• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Prospero the wronged Duke of Milan, or a cruel colonial master?

Extracts from this document...


Is Prospero the wronged Duke of Milan, or a cruel colonial master? Prospero had his throne usurped by his brother and he and his daughter set adrift to survive only by chance. Prospero appears to wish to restore justice and himself to power by any means at his disposal which includes magic and enslaving Caliban and Ariel. Ultimately there is a happy ending; Prospero forgives everyone; Miranda and Ferdinand fall in love, Ariel gains his freedom and Caliban remains on the island. However the end does not necessarily justify the means, in that although Prospero has been treated badly himself, his treatment of Caliban and Ariel is harsh and immoral. Consequently the sympathy of the audience moves between the characters, initially having sympathy for the shipwrecked and usurped Prospero and later, surprisingly, for the much maligned and manipulated Caliban as the audience gains different insights into the events, characters and the challenging situation the characters find themselves in. When Prospero first arrives on the island, he enslaves Caliban and Ariel; his relationship with Caliban is very negative, he does not treat Caliban well and makes horrible threats; 'Thou most lying slave, Whom stripes may move, not kindness' In contrast, Prospero's relationship with Ariel is mainly positive and Ariel serves Prospero willingly; 'Told thee no lies, made no mistakes, serv'd Without grudge or grumblings.' ...read more.


Prospero says that he has racked Calibans' body with cramps and side stitches and also threatens him with the same torture. On the one hand Trinculo talks about how in England Caliban could have been shown off as 'any strange beast' for money which demonstrates the intolerant attitude of people towards different people. Also in Act III Caliban's speech about the islands 'noises' showed a more sensitive and human side of Caliban; 'Be not afeard, the isle is full of noises, Sounds, and sweet airs, that give delight and hurt not,' This is very effective in making the audience question Caliban's character and reminding them that he lived on the island first and whether the initial harsh view of Caliban was accurate. However Caliban seems to want to have a master; he sets up Stefano as the next master, who probably would not have been any better than Prospero, as he was offering to show Caliban off like a freak to the public who would treat him badly as well, because of him being different. It also shows Caliban's vulnerability as he finds another master who thinks; 'This will prove a brave kingdom to me, where I shall have my music for nothing' Ariel is a spirit that was imprisoned in a 'Cloven Pine' by Sycorax; this ordeal was obviously very painful for him, 'What torment I did find thee in. ...read more.


After he had done that, Prospero had decided to learn about magic whilst Antonio plotted his plans to overthrow him. If he had taken more care he would not have been overthrown. Prospero is a cruel colonial master because he has enslaved Caliban and Ariel to do his bidding when they clearly wish that he would let them go or never came to the island (apart from at the start possibly when Prospero was kind to Caliban and released Ariel from a tree); Prospero did take advantage of Caliban by getting him to show him the islands qualities and then apparently without a just cause, started treating him badly. Ariel has had a tough time, being locked in a tree, and being badly treated even before Prospero arrived, but has remained loyal and trustworthy, and Ariel is shown as a more pleasant character than Caliban who is portrayed as a beast not even fit for a human body. In conclusion, I believe that Prospero did take the island from Caliban, but I am not very sympathetic to Caliban after he tried to rape his daughter and I also believe that Prospero deserved to be overthrown by the way he treated his role as Duke and that he is a cruel colonial master to Caliban and Ariel and that he should free them so they will be happy. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Tempest section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Tempest essays

  1. How does the relationship between Prospero and Ariel change during the tempest

    As soon as she says "Come, you spirits" I want her to drop to her knees with her hands spread out above her head, beckoning them to come to her. Lastly when she says "to cry, 'Holy, hold,' I want her to just cry silently holding herself tightly, her head down.

  2. Is Prospero the wronged duke of milan or a cruel colonial master?

    On the other hand, Prospero used Caliban to gain control of the isle 'I showed thee the best springs' Caliban says, this points out that some time before the play was set Prospero was kind to Caliban or such. In this point of the play Prospero has enslaved Caliban, 'curs'd be I did so' he says.

  1. How does Shakespeare use the chracters of Prospero, Ariel, and Caliban, to explore human ...

    Simply by the way that Ariel responds to Prospero we can clearly see that Ariel is submissive and rather passive in his approach towards his master. However, when realizing Ariel's history there is a possible explanation for him being so sycophantic, and obsequious.

  2. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of Caliban in The Tempest. How far do you accept that ...

    As for his actions we could argue that his animal instinct won over the human instinct therefore he can't be blamed. Caliban opens Act 2 Scene 2 with his soliloquy. "All the infections that the sun sucks up from bogs, fens, flats, on Prosper fall, and make him by inchmeal a disease!

  1. Compare, contrast and evaluate different filmic, dramatic, stage-historical, literary critical and artistic interpretations of ...

    No analysis of filmic interpretations of 'The Tempest' can be undertaken without mentioning the unconventional, irreverent and inventive 'Prospero's Books', Peter Greenaway's 1991 incarnation, however Prospero is played in a fairly traditional manner, though very successfully, by the late Sir John Gielgud.

  2. Do you believe that Shakespeare intended the audience to share Prospero's view of Caliban?

    We are also alarmed when we first see Caliban as he is a monster and is not a nice thing to look at. This triggers the same prejudice as the one triggered with Miranda but it works in reverse, due to Caliban's appearance we dislike him, even though we know nothing about him.

  1. Script work - Who should be duke of Milan?

    Prospero: Well, like I told my daughter yesterday, I made a good Duke because I spent a lot of time studying and reading in my Library, and yet I still managed to solve the problems, and legal troubles of my people.

  2. Studying the character of Caliban in The Tempest

    When he said ?I loved thee,? it shows he really loved the old life he had. In my opinion, if someone, even Caliban, loved a person; an element of love will always remain within oneself. This tiny bit of love and happiness quickly turned to anger.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work