Is this an accurate assessment of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth?

Authors Avatar

This dead butcher and fiend-like Queen.

Is this an accurate assessment of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth?

In retrospect Macbeth does not embody the traits of a butcher at the start of the play but the chain of events he and his wife set in motion, changes him into a remorseless killer.  A butcher by trade kills for necessity, shows no remorse or conscience and is pitiless.  However, Macbeth is persuaded by his selfish, ambitious wife to perform these terrible deeds against his moral standards.  Once Macbeth crosses the moral boundary of taking someone’s life, he loses all sense of right and wrong.  A domino effect is created whereby the loss of one life automatically leads on to mass murder in that he tries to eliminate all contenders to the throne i.e. the slaughter of the innocents (Macduff’s wife and children).  

   During the course of the play, Macbeth and his wife have a role reversal-she develops a conscience after her initial lust for blood and descends into madness whereupon she kills herself.  She is no longer the fiend-like queen, but a pathetic creature full of delusions (“Out, damned spot!”) who almost demands pity from the onlooker.  Macbeth however, has taken total control of the situation and cannot step back now that he has gone so far.   Lady Macbeth’s statement,“What’s done cannot be undone,” is appropriate here.  Consequently, Macduff’s quotation, “This dead butcher and fiend-like queen”, is not wholly true.

Join now!

   Upon hearing of the witches prophecies, Lady Macbeth instantly conspires to speed up events so that Macbeth becomes king quickly.  She believes that she is speeding up fate, but all she is in fact doing is playing out the prophecy exactly.  He lacks the necessary ruthlessness that accompanies ambition- “Thou wouldst be great,

Art not without ambition, but without

The illness should attend it;”

but she can supply that for him.  She is fiend–like in the way she manipulates her husband, a shrew brow-beating him into these acts.  He is merely her instrument carrying through her plans. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay