• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Male Representation in the Two Film Versions of the Play 'Romeo & Juliet'

Extracts from this document...


Male Representation in the Two Film Versions of the Play 'Romeo & Juliet' The Opening The opening of both versions of this piece sets the president for what follows, the Luhrman version perhaps more so than Franco Zefferelli's attempt. They display glimpses of what is to come, drawing the viewer deeper into the story. The amalgamation of multiple 'Big Close Ups' and bird's eye shot, as well as the incorporation of a masterful music score, serve to create a genius piece of cinematic production for the opening scene. Not only that, but the scenes presented in the shots are chosen specifically to give an uninformed viewer an insight into the turbulent nature of this story; to settle any misgivings the audience may have at the mention of Shakespeare. A male viewer would certainly breath a sigh of relief at the sign of someone getting shot at. Luhrman has chosen to include the Chorus, a popular theatrical device of the Shakespearian era taken from famous Greek tragedies, in the form of a newsreader from a news program, which is an image very familiar to the intended audience. The Chorus uses the original text, superimposed over flashes of gangland violence, to create a subtext that becomes embossed on the viewer's interpretation of the rest of the film. As opening sequences go, this one could be considered a masterpiece of modern cinema. Franco Zefferelli has not invested as much importance in the opening of his production. He has instead decided to go with a theme to suit the mode of his film. ...read more.


The fight seems to be a parody of a Western, with bullets bouncing off metallic objects at humorous moments. Tybalt's appearance tilts the fight into an altogether more frightening prospect. He seems to delight in the bloodshed, not merely accepting is at a part of life as his counterparts do. The deliberate ignition of the petrol fire is evidence of his psychotic nature. The token movie bad guy, it would seem. Compared to that potential bloodbath Zefferelli's fight scene appears almost friendly. The two families embark on a sword fight after a similar, although less heated, exchange. The fight may not be as action packed as the previous version, but is no less amusing as we see the whole fight moving into the courtyard, where everyone in the picture has their swords drawn and brawling amongst themselves in a genial sort of way. The camera work is much less sophisticated, with most of the shots being provided from the horizontal axis, which rules out any close-ups. The two families in this version seem calm and composed and the rivalry doesn't seem to be as serious or intense as we see in the Luhrman version. The calm music does not add to the impression of a serious rivalry; more an afternoon of sport. At the climax of the violence Zefferelli has the Prince riding in on a horse (which is accurate in that he would enforce the law at the time that the play was written) ...read more.


The Luhrman version effectively harnesses the power of pathetic fallacy in the form of rain pouring from the heavens, framing Romeo's tortured expression. A deadly mixture of pain, anger, suffering and rage pass across his delicate features as all his sorrows boil in the cocotte of his soul. Without sounding too chauvinistic and stereotypically male, I found the Zefferelli version of this play tediously artsy and lacking in appeal. I realise that I don't fall into the target audience for this production, which is probably why I found watching it decidedly painful and confusing. The acting was impossibly wooden and lacking in emotion, the camera work was terrible and the score was almost identical throughout; far too heavy on the mandolin. By comparison the Luhrman version was pure genius. Despite it not being one of my all-time favourite films I still found is a pleasure to watch. The production was outstanding, as you would expect from a film with such a big budget, and the star-studded cast provides some of the most critically acclaimed performances of their careers. The multitude of gunfights, car chases, explosions and brutal murders also lifted my esteem for this film high above its tawdry counterpart. The film has been penned, directed and edited to appeal the people of my generation, and I feel that it does just that. It may not contain the scripted values of the original text, but it packages the tale of love, loss and tragedy that is Romeo and Juliet into something altogether easier to comprehend. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Comparing two versions of Romeo & Juliet (Zefferelli and Baz Luhram).

    The camera follows Juliets every movements well and is showing that things are very chaotic in a way, following Juliet up the stairs, through the hall way, past the balcony, rushing around, maybe showing us a sign of things to come.

  2. Is Shakespeare's portrayal of a patriarchal Veronaironic and subversive, or is the play an ...

    Another example of patriarchy being subverted is found when Lady Capulet threatens to put Capulet under surveillance: Ay, you have been a mouse- hunt in your time, / But I will watch from such a watching now. (Act 4 Scene 4 line 11-12)

  1. In this essay I shall be discussing the differences and similarities between two film ...

    This scene consists of the parents crying, the police cars, the increasing noise of the helicopters, and the rain. It is tension creating, suspenseful and dramatic, Baz chose to take a totally different approach to Zeffirelli and was brave in doing so, he was also very successful.

  2. A Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet.

    His expression was inaccurate and needed more emotion. I think that by having the crowd laughing so much, the atmosphere and seriousness of the matter was spoilt and it was an unrealistic reaction. In the new film, Mercutio started off by pretending the wound was just a scratch, but he then became angry and serious.

  1. The Generation Gap:comparing the starts of two film versions of Romeo and Juliet

    When Juliet awakens from her sleep she discovers that Romeo has swallowed poison and is dying. The main difference lies in the fact that we are led to believe that maybe he will see her awake before he drinks poison.

  2. Compare two film versions of Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet.

    Whereas in Zeffirelli's version when Romeo comes the audience hear soft, float music to that he is dreaming and not seeing the true light. But in this version Zeffirelli has chosen to cut out the part when Romeo speaks in oxymoron's, but to show this he has chosen to show Romeo lying down to tell the audience of the heaviness.

  1. Romeo and Juliet theatre production essay.

    For example at the beginning of Henry V, the chorus says the theatre relies more on the "imaginary forces" of the audience than on the realistic effects. This would apply to this scene, as the audience were in direct contact with the actors and would consequently have been dragged into

  2. Compare two film versions of Romeo and Juliet.

    Both films show this well as Benvolio tries to be diplomatic during the brawl at the market place and petrol station. The Prince in Zefferelli is the official authority of Verona but Luhrmann had to adapt this idea of a monarchy being in control, as many countries are no longer run by a monarchy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work