Is it essential to the development of the play's tragic situation that Othello and Cassio are soldiers. How far do you agree with this statement?

Authors Avatar

Is it essential to the development of the play’s tragic situation that Othello and Cassio are soldiers. How far do you agree with this statement: in your answer you should:

  • 1. Discuss character’s and their motives, as well as Shakespeare’s handeling of the narrative development and setting in the play.
  • 2. Give your own response to the critical view expressed, weighing how far you can agree with it and why.
  • 3. Show an understanding of Elizabethan attitudes to 1.gender, 2. honour, and 3.status, as well as an awareness of Shakespearian Tradegy.

Othello is a play about the tragic fall of the Great Othello. This of course would not be possible unless Othello was conveyed as a most powerful and significant figure in the Play. As the foremost in the state of Venice and the new Govenor-General of Cyprus, Othello is clearly a general in rank. Therefore they way people behave infront of him, convey his importance.

        Being an important officer in the Army meant that Othello must posess all the virtues for a general prescribed by Renaissance military treatises. He is of noble birth, he is self controlled, he is religios, he has the respect of his men and he demonstrates the most advanced military knowledge. He can speak well, to a court for example, and chooses Cassio over Iago, as he feels that Cassio will be better respected by the men as he is more acceptabel, this of course presents the audience with the basis for which Iago can place his deep resentment on as he feels that ~Othello chose Cassio, unwisely as all he does is ‘QUOTE ABOUT COUNTER CASTER’.

        Therefore the fact that Othello is a high ranking member of the arny contributes to the image of Othello as a tragic hero, as he is magnified and ennobled, (ACT ! SCENE £ IDENTIFIES HIMSELF WITH THE GREAT ONES OF THE WORLD).  But at the same time Othello is not arrogant or treat those below him as inferior beings.

        The fact that Othello is a soldier also means that he will unvariably view the world in the same frame of mind that he enters a  battle. Thid is frequently demonstared in the fact that his speaches are full of epithets of war (QUOTE AND EXAMPLE). We must remember that Othello has been a soldier since he was seven years old and therefore it is uneveitable that he will tink like a man going into battle and is not familiar with other peoples emotions and way of thinking.. Therefore though he loves Desdemona pasionately, he will hate passionately, too and it seems that there is no middle ground . Othello sees the world in extremes, therefore when faced with the prospect of Desdemona being an adulteress, violence and force overcome him, and therefore feels that he must kill her. Therefore Othello can any see Desdemona as either an dirty whore or a Godess.

        The fact that they are in Cyprus maknig Othello, the most senior member on the Island would contribute to his sense of power and almost invurnerability, and therefore he is highly aware of this high position he has and it overwhelms him into thinking that he can take drastic measures without severe conseuqences. And at the ned this builds up the desperatness of his situation ,as he was supposed to be the man in controll of the whole island and yet, he can’t even control his own jealous, and lets it lead him to murder.

Join now!

        The change in setting between Venice and Cyprus is important in conveying the vhange in Othello and Iago. Venice is associate with all things cultutred and sophisticated. Therefore for Othello to have a high position in the society of Venice, is a great achievement. But when Othello moves to Cyprus, Othello is in an unfamiliare envirnoment, isolated from the ordered world he is used to, passion, violence and jealous are unleasesd to dramatic effect. There is the storm on the way to Cyprus reflecting the fear and violence that will greet Othello, once in Cyprus. The little island of Cyprus ...

This is a preview of the whole essay