• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In Act 2 when Alice tells Maggie " I don't know what your aiming at..." she answers " The difference between us is that I do. I always did." Explore the differences between Maggie and her sisters in " Hobson's Choice."

Extracts from this document...


In Act 2 when Alice tells Maggie " I don't know what your aiming at..." she answers " The difference between us is that I do. I always did." Explore the differences between Maggie and her sisters in " Hobson's Choice." Hobson's Choice is a play written by Harold Brighouse and it is set in Salford in 1880. In those women were victims of the conventions of the day which meant they had to stay at home, cook their masters tea and were generally ordered about during their lives. However, in this play Maggie is a victim of no one and nothing. We see her as an individual, very strong headed and also very different from her sisters. Maggie transcends convention in order to get exactly what she wants, not only for herself but also for those around her. In this essay, I am going to explain what I feel the main differences between Maggie and her two sisters are and how I think they are portrayed in the play by closely studying Hobson's Choice. The play opens in Hobson's Boot Shop, Chapel Street, in Salford. We are introduced to Alice and Vickey who are sat behind the counter when Maggie enters. As the reader, I learn that Alice is expecting Albert Prosser that morning to come in and attempt to "woo" her. ...read more.


However, Maggie isn't bothered in the slightest. She can see that her sisters have greatly failed to see why Maggie is doing this with a view to achieving as much as possible for herself and Will in the future. Maggie has great visions of long-term plans in the future and she doesn't mind making sacrifices at the beginning of the relationship, as she knows great things can grow from very humble beginnings. The difference here between Maggie's character and her sisters' character is that Alice and Vickey are more interested in material and other peoples opinions whereas Maggie needn't care for either. Ambition is certainly what drives Maggie on to make the decisions that she makes. As a woman of thirty living in the nineteenth century, she finds herself in a much more difficult position than her sisters are when it comes to finding herself a husband. However, she does not let her Father's remarks of her being "shelved" stop her. Ironically, she not only finds herself a husband but one for each of her sisters by using her many talents to do this. One of Maggie's talents is her judge of character. She has such a good understanding of how her Fathers mind works that I would say she knows him better than he knows himself. On one occasion when Hobson leaves for the Moonraker's, she informs him that dinner will be served at one o'clock promptly. ...read more.


Basically, she is necessary to his survival, especially as he is drinking himself to his death at the end of the play. She knows how his mind works and is still very loyal to him as she compromises with Will to partly own the business with Hobson. In conclusion, everything so far has confirmed that Maggie is an excellent businesswoman. Another thing that makes her so achievable is her cunning quick thinking and her ability to form a workable plan. She manages to get her Father to sign a piece of paper allowing Alice and Vickey to get married and to also provide them a sum of money. Overall, the difference in the three girls' characters is incredible. There's Alice and Vickey who are much more interested in materials and worry too much about other people's opinions. They are weak and are not prepared to stand up to their Father and they rely on people to get them through their lives and are easily dominated as they don't share their opinions. But then there's Maggie, the definite leader of the play. She is strong headed powerful ambitious and domineering in a good way. The main difference between the sisters is that Maggie always knew what she was aiming at in life unlike her two sisters. We saw her conjure up a plan over many weeks to get Will to marry her and she did everything in her power to make it a success. I think it is safe to say to say that she certainly did that. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Harold Brighouse section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Harold Brighouse essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Hobson's choice - Maggie can be described as a "woman of specific qualities." ...

    4 star(s)

    The 'proposal' goes quite Maggie's way. She succeeds in dismissing Ada and being engaged to Willie and convincing him that it would be best for him to marry and her and be her partner. He realises there is "no escape" after she tells him, "Willie Mossop, you take orders from me in this shop.

  2. Hobson's Choice Coursework

    frightened as he used to be although still reluctant about his marriage. In the play, Maggie had to come out of the bedroom, take Willie by the ear and drag him into the room. This shows that Willie is still a bit frightened as he doesn't want to go in the bedroom with Maggie.

  1. Hobson's Choice

    plans to build a partnership with Willie, as he is good at making the boots and Maggie is good at selling them. Willie's attitude changes at this point. This is shown by his eyes widening. In the book, Ada comes to see Willie as she brings his lunch to him.

  2. Hobson's Choice

    I collapsed. I collapsed through fear and sadness, crying into Leanne's shoulder, letting the pain out. "I hate him. I just... I hate him so much..." I stammered through the tears. Chapter 4 - Kim Morrison "Sandra McDougal?" I asked, surprise filling my voice. "Run away? I can't believe that."

  1. In Hobson's Choice, how does Harold Brighouse make the audience aware of the changes ...

    Here we see a dramatic change in Willie's character. He is standing up to Hobson and not waiting for Maggie to tell him what to do. Even though Hobson attacks him verbally and physically, Willie does not lose his nerve. Hobson's anger and threats fuel Willie's courage. Brighouse has shown that Willie has already begun to change with the support of Maggie.

  2. Hobson's Choice - How does Brighouse represent the character os Maggie in Act One?

    not a confident person and was not used to the idea of marrying Maggie, when he defied the man who paid his (poor) wage and kissed Maggie, before walking out with his head held high. This confidence was a sign of things to come from the most unlikely of people to take initiative and rebel against the norm.

  1. Trace the development of Willie Mossop throughout the course of the play. Include the ...

    However, this is the last time we see Willie as a ridiculous figure. Act Four is set a year later so in this act the audience do expect a dramatic change in Willie, and that is what they get. Before Willie even enters the act we see that he has

  2. "Hobson's Choice". - "What do you think of Maggie Hobson in the first act ...

    start off in their new life and he is way too tight fisted to do this. Maggie is very clever and after the encounter with Mrs. Hepworth notices Will's potential "he is a lanky fellow about thirty, not naturally stupid but stunted mentally by a deprived childhood.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work