Jane Eyre - In what ways is Jane different from the other women in the novel? Why did one reviewer feel that Charlotte Bronte had "forfeited the society of her sex"?

Authors Avatar

JANE EYRE

                                                

In what ways is Jane different from the other women in the novel? Why did one reviewer feel that Charlotte Bronte had "forfeited the society of her sex"?

"Jane Eyre" is a nineteenth century novel, which tells us a lot about the roles women played in a strong patriarchal society of which Jane refuses to confirm to entirely. This was the time when women were treated as men's possessions. They were restricted legally, morally and spiritually, with no rights to their property, belongings or children. They were denied many of the things that we take for granted today, such as a wide education on all subjects, the vote and a profession. Jane Eyre is a very passionate woman, who believes that women are equal to men in every way; these views were quite unconventional for her day.

At the very begging of the book, we can see that Jane is very different from other children. The Victorians believed that children were to be 'seen and not heard' however Jane is not scared to speak her mind. One example of this is when Mr. Brocklehurst comes to Gateshead Hall, about Jane going to Lowood School. Mr. Brocklehurst is a tall man with a grim face and Jane is a small, weak child, but when Mr. Brocklehurst asks, "What must you do to avoid hell?" she replies, "I must keep in good health and not die." To threaten a small child with the prospect of falling into an eternal pit full of fire was a horrible thing to do, but it did not shake Jane. This immediately tells us that Jane is not the conventional child. This is not the only time that Jane takes courage to stand up to an elder, though, because she also stands up to her Aunt Reed, who tells Mr. Brocklehurst that Jane, 'has a tendency to deceit.' This arouses great feelings of injustice in Jane, which she cannot contain. She says to her Aunt Reed: "I am not deceitful: if I were I should say I loved you, but I declare I do not love you: I dislike you the worst of anybody in the world except John Reed." Mrs. Reed cannot believe her ears; a child is not to quarrel with its elders. I think it takes great courage for Jane to do this: the maid has already told her that she is under an obligation to Mrs. Reed, "She keeps you: if she were to turn you off, you would have to go to the poorhouse." So Jane, as a dependant relative is taking a big risk, but she feels something must be done.

        This is why Jane's character contrasts so much with Helen Burns. Jane meets Helen, when she is sent to Lowood Institution, a charitable-school. One day Helen is dismissed is from her history class in disgrace and sent to stand in the middle of the large schoolroom. "She neither wept nor blushed, composed, though grave, she stood, the centre mark of all eyes." This astonishes Jane; she would never let anybody treat her like this. Then, again the next day, Helen was punished by being hit with a bundle of twigs, twelve times on the back of her neck. Later that night, Jane finds Helen at the fireplace. Helen feels that Miss Scratchard is severe, because she dislikes her faults, but not cruel, which astonishes Jane. " If I were in your place I should dislike her: I should resist her; if she struck me with that rod, I should get it from her hand; I should break it under her nose." Helen is astonished by Jane's passion and simply replies, " It is far better to endure patiently a smart which nobody feels but yourself, than to commit a hasty action whose evil consequences will extend to all connected with you- and besides, the bible bids us return good for evil." This viewpoint tells us that Helen is a religious person and believes that Jane's passionate feelings are wrong.

Join now!

Helen teaches Jane to control her passion and gives her courage to be brave. On one occasion Mr. Brocklehurst comes to the school and Jane is made to stand on a high stool in the centre of the room, while Mr. Brocklehurst tells everyone to avoid her company, because she is a 'LIAR!' She could not bear the shame of this, she is looking for a new start at Lowood, where she will be valued and treated as an equal, but now everyone has been told to: "shun her from your converse." While Jane was standing on the stool one ...

This is a preview of the whole essay