• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10
  11. 11
    11

Is it right to describe Edward the Confessor as a failure?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History Coursework Essay Is it right to describe that Edward the Confessor as a failure? There were many problems in Edward's reign from 1042-1066. Stafford argues that some of his problems had no obvious solutions. Some historians argue that Edward was not a failure, as he was able to maintain a good relationship with the Godwines. He was also able to solve the problem of not having enough supporters and was able to defend his kingdom in case of any invasion in England. According to Barlow, Edward was also able to maintain peace within his kingdom in the latter part of the reign. This view is supported by ASC and the Vita. However, other historians argue that Edward was a failure as he was unable to deal on the long term with the power of the Godwines and was unable to solve the problem of the succession. Edward's failure is shown with the succession issue as both the Norman sources and English sources have in agreement that Edward did not have a consistent policy on the succession. Some historians argue that Edward should not be described as a failure. This was shown, as he was able to defend England in case of any invasion from other countries. This view is agreed by Barlow1 who describes Edward defending England and Denmark making an alliance with Swein against Magnus of Norway. Barlow says that "Edward always took command whenever possible of an invasion." This view is supported by the author of Vita 2 who describes Edward as, "the protector of his land and people." Barlow says that Ailred3 agrees with this view. This shows that the evidence is trustworthy. According to Barlow, Edward dealt with foreign policy, by stopping William from forming an alliance with Flanders. This was because Flanders and Normandy had maritime power and if they formed an alliance, they would have been able to share maritime power and help Swein, Magnus or Harold Hardrada from invading England. ...read more.

Middle

Therefore it is most probable that Barlow is giving an accurate account. Therefore, it is right to describe Edward as a failure, as he was unable to make Godwine fear him. Edward's achievement of putting Godwine into exile was only a short-term success as Edward was unable to expel them in 1052. Edward was not able to expel the Godwines as he did not have support from Siward and Leofric. Historians such as Barlow and Stenton agree that Edward had no alternative but to allow the Godwines to return in 1052. In addition Godwine had much support from Wessex and the London citizens. Stafford1 describes that he 'was not swept back on a tide of popular enthusiasm.' However, the Vita2 contradicts the view of Stafford and agrees with ASC (D) mentioning 'the whole city went out to help and protect the earl.' According to Stafford3, Ralf and Odda were supposed to receive reinforcements and help resist the Godwine's army, but by the time Edward's army had assembled, Godwine's army had already arrived London. Therefore, it is likely to describe Edward as a failure as he was unable to mobilize an army, lacking as he did the support of Leofric and Siward. Harold became Earl of Wessex, after Godwine died in 1053. Edward was unable to stop Harold from becoming over mighty and allowed him to gain more land. Tostig was then appointed to Northumbria in 1055 after Siward's died, and in 1057 Harold took over from Ralf in the Welsh marchers. By 1057 therefore all the earldoms except for Mercia were in the hand of the Godwines, so was a failure as he was unable to stop Harold from becoming over mighty. Campbell4 agrees with the view and supported by Stenton5, 'Harold had a great deal of influence in southern England, where the centre of national authority lay.' Furthermore, Edward was unable to deal with Welsh and Scottish Affairs, but instead had to depend on Harold. ...read more.

