• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In this piece of coursework I will be comparing two different films based on William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet to the original text.

Extracts from this document...


Romeo & Juliet In this piece of coursework I will be comparing two different films based on William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet to the original text. I will first introduce the two different films: 1. Baz Luhrman version - this version is set in modern times, in a large city, Verona. The language is Shakespearian but everything else has been converted to modern style. 2. Franco Zefferreli - This is set in medieval times. Most things are as the original text. It seems like a Greek or Italian city, however it is still Verona. At the start of the films, there are prologues that attempt to tell you what is happening. In the modern, Luhrman version, a news reporter on a television against a black background does this, however in the Zefferelli version, the prologue is told as the credits and title is shown. The speaker is not seen, and the voice is coming from the background, the speech is in an old style. In addition, the Luhrman version has a series of scenes that explain and show to the viewers who the different characters in the film are, also in these scenes it repeats a section of the prologue in text and speech accompanied by fast paced, classical music. In the original text, there are 14 lines of text in the prologue, however, in the films prologue, the Luhrman version cuts down the lines to only 12 when the TV reporter is speaking it, and then cuts it down to 9 during the action scenes in the civil brawls, so it ends at "A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life". The Zefferelli version, during its prologue stops at line 8 which is, "doth with their death bury parents' strife", therefore it ...read more.


In the Zefferelli version Benvolio is again the same, as in the Luhrman version, and tries to separate the two sides. But he will fight if he has to. Tybalt again is like the Luhrman version. He is a very snug character and thinks he is the best there is. Both films seem to emphasise that Tybalt is a very dark, tough and evil type of character. The text also seems to want to show this. The same is true with Benvolio. They both follow the text at this point. In the text he also seems confident when he is trying to break the fight up, but when Tybalt appears he seems to loose this confidence. Also the prologue is cut slightly, to keep viewer interest. And the text and voice prologue during the introduction is cut when it says, "take their life". I think this is so interest is kept and the audience know something is going to happen. The conversation between Romeo and Benvolio is cut in the Luhrman version. They seem to walk into a hall then skip to the beginning of Act 1 scene 2, but then it goes back to the rest of the conversation from Act 1 scene 1. This may be so that the audience knows what's going to happen, because they mention the Capulet feast and also this could have been because the lines missed out are not of any use to the viewer. Also, this version changes the beginning so that the Montagues are shown first instead of the Capulets. This may be so the producers could introduce the Capulets later in the petrol station, because they are the ones who cause the trouble. ...read more.


He has a very calm and noble personality. He seems to like being alone and is the kind of person that everyone is a friend with. His relationship with Benvolio is quite strong as they are cousins. You can clearly see that Romeo is not happy with all the Fights Benvolio gets involved in, this can be shown when he says "o me! What fray was here?" after he sees his cousin on TV with his weapon raised. In the Zefferelli version Romeo is again quite an innocent character. He is wearing different clothes to the other Montagues; his clothes are less classy in comparison to theirs. He is also holding a flower, which shows his good nature and intentions. The way in which he enters the film gives the viewer the impression that he is feeling depressed. His demeanour is that he is a person with little on his mind. His relationship with Benvolio is not as strong as it is in the Luhrman version. This is possibly because he doesn't like violence and therefore tries to limit his time with Benvolio, who seems to be a slightly more violent character. We can see how upset he gets when he sees the injured citizen. I think that the Zefferelli version is the best at representing Romeo as a character. This is because he makes him much more innocent and seem more affected by his life so far, than in the Luhrman version. I think that overall, the Zefferelli version has followed the text more closely during Act 1 Scene 1, and in doing so has emphasized the points that Shakespeare wanted emphasized. However, the Luhrman version is aimed at the modern young teenager, and is set to suit their tastes. It has been completely re-structured in regards to setting and costumes. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Comparing two versions of Romeo & Juliet (Zefferelli and Baz Luhram).

    The two versions are quite similar but have some obvious differences due to the modernisation of the play. First of all in Zefferelli´┐Żs version, we see Juliet walk towards the edge of her balcony. She speaks of her love for Romeo, she is so in love that she calls for

  2. GCSE Media Piece Comparing two films

    This juxtaposition helps the students to visualize the conflict between the two families and also the overwhelming domination that they have over the city. The newspaper headlines that are intermittently flash on screen also help to portray that the entire city is focused on the two families.

  1. Compare and contrast the way act 3 scene 1 is presented byFranco Zefferelli and ...

    I will be focusing on Act 3 Scene 1. This scene is pivotal to the rest of the play, as without it there would be romance rather than tragedy. In Act 3 Scene 1 Baz Luhrman makes the weather an effective device in symbolising and reflecting the mood in the scene.

  2. Analyse how Franco Zefferelli and Baz Lurhmann show the hatred between the Montague's and ...

    A man's voice say the words - his voice is quite low and very serious when these word come up and there is also really loud music. The music sounds very religious then the scene changes to a city with a big close up of Jesus then the camera goes straight into a long shoot of the city and statue.

  1. Compare the ways in which William Shakespeare and Baz Luhrman make the scene interesting ...

    written by Shakespeare because he is a bit drunk and showing his underwear where as in the script he is very jolly but being formal at the same time. Tybalt is introduced to the party much sooner than in the original with him dancing with Lady Capulet.

  2. "Girls are more mature than Boys."

    Girls mature physically more quickly than boys. So if you look at it from a biology point of view girls are more mature. Girls are slightly shorter than the boys at all ages until adolescence. She becomes taller shortly after age 11 because her adolescence spurt takes place two years earlier than the boy's.

  1. Compare the way Zefferelli and Luhrman present the oping scene of Romeo and Juliet ...

    The cast has popular young actors including Claire Danes and Leonardo Di Caprio. In contrast to Luhrman's opening, the Zeferelli version begins with the camera moving very slowly. We see a courtyard in the early morning mist. Then the sun rises and starts to shine with credits appearing over it.

  2. Shakespeare Coursework

    Although I think this is an excellent idea, I don't really have enough knowledge of this time period. So I have decided to set the film in a period of time where I know quite a bit of and what I am interested in.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work