• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Looking closely at Pygmalion, consider the relationship between Higgins and Eliza. Where do your sympathies lie?

Extracts from this document...


Looking closely at Pygmalion, consider the relationship between Higgins and Eliza. Where do your sympathies lie? In the play Pygmalion, my sympathies change between the two characters Higgins and Eliza, as the play progresses. Eliza seems the more likely of the two to feel sorry for because she is without money and was brought up in filth. At some points during the action we do tend to sympathise for Higgins because of what he is going through and sometimes the stress of teaching a lower class girl gets the better of him. In Act1, at Covent Garden outside St Paul's Church my sympathies are for Eliza as she is grovelling in the rain for money. She clearly is poor and is dressed in dirty clothes as well as not having had a wash. When her flowers are knocked out of her hands by Freddy and trodden into the mud, she is deeply annoyed as it is her only means of living and without selling the flowers (which are now destroyed) she does not have much chance to have a bed to sleep on: "...eed now bettern to spawl a pore gel's flahrzen than ran awy like that athaht pyin." When the mother kindly offers to pay for the flowers, Eliza is pleased that she now has more money than they were worth: "Thank you kindly, lady."(page11). ...read more.


When Eliza offers Higgins money for the lessons, he starts to be a bit careless and calculates the offer, related to what a millionaire would pay him when he full well knows that she will not be able to pay. He is just trying to test her resistance: "Two-fifths of a millionaire's income for a day would be somewhere about �60."(p28). This starts off the bet which Higgins cannot resist and leads onto the garden party which Eliza begins to be very pleased but worried about. At times Higgins can be careless although Eliza thinks he is being very harsh. Sometimes when Eliza is being unreasonable Higgins will be strict towards her: "If she causes you any trouble, wallop her."(p30). I think that most of the time during the scene Higgins is being unfair to Eliza and not giving her much of a chance to speak out although he is testing her for her patience and strength of character. In Act 4, Higgins and Eliza argue when they return from the Embassy. Higgins was speaking across Eliza to Pickering, who for once in the play was ignoring Eliza which is bound to test her patience and will cause us to have some feelings for her. Eliza gets extremely irritated when Higgins is being so rude that she shouts back at him but Higgins takes in none of what she says and cannot see her point of view. ...read more.


Higgins admits that she has a finer ear than him. He laughed nervously when she said she would teach phonetics because he knows she is good at it: "Ha! ha! ha!"(p104). All the way through the scene Eliza is getting her own back on Higgins. He likes this as it shows she can stand up for herself although she is not going to go back to Wimpole Street and he is on the losing end of an argument. I don't feel sorry for Eliza as she can stand up for herself and Higgins is getting what he deserves. Eliza gets a clever answer to Higgins cheeky order at the end of the play which we admire. At the end of the play, Eliza gets my vote for sympathy as she is under Higgins wrath for most of the action. Only a few times do I feel sorry for Higgins when he is working hard to teach Eliza the tricks of the trade. At the end, I think Higgins regrets letting Eliza go as he becomes quite fond of her. Overall though Eliza has started from so low and reached great potential that she never realised she could because she never had a chance that she deserved so much from this. Eventually Eliza has what she wants; a decent life. ?? ?? ?? ?? David Rankin The Relationship between Higgins and Eliza.doc 1,358 words 15/03/2009 Page 1 of 3 GCSE English ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Authors essays

  1. How does Ayub Khan-Din portray conflict in the play East is East

    'I am your father, you are my son, you do as I say, bass.' That's not fucking trust". Tariq said this quote when he expressed his emotions about his father. He believes that George will never really care about his kids, but that George only wants them to do as they are told in order to make him happy.

  2. How does Shaw draw the audience's attention to issues of social class in Act ...

    Bernard Shaw described the Fabian Society as seeking "-to establish equality as the universal relation between citizens without distinction of sex, colour, occupation, age, talent, character, hereditary or what not..." which was the same message he put out to the world via Pygmalion.

  1. Ralph says "Things are breaking up I don't understand why. We began well. We ...

    This shows that there is an evil in all of us, which is what Golding is trying to say throughout the novel. After Ralph and Piggy realise that the dance fuelled the murder of Simon they deny any involvement in it.

  2. What do we learn of Shaw's attitude towards class from "Pygmalion" ?

    The Eynsford Hill's and Higgins' treatment of Eliza show the prejudices that Shaw say towards the lower classes from the middle and upper classes. Clara Eynsford-Hill treats Eliza with contempt, "make her give you the change.

  1. What Do The Audience Learn About Sheila Birling In Act 1?

    The hand gestures she makes are clearly nervous as she is trying to justify her actions. The next part of the speech, "She was the right type for it, just as I was the wrong type" is significant because to make it seem like it was inevitable she laughs nervously after saying 'she was the right type for it.'

  2. Discuss the relationship between Frank and Rita in Educating Rita how does it change ...

    Rita's constant swearing and rude language is different from the language and manners of the other students making her different and more appealing to her tutor Frank as he sees her as original.

  1. How does Mary Shelley challenge and unsettle the reader of Frankenstein?

    There were many deaths in her early life, the first being the death of her mother 10 days after Shelley's own birth. This directly links to the amount of deaths in the novel itself. Shelley's son was called William, he died age 3 of malaria.

  2. Discuss the meeting of Stanley and Mompesson in Act 1. Consider it's dramatic effectiveness ...

    in the future, if the plague is the "beating" that Stanley and Mompesson require to mix. Stanley leaves suddenly and dramatically and the exchange is over. It was formal, the language and the way they acted towards each other, because even though the play is modern the language had to reflect the time.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work