• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In Act two, Alice tells Maggie "I don't know what you're aiming at." She replies, "The difference between us is I do, I always did." Explain the differences between Maggie and her sisters. 'Hobson's Choice' is set in Salford in 1880

Extracts from this document...


Beth Thompson In Act two, Alice tells Maggie "I don't know what you're aiming at." She replies, "The difference between us is I do, I always did." Explain the differences between Maggie and her sisters. 'Hobson's Choice' is set in Salford in 1880, at a time when women tended to occupy largely domestic roles. However, the leading character, Maggie Hobson, is a woman way ahead of her time. Unlike her sisters, she is a demanding and domineering character. She knows what she wants in life and is not afraid to strive for it. Alice and Vicky stand up to Hobson, their father, about small and trivial matters. After Hobson has complained about the bustles the girls wear, Alice says to her father: "We shall continue to dress fashionably, Father." However, Alice and Vicky are very intimidated by Hobson and so when it comes to bigger and more important matters the talking is left to Maggie. Jim Heeler calls on Hobson to take him to the 'Moonrakers'. This is a bar where he spends most of his time drinking a lot of alcohol. Whilst Jim is around, Hobson seeks some advice from him. He requires advice on how to manage the girls. ...read more.


She is completely helpless. Alice decides to ask Vicky for some help: "What is seventeen and twenty-five?...Fifty-two of course," replies her other sister. This is blatantly incorrect. They are both just as bad at math and the shop obviously can't improve without the help of Maggie. Tubby has noticed that the shop is failing. He tries to imply to Alice how great the shop was when Maggie was around and running the business and how bad it is now that she has left: "I do not recollect things being as slack as this in her time." Without Maggie, business is deteriorating. Another difference between Maggie and her sisters is that Maggie has a way with people, she is a good judge of character and she can see potential in people. Alice and Vicky cannot fathom Maggie's choosing Willie as a husband. They are unable to appreciate the reasons behind her choice. The difference in outlook between Maggie and her sisters in relation to people and possessions is very clear. Maggie knows what she wants in life and how to get it: "The difference between us is that I do, I always did" she tells Alice. Only Maggie can see how she and Willie's relationship will work. She can see a lot of potential in him as a person. ...read more.


Another main reason in which Maggie is different to her sisters is that Maggie has a lot more respect for other people than Alice and Vicky have. When Willie called Vicky "Miss Vicky" Vicky herself did not try and correct him, it was Maggie who interrupted and corrected him. Also Maggie has to force respect from the sisters when she makes them kiss Willie to make him part of the family, their new "brother in law". The girls were not happy but still they were overruled by Maggie's domineering character. To conclude, Maggie is different to her sisters in the way that she knows how to achieve the good things in life, she tries to bring out the good in every person. She makes her future good and she does it on her own. She stands up for what is right and for what she believes in. Maggie is not influenced at all by men and their opinions, she gains things by her own determination and will power. She is a person who values the fact that starting off small can lead to great success. Her sisters keep themselves to themselves and are too cowardly to stand up for themselves, therefore due to remaining passive characters, their future will be what the future makes it, not what they make for themselves as they do not intervene in order to make it better. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Harold Brighouse section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Harold Brighouse essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Hobson's choice - Maggie can be described as a "woman of specific qualities." ...

    4 star(s)

    As time progresses we see Hobson and his health deteriorating. He is still his own persistent, stubborn self. The doctor can only think of one thing for Hobson. Someone to look after him who can be in control and in charge at all times, and these point to Maggie.

  2. Hobson's Choice

    I wondered how much to tell Miss Parkinson. I decided on the truth, since I knew Miss Parkinson could keep things quiet when needed. "She apparently ran away last night, but why she's in school if that's the case I don't know. Anyway..." I turned and walked over to where Sandra was sat.

  1. In Hobson's Choice, how does Harold Brighouse make the audience aware of the changes ...

    Willie comes up out of the trap as Hobson conceals the strap whilst he talks to Willie. Hobson claims that he must beat the love out of Willie's body, and Willie tries to explain that the love cannot be beaten out of his body, as there is none there.

  2. Hobson's Choice - How does Brighouse represent the character os Maggie in Act One?

    Hobson appeared to have his business working like a charm, he had 3 children running the store for no wages and two boot hands making the boots for a pittance, the shop was thriving making large income and small amounts going out in wages.

  1. "Hobson's Choice". - "What do you think of Maggie Hobson in the first act ...

    I think here that Maggie is sticking up for herself, but also reasserting her stubbornness, either way she is right for demanding pay for the work she does. Hobson believes that he will be able to force will into not marrying Maggie by beating him.

  2. Hobson's Choice Summary

    Maggie announces that she and Willie will be married at one o'clock at St. Philip's church. She buys a brass ring to use as a wedding ring. This shows that Maggie has her feet firmly on the ground as she is not prepared to waste money on sentiment when they


    Harold Brighouse did this because the status of a person in that time determines almost every aspect of their character including jobs, dressing, language, and perspective to life, attitudes and behaviours to other characters. The audience are introduced to Hobson's shop with "exhibits of boots and slippers, filled with rack

  2. Hobson Analysis - Henry Horatio Hobson is one of the principal characters of the ...

    and Vickey's weddings and after realising that he has been "diddled" he storms out angrily after giving his word to pay the money, meaning that to retain any honour or self-respect he could not break his promise. Grateful to their sisters Alice and Vickey leave happy, knowing that they are soon to be married to Albert and Freddie.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work