Conclusion

In Shylock's famous speech in Act 3 Scene 1, the actor could express his pain, in order to gain the audiences' pity. Jewish people have been persecuted for centuries, treated unfairly in societies. There is no exception in Venice and Belmont. Because of the unfairness of the community, anyone, even the kindest heart would be hardened. Shylock has always known the cruelty this society has towards the Jews. Being brought up in the country has made Shylock a cold blooded person, who is always wanting revenge. This is natural, whereas forgiving seems to be unnatural for human beings. Having said this, Christians should be more aware of this forgiveness as they are told to forgive in their bible. The Christians in 'The Merchant Of Venice' are not good examples of their religion either. Should not a Christian take Jesus as their guideline in every day's life, and so persecuting, criticising and humiliating an example of Jesus? Shylock never does anything would harm anyone, so why does Antonio see Shylock as his 'enemy'? Shylock is mean, but after this humiliation and persecution, who can blame Shylock of being cruel? He is just trying to defend himself, by hurting others before being hurt. ?? ?? ?? ?? Alice Lee ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Merchant of Venice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Merchant of Venice essays

  1. Explore the conflicting responses, which the character of Shylock provokes in the audience. How ...

    However, this is contrasted by the Shylock that exists at the end of the scene. As he leaves the courtroom, Shylock feels angry, disappointed, wronged, upset, defeated and unfairly treated. Shylock has been persecuted by the court and has lost his battle to take his bond.

  2. Shylock - Victim or Villain - What is your assessment of the presentation of ...

    Unfortunately, everything else Shylock says in this scene makes it virtually impossible, if not impossible, to sympathise with him. Shylock is going to dine with the Christians, but not as a friend, "I'll go in hate", he says, showing a clearly visible villainous side.

  1. The Merchant of Venice Coursework Essay - Shylock; Victim or Villain

    So essentially, Shylock sees the advantages of hiding behind the law, which could be interpreted as the action of both a villain and a victim, but to me it is merely a tactical decision. The Duke decides that, unless a doctor that he has sent for to determine the matter comes, then he will dismiss the court.

  2. "Shylock is a two dimensional villain who does not deserve our sympathy" To what ...

    Act 4, Scene 1. As the scene continues, the duke seems almost to be threatening Shylock when he says "We all expect a gentle answer, Jew." Act 4, Scene 1. Portia's bluff also crushes Shylock severely, bringing his hopes up with cries of "Why this bond is forfeit, and lawfully be this the Jew may claim."

  1. How does Shakespeare portray character and relationships in Act 1 Scene 3 of 'The ...

    We also consider Antonio from an enemy's viewpoint. This is evidence of Shakespeare using the theme of religion and race to portray characters. The use of prose for the conversation between Bassanio and Shylock in the opening lines of scene 3 suggests informality even though the subject of their discussion is the loan, a formal agreement.

  2. Shylock - Villain or Victim? Examine the language and behaviour towards others, as well ...

    He is explaining why he feels so much hatred towards Christians. In line 57 ' If you prick us, do we not bleed?' makes you feel sorry for Shylock. He is saying that Jews are no different from anyone else.

  1. Shylock: victim or villain?

    Shylock wants a pound of Antonio's flesh if Antonio cannot repay Shylock's bond by the time agreed. Shylock makes Antonio think that he is joking with him by claiming that " a pound of man's flesh" would be no use to him.

  2. Shylock: Victim or Villain

    signifies that even thought that Jessica may be his flesh and blood, she had more in common in the Venetians then with her own father. The audience at this point feels some consideration for Shylock as he is again being abused by Venetians and is left lonely because of the revenge he seeks.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work