• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Journey's End - Compare and contrast Osborne, Stanhope and Raleigh as people and as soldiers.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Journey's End 2. Compare and contrast Osborne, Stanhope and Raleigh as people and as soldiers. In the play we learn very little of Dennis Stanhope's character as a man and much more of his character as a soldier. One reason for this is that he is the Commander of Infantry Company C and so always has to appear strong, composed and in charge. He feels that he must be very dedicated to his work and present a stern but fair front to the rest of the men. It is important for him to do this as he has only been a commander for a year and is relatively young, as he is just 21 years old. Another reason why we see very little of his character as just a man is that he has been fighting in the war for a long time "Nearly three years. He came out straight from school- when he was eighteen." This has hardened him and he is much more used to the war as an everyday reality, and because of this he has found ways to cope with the stress and horror of war. He uses drink to forget about his life at home and the atrocious war going on around him. He relies on drink a lot and he drinks most of the six bottle of whisky they brought with them in just three days." ...read more.

Middle

which does not suggest that he is filled with enthusiasm or that he is grateful that he has been chosen to lead the raid. Instead of reacting in the way that Raleigh did, Osborne tries not to talk about the raid and he orders Trotter not to mention the danger of it to Raleigh, "There's no need to tell him it's murder". His reaction to Osborne's death shows how young and inexperienced he is at witnessing death unlike Stanhope to whom death is almost too familiar. He is appalled at how Stanhope, Trotter and Hibbert sat down after Osborne's death and: smoked the cigars, drank the champagne and ate the fresh chicken, which had been sent up specially to celebrate a successful raid. All he can think of is how could he "sit down and eat that- when- when Osborne's- lying- out there." He soon realises how much this statement hurts Stanhope and how close he and Osborne were. He also understands that there is a" limit to what a man can bear" and that you must accept death and move on in these circumstances. Although he hasn't been there for a very long time he is already respected by the other officers Trotter comments, " 'E's got pluck. Strong lad, too-the way he came back through the smoke after that raid, carrying that boche under 'is arm like a baby." Also earlier in the play Osborne remarks that" He's a good-looking youngster. ...read more.

Conclusion

However, unlike Stanhope he can cope with the war without having to be supported by crutches like alcohol and his nerves have remained much more in tact than Stanhope's. He realises the reality that the raid they are asked to go on is a suicide mission and that he is unlikely to return. Before he leaves he asks Stanhope if he would mind looking after a few thing to send to his wife if he is not able to return from the raid: " I say, don't think I'm being morbid, or anything like that, but would you mind taking these?" He is the most supporting officer, as before the raid he tries to reassure Raleigh by saying, " I'm glad it's you and I- together, Raleigh" and he is loyal to the end of his life as he was killed by a hand grenade while he was waiting for Raleigh. After considering all three characters I feel that Osborne's calmness and wisdom strongly compliments Raleigh's enthusiasm and energy. Stanhope appears to balance the situation with his bold character. He organises Osborne, Raleigh and the other officers to the best of his ability but as a result he needs Osborne to support him through difficult circumstances. Raleigh respects and looks up to Stanhope and Osborne and learns how to deal with war through them. I found that the three characters work well together in the play and they keep the audience interested and involved at all times. Zara Lightowler 3 4 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE RC Sheriff section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE RC Sheriff essays

  1. Act one of Journey's End.

    But they were not home by Christmas and for four years women and children back home had to support themselves without no men, apart from the 'cowards' who were shunned by society for not going to war and many were given white feathers to symbolise their cowardice.

  2. Compare and Contrast the Presentation of the Psychological Effects of the WarAnd the Setting ...

    the War has caused him to isolate himself and his feelings from those at home whom he used to feel close to, namely his sister, Beth. Contrary to Sherriff, Hill initially introduces Hilliard as a man who, despite engaging in conversation with other men, does not confide in anyone as

  1. Journey's End

    Hardy, the plays "narrator" is someone who tries to avoid responsibility despite being a captain. Osborne: Come along. Finish handing over and stop blithering Hardy: There's nothing else to do. Osborne: What about the log-book? Hardy: God! You are a worker!

  2. Explain what Osborne means to Stanhope and how is this shown in the play

    has a great respect for Osborne, even though he may not openly admit it. When they arrive at the dugout, Stanhope is offered the better bed by Osborne. ; However, he refuses it on the grounds that Osborne "must have a little comfort in [his] old age".

  1. Journeys End Drama Studies

    The only possible reasoning I can think of for Stanhopes behaviour is that Stanhope wants her to think good of him, or that she wouldn't think Stanhope very brave or courageous. This brings me to the very important aspect of Stanhopes character which is repeated throughout the play.

  2. Journeys End Coursework

    The director could develop the horror of this scene on the screen by making the sounds of distant guns and explosions a but more prominent, almost as if Hibbert is getting more and more scared as the attack draws closer.

  1. Discuss how R.C.Sherriff manages to describe the horrific effects of war on different soldiers ...

    doesn?t want to die in the front line, he says "I shall die of this pain if I don't go!", this quote connotes that he is a cowered, but he shows how nervously and furiously talking to his commander.

  2. Explore Raleigh and Stanhopes relationship and compare their characters

    During Act Three, Stanhope again shouts at Raleigh only because he ate with the men up in the trenches ?you eat the men?s rations when there?s barely enough for each man?? this suggests that Stanhope finds whatever opportunity to throw a tantrum, Raleigh on the other hand during this incident

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work