• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Justice and the Law in A View from the Bridge

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss the ways in which Arthur Miller writes about justice and the limitations of the law in his play, A View from the Bridge Justice can be defined as the quality of treating others fairly and reasonably, whereas law can be defined as rules and regulations set out and enforced by the authorities of a state. Those authorities, who developed the legal statutes, see it as pure and total justice. But justice can vary through the minds of different people, coming from different communities, as people are subject to different cultures and traditions, where what is considered 'right' or 'just' may be very different to that in other places. Conflicts between the American legal system and the Italian-Sicilian traditions of the Red Hook community of Brooklyn are clear in many places in the play, A View from the Bridge, and Arthur Miller makes use of these conflicts to form a major theme in the play of 'Justice vs. The Law.' Miller once said that he wanted to make the modern equivalent of a Greek Tragedy. ...read more.

Middle

And also why Eddie and Beatrice have agreed to give them a place to stay, as it is an action of justice and honour towards our own family: 'It's an honour, B.' (page 17). As the play goes on, the characters, particularly Eddie, feel there are many holes in the US legal system; Eddie expects there to be laws that prevent Rodolpho from marrying his niece, Catherine. 'You have no recourse with the law, Eddie.' (page 47). Eddie feels that there are certain characteristics of Rodolpho, his singing, cooking and dressmaking in particular, that make Rodolpho 'not right' (page 46). And by 'right', he may also be referring to the idea that it is not morally right or just. But as Eddie finds out, there is no law related to these situations and incidents, and Eddie feels that the law, in this situation, is not just. This is strongly linked with a phrase of Alfieri: 'we settle for half, and I like it better.' (page 12 - prologue; and also a very similar phrase in page 85 - epilogue). ...read more.

Conclusion

It is as if killing him would restore the balance of justice in their lives. As Alfieri would say, Marco has to settle for half, and abide by the law of not killing Eddie, although it is wrong in terms of his culture, traditions and background. This scene displays a lot of the conflicts between the Italian traditions of justice and the American legal system. Perhaps Miller is saying that legal systems do not bring about total justice, as they too were formed by humans with different ideas about justice, and not formed by God. So American law is not entirely right. In conclusion, it seems as though Miller does not believe in total justice on earth, and that no humans can ever have fully understand what justice is. He also forms ideas on how one's own personal ideas of justice can never really be formed, and we have to make a compromise between what is right and what we are allowed to do, thus negotiating between justice and law. Miller seems to be explaining limitations in the law as differences between cultures and their beliefs of total justice. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. Examine the Ideas of Manliness, Hostility and Aggression in 'A View from the Bridge'. ...

    For example Catherine says to Eddie, we wasn't goin' and Beatrice uses wanna several times. This indicates the similarity to Eddie's syntax. Marco speaks relatively little throughout Act One and through most of Act Two. Miller tries to show the audience that Marco finds it hard to understand and speak English as fluently as Rodolpho.

  2. A View From the Bridge - The whole of this play involves symbolism, on ...

    She feels frustrated that Eddie doesn't like him '(sobbing) I don't believe it and I wish to hell you'd stop it.' Eddie feels that he has parted from her 'I don't see you no more I come home you're

  1. Analyse the themes of law and codes of justice in A View from a ...

    Eddie is very protective of Catherine and loves her very much. However, is Eddie being protective because he thinks that Rodolfo is unsuitable or is it because Eddie is jealous of him. Sexual jealousy would account for why Eddie strongly feels that Rodolfo has broken the unwritten code, by being

  2. Discuss the view that when Miller wrote the 'A View from the Bridge', he ...

    She does however, tries to defend the pair by telling the Officers of the difficulties they go through in Italy, and that they are doing no harm. This protective behaviour is a complete contrast of her views on law in Act One.

  1. Examine the theme of justice in the play "A View from the bridge"

    The unease with which two of the pitchers great Alfieri at the beginning of the play clearly shows how unwelcome corporate federal law is to the society. Also the way people uneasily nod at him shows they see him as a bad omen "you see how uneasily they nod at

  2. At The End Of “A View From The Bridge,” Is The Audience Likely To ...

    It is this ability to "let himself be known" as he dies that prompts Alfieri to mourn him even though he knew "how wrong he was." The closing lines of this play are gripping and present us with the opportunity to decide whether we "settle for half" most of the time or are "ourselves purely" though not "purely good."

  1. How does Miller present ideas about justice and the law in A View from ...

    is too black-and-white to be effective, and that because of that, justice is out of their power.

  2. "A View From the Bridge". The main themes in this play are justice and ...

    Their view of Vinny is one of disgust, as betrayal is the most dishonorable thing a person can commit. There is also irony in Eddie's doing exactly the same thing of which he has spoken with such horror making him a hypocrite.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work