• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Eddie Carbone a tragic hero?

Extracts from this document...


Is Eddie Carbone a tragic hero? Before I decide on whether Eddie Carbone is a tragic hero, we must define what the word 'tragic' and 'hero' actually mean. 'Tragic'- A tragedy is a type of drama. A tragedy traces the fall of the central figure, the 'hero', as he grapples with his destiny. Historically, tragedy started in Ancient Greece. Greek tragedies usually formed on a very important and powerful figure (a king or a prince perhaps) who makes an error or judgement or who has a hamartia (fatal flaw) that leads to his tragic downfall. In the context of a tragedy, the word 'hero' means the central character or protagonist (the hero) whom we admire or respect in some way, but who is flawed or imperfect and where his flawed character contributes to his own downfall. A hero is consequently not a perfect character, not even necessarily a pleasant one. His plight illustrates the cruelty of the world, and how one man faces up to his fate. It is important that a tragic hero acquires some self-knowledge, that he faces up to his own predicament, with honesty and openness. Now, in order to find out to what extent Eddie is a tragic hero, we must ask ourselves the following questions: a) ...read more.


Yet the 'icing on the cake' for our losing all respect for him is the fact he can't see what he's doing, how he's acting, all the problems he's caused. Which eventually leads to him turning in the two submarines causing Marco to pick a fight with Eddie, in which Eddie dies, (though that was probably a better fate for Eddie as the Mafia who were a second government effectively in those days wouldn't have let him off with a quick and easy death). The second question we must ask, is what is Eddie's character flaw? Well, he has several character flaws, the first being his deep rooted sexual attraction for Catherine. This becomes evident fairly soon into the play, with the way he acts when she is around. It also leads onto another flaw; his obsessive jealousy and deep resentment of Rodolpho. This is because Rodolpho is hitting it off with Catherine, whom Eddie can't get anything from, and it has sparked something off inside him, which is also mentally tearing him up. Though what makes it worse is the fact he's blind about himself. He is unable to confront himself with how he feels about everything. This is why his bitter resentment towards Rodolpho is so great. ...read more.


Another thing that puts him beneath our contempt, is the fact he had the audacity to turn in the two submarines because he was jealous, knowing full well what the consequences were, with the mafia not the police. Does Eddie ever gain any self-knowledge? No. Simple as that, he never gains insight into his own character. Throughout the play, maybe not so at the beginning, but very definitely when the two submarines arrive early on in the play, he was very selfish and very over protective of Catherine. He is very jealous of Rodolpho, and hence bullies him. However Marco makes sure Eddie doesn't harm Rodolpho physically by showing off how strong he is (and also subtly hinting at how he could beat Eddie in a fight). He does this by showing that he can lift a chair by only one of its legs, whereas Eddie is unable to. Unfortunately Eddie seemingly misses this hint of Marco's power, and this in turn leads to his death. All in all, what we can see Eddie is a protagonist whom we all respect to start with, but indeed he has a fatal flaw, which his inability to be emotionally articulate, especially within himself and he becomes a tragic hero as we watch his downfall from the beginning of the play. So is Eddie Carbone a tragic hero? Yes. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. Analyse the ways Arthur Miller presents Eddie Carbone as a tragic hero whose downfall ...

    In the Sicilian culture this is seen as being disrespectful. He then tries the destroy the reputation of Rodolpho in Catherine's eyes, "That's right, He marries you he's got the right to be an American citizen . . . lookin' for his break, that's all he's lookin' for" At first

  2. "Eddie Carbone is the classic tragic protagonist whose downfall evokes the audience's sympathy". To ...

    Actually, what Eddie wants ultimately is his name as he told Marco to give him back his 'name'. As Eddie has excessive pride, he wants to get rid of Rodolfo and in the end, is isolated by the Italian Community.

  1. "The tragic hero is one who is neither villainous nor exceptionally virtuous, moving from ...

    Even when Eddie hears about Catherine getting a new job, he reluctantly allows her to take the job: "She's got a job. What job? She's gonna finish school. Eddie, you won't believe it - No - no, you gonna finish school.

  2. Why and How Does Eddie Carbone Change As The Play Progresses? What Leads to ...

    "You're the Madonna type". When she remarks that Eddie should let Catherine grow up, he feels insulted. Beatrice tries to open his eyes. The audience again feel sympathy for her; she just tries to help Eddie earn back his respect before it's all gone.

  1. Discuss Eddie Carbone as the tragic hero of the play

    He is too protective and this is shown by him making the decisions for her and deciding what he thinks she should do by saying 'but that ain't what I had in mind.' Throughout the play we see happiness shed upon Eddie, while Catherine was in his control and was

  2. Proctor, hero or Villain?

    in lies, mister you will give me your honest confession in my hand or I cannot keep u from the rope which way do you go mister" Proctor crumbles up the paper, which signifies that he chooses to die. This can be seen as a selfish action as he is

  1. In many ways, 'AVFB' is a typical 20th Century tragedy because it involves acts ...

    He talks to Alfieri and tells him all his thoughts and feelings about Catherine and Rodolpho. Eddie believes Rodolpho only wants Catherine so he can be a citizen. 'He's only bowin' to his passport'. This seems like a good point and could be true but like Beatrice says, 'He'll say

  2. How does Miller present Eddie Carbone as a tragic hero in

    Indeed, his marriage to Catherine is brought forward to secure his staying in the country. Marco's accusation of Eddie leads him, in the latter stages of the play, to an impossible effort to recover his good name in the community.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work