Malcolm calls Macbeth a

Authors Avatar

Malcolm calls Macbeth a “Dead Butcher”. Can he possibly be a tragic hero?

Macbeth is an intriguing story of witchcraft, murder and retribution that can also be seen as a study in the philosophy and psychology of evil.

Shakespeare sees deliberately to have drained colour away from some parts of his composition in order to concentrate attention on Macbeth and His wife. As Stanley Wells writes “It is Macbeth’s neurotic self absorption, his fear, his anger and his despair, along with his wife’s steely determination, her invoking of the powers of evil” that are the main focus of his attention.

Malcolm calls Macbeth a “dead butcher for the simple reason that he is guilty of murdering Duncan, and ordering the deaths of Banquo, Lady Macduff and her sons.

Shakespeare allows the audience into the mind of Macbeth, in doing so the audience have a clear idea of Macbeth’s motives and intentions. The audience is allowed to witness Macbeth’s conscience that will eventually destroy him. Soliloquies are a vital factor in doing this. A splendid example of one of Macbeth’s early soliloquies is in act 1 scene 3 where Macbeth recognises his new status as “Thane of Cawdor”.

Malcolm obviously doesn’t see and hear what the audience, therefore he has no reason other than to see Macbeth as a “tyrant” and a “villain”.

Join now!

At the beginning of the play, Macbeth is very much considered a gallant “hero” and “full so valiant”. This is a result of the brave and heroic efforts during the conflict with the Norwegians. Macbeth is rewarded for this by being awarded “Thane Of Cawdor”. Macbeth informs Lady Macbeth of his newly acquired status, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth recognise that Macbeth is “King that shalt be”, and they are not “ignorant of what greatness is promised”. It is in fact the witches who prophesise the rise of Macbeth, and they offer him security throughout the play, claiming “no man, of ...

This is a preview of the whole essay