Is Romeo and Juliet a tragedy of fate or of character?

Authors Avatar

Is Romeo and Juliet a tragedy of fate or of character?

     The tragedy Romeo and Juliet is about two ‘star-crossed’ lovers from rival families. As the two families, the Capulet’s and the Montague’s, hatred for each other grows, Romeo and Juliet’s love for each other turns into a very dramatically passionate and lustful love. This causes the couple to make radical decisions leading to the suicidal ending.

     Some critics argue that Romeo and Juliet is not a true tragedy. They suggest that the play is a variation of a form of drama called ‘Tragedy of Fate’ which was popular during the early Elizabethan period. But is fate the only cause of the inevitable ending?

     Although some reasons that Romeo and Juliet die are out of their control, fate is not the largest reason that the lovers end up dying. For example, when Romeo hears of Juliet's death, before it is brought to light that it is a false death. Romeo rushes to her side to murder himself so he may lie with Juliet.
“Well, Juliet, I will lye with thee tonight”.
The choice for Romeo to end his life is his alone; no one else is responsible for his decision. And in the rescue plan we know that things will go wrong and we think the potion may well be the cause of that. In fact, the plan will go wrong for a far simpler reason: lack of communication.

     In act 3 the Friar is in a dilemma. He feels responsible for what has happened and desperately seeks a way out. Friar Lawrence tries to plead and goad Romeo.

“Unseemly woman in a seeming man”

This is to make Romeo come to his senses, and Friar Lawrence tells him Juliet is alive.

Join now!

“What rouse thee man! Thy Juliet is alive, for whose dear sake thou wast but lately dead”

Time will pass and Romeo may be forgiven, however, the Friar’s desperation, to clear the rivalry between the Montague’s and the Capulet’s, clouds his vision and spontaneously Friar comes up with a plan to re-unite Romeo and Juliet. Friar’s plan could have worked but so many things could have gone wrong, just as they did. The letters never get to Romeo, and when Romeo turns up at Juliet’s grave he commits suicide thinking that he will be with Juliet in heaven. The fact ...

This is a preview of the whole essay