Macbeth: Hero or Villian?

Authors Avatar

Mrs Little – English Coursework February 2006

Macbeth: hero or villain?

The theme of Macbeth that I have chosen to explore is “Macbeth: hero or villain?”    The question demands a decision on whether Macbeth is a villain, (as most people assume when reading the play), or is he in fact the misguided hero of the piece, one whose actions are misinterpreted.  I intend to prove that he is the latter of these two, a misunderstood hero; a tragic hero.  

I feel Macbeth falls into the category of tragic hero, the definition of which can be defined as:

“an honourable protagonist with a tragic flaw, also known as a fatal flaw, which eventually leads to his demise.”

Macbeth, at the outset of the play is portrayed as a good and brave soldier who has the respect of all who fight with him, an example of this is shown in Act 1 scene 2 where a captain reports:

“For brave Macbeth (well he deserves that name), disdaining fortune, with his brandished steel, which smoked with bloody execution, like valour’s minion…”

This demonstrates the respect for Macbeth that was held not only by this soldier but of the army, it also highlights that the man felt that Macbeth was brave as it uses the term “valour’s minion” a literal interpretation of which is that Macbeth is a servant to courage.  

King Duncan trusts Macbeth and is amazed by his talents and courage on the battle field; this is shown when in Act 1 scene 2 he says:

“O valiant cousin!  Worthy gentleman!”

In this exclamation he refers to Macbeth as “valiant cousin” this might suggest that Macbeth is related to him in some way but is more likely to be a way of showing his delight in Macbeth as he is linking him to royalty.  It appears that Duncan sees Macbeth as a great noble as when he says: (Act 1 scene 4)

“would thou hadst less deserved…more is thy due than more than I can pay”

In this he is saying that Macbeth is an extremely deserving man whom he can never fully repay for his great services.  Duncan refers to Macbeth as a tree which he hopes to cultivate, he wants to give further rewards and promotions, and this is shown in Act 1 Scene 4:

Join now!

“I have begun to plant thee…”

However Macbeth begins to turn form the path of a typical hero when he starts to let his main flaw, ambition, overrule his loyalty, this is first made evident to the reader when after the witches have called him king of Scotland he says: (Act 1 Scene 3)

“would they have stayed!”

We can gauge from this that instead of being alarmed at the thought of his King’s death Macbeth, instead wants to hear more of what the witches have to say for him, it is almost as if he wishes them to ...

This is a preview of the whole essay