Conclusion

1 Anglo Saxon Chronicle D 2 James Campbell, Anglo Saxon England, pg 222 3 Pauline Stafford, Unification and Conquest, pg 89 4 Frank Stenton, Anglo Saxon England, pg.572, Oxford University Press, 2001. 5 Simon Schama, A History of Britain, pg. 81 Schama also includes, that he built, 'Norman Romanesque basilica,' and 'Edward was also taking advantage of the movement that placed abbeys and monasteries under direct royal patronage.' BBC Worldwide Ltd, 1992. 1 Edited and translated by Barlow, The Life of King Edward, 2 Barlow, Edward the Confessor, pg 202, Yale University Press,1997 3 Schama, A History of Britain, pg. 78, BBC Worldwide Ltd, 1992. 1 Barlow, The Feudal Kingdom of England 1042-1216, pg 45. Longman, 1999. 2 Stafford, Unification and Conquest, pg.86, Stafford says, 'William of Malmesbury tells how Edward was so uncertain of his situation that he considered returning to Normandy and was only persuaded to remain in England by Godwine, who offered to bolster his security,' and a similar thing is said by Florence of Worcester, according to Stafford. 3 Stafford, Unification and Conquest, pg 83 4 Anglo Saxon Chronicle D 5 Stafford, Unification and Conquest, pg 84 1 Pauline Stafford, Unification and Conquest, pg. 91 2 R.Allen Brown, The Vita Edwardi Regis, pg. 43-46, Edward Arnold 3 Pauline Stafford, Unification and Conquest, pg.91. 4 Campbell, Anglo Saxon England, pg229. 5 Stenton, Anglo-Saxon England, pg. 572. Oxford University Press, 2001. 6 Campbell, Anglo Saxon England, pg. 229. 1 Schama, A History of Britain, pg. 82 2 Barlow, Edward the Confessor, pg. 253 Barlow says that the Vita believed that Edward suffered from a mental illness. Yale University Press, 1997. 3 Loyn, 4 Schama 5 Adam of Bremen, History of the Archbishops of Hamburg,, pg. 108 1 Wilkinson and Cantrell, The Normans in Britain, pg. 7 (William of Jumieges account), Macmillan Education LTD, 1987. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 9 10 11 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Richard III section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Richard III essays

  1. How effective was Edward IV's domestic government from 1471?

    which was a special commission used to discipline activists. He sent out these commissions readily and tried very hard to show that he was not to be opposed. Which clearly worked very well because there were no revolts against the crown during this reign.

  2. How effectively did the Scots respond to Edward I's historical arguments for English superiority ...

    When he received a bull in 1299 from pope Boniface VIII therefore, demanding that he "abandon the war in Scotland, a land in which the pope says that the right belongs to himself,"1 he responded by setting out his legal case for overlordship based on historical precedent.

  1. How effective a ruler was Edward 4th from 1471 to 1483?

    Using Richard in this way would have given Edward stability in the North east because he was a strong influence on the people keeping them in good order. There is possible criticism that can be levelled at Edward for not learning from the events when Warwick rebelled in the 1460s

  2. On What Basis were the various claims to the throne made in 1066?

    In doing so he had to trick Harold into swearing an oath over holy relics that he would be William's man and not make any attempt to deny what at the time felt was rightfully his. An oath, which if broken would mean one of the biggest sins in the

  1. 'In his depiction of Richard III Shakespeare has created much more than a simple ...

    It also shows his deep contempt for women, trying to stop both his brothers from liking them. Another one of Richard's traits is revealed in lines 110-112. He fakes emotions to lure people into a false sense of security. He has already shown fake emotions to Clarence, as he was

  2. Discuss how the climatic scenes from Edward Scissorhands and Sleepy Hollow make use of ...

    The camera is looking up from the floor past Katrina and focusing on the stepmother, this gives a very good effect as it makes the stepmother seem superior and in control, which she is. It makes Katrina seem very vulnerable and innocent because the stepmother is above her menacingly and takes up a dominating part of the frame.

  1. The aim of these piece was to show the theme of survival. In fact, ...

    In fact when the normal Adam starts to read out the Koran, the troubled Adam is really frustrated because he doesn't want to listen, and he start screaming that he's going to die. This is how the scene finish it.

  2. After successfully invading England, William the Conqueror changed the course of English history

    an arrow in the eye at the Battle of Hastings while trying to repel the Norman invasion under William the Conqueror. Harold succeeded to his father's titles in 1053, becoming the most powerful man in England. Titles for his three brothers - Tostig, Gyrth, and Leofwine - swiftly followed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